David, John, and Marilyn recap Season 3, Episode 3 of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power on Prime Video. They discuss redemption arcs, moral infallibility in storytelling, and how to remedy a slow burn misstep.
Contact Us
Questions or comments? Visit us at our website where you can use the contact form or use the voicemail feature. Or, send an email to lotr@thelorehounds.com
Sign up for the One-Time Rings of Power Season Pass:
Links to Patreon, Supercast, Discord, and Network Affiliates
Any opinions stated are ours personally and do not reflect the opinion of or belong to any employers or other entities.
Our Sponsors:
* Check out Uncommon Goods and use the code uncommongoods.com/LOREHOUNDS for a great deal: https://www.uncommongoods.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
00:21 --> 00:27 [UNKNOWN]: Welcome to the Rings of Power Podcast where the Lord hounds your guides to Tolkien's world of Middle-earth.
00:27 --> 00:33 [UNKNOWN]: I'm your host John, and with me are my fellow Lord Hounds David and Marilyn, our favorite Tolkien scholar.
00:34 --> 00:40 [UNKNOWN]: And this is our coverage of Prime Video's original series, the Lord of the Rings, the Rings of Power.
00:41 --> 00:44 [UNKNOWN]: Season 3, Episode 3, The Secret Fire,
00:45 --> 00:52 [UNKNOWN]: In this podcast, we're going to start off with our hot takes and then we're going to get into a detailed scene by scene breakdown of the episode.
01:07 --> 01:10 [UNKNOWN]: And we're running a season pass for this season.
01:10 --> 01:16 [UNKNOWN]: And we'll talk about that with some more details after we go through our hot takes for the episode.
01:17 --> 01:17 [UNKNOWN]: Wait, we are?
01:17 --> 01:20 [UNKNOWN]: I don't want to tell me about that.
01:23 --> 01:25 [UNKNOWN]: The man who invented the format himself.
01:25 --> 01:27 [UNKNOWN]: No, Dave, it was David's idea.
01:27 --> 01:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to give David credit for that.
01:29 --> 01:29 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, OK.
01:29 --> 01:30 [UNKNOWN]: It was a very good idea.
01:30 --> 01:35 [UNKNOWN]: So it's excellent at putting it all together and turning it alive on your net.
01:36 --> 01:38 [UNKNOWN]: I'm the execution guy, you know?
01:38 --> 01:38 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yes.
01:38 --> 01:40 [UNKNOWN]: That's why there's a big black axel in your back wall.
01:42 --> 01:43 [UNKNOWN]: No, that's just a rough road.
01:44 --> 01:45 [UNKNOWN]: That's just Frodo Lisa back.
01:45 --> 01:47 [UNKNOWN]: I do have your photos out.
01:48 --> 01:50 [UNKNOWN]: You have the photo Lisa on my wall now.
01:50 --> 01:53 [UNKNOWN]: It is a picture of Frodo Baggins as the Bonalisa.
01:55 --> 01:59 [UNKNOWN]: But as Marilyn pointed out, so cleverly, the ring is in the wrong place.
01:59 --> 02:00 [UNKNOWN]: He's wearing the ring.
02:00 --> 02:06 [UNKNOWN]: And so if he was wearing the ring, we'd actually not see him, which I think is a brilliant take.
02:06 --> 02:07 [UNKNOWN]: I love that.
02:07 --> 02:08 [UNKNOWN]: That is just so.
02:09 --> 02:11 [UNKNOWN]: Tolkienian, yeah, Tolkien lore expert.
02:11 --> 02:13 [UNKNOWN]: Well, it was nice to have appreciated.
02:14 --> 02:15 [UNKNOWN]: We haven't gotten to that ring yet.
02:15 --> 02:18 [UNKNOWN]: So let's keep going so that we can get to it.
02:18 --> 02:19 [UNKNOWN]: We were trying to forge that ring.
02:19 --> 02:20 [UNKNOWN]: I heard it.
02:20 --> 02:22 [UNKNOWN]: What did everybody think of the episode, Marilyn?
02:23 --> 02:30 [UNKNOWN]: Well, just as an aside, the release schedule is making me feel like if it's Tuesday, then this must be Belgium.
02:31 --> 02:37 [UNKNOWN]: That is a very old reference, very few listeners who are not movers will recognize it.
02:37 --> 02:38 [UNKNOWN]: But, um,
02:39 --> 02:41 [UNKNOWN]: It's a name of the film, I think, from the 60s.
02:41 --> 02:41 [UNKNOWN]: But I believe you.
02:42 --> 02:45 [UNKNOWN]: It conveys that same sense of where am I with days?
02:45 --> 02:46 [UNKNOWN]: What episode am I on here?
02:46 --> 02:48 [UNKNOWN]: What do I have to watch, et cetera, et cetera?
02:49 --> 02:53 [UNKNOWN]: Um, episode three was an okay episode.
02:53 --> 02:58 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's offered a bit from following episode two, because episode two was so powerful.
02:58 --> 02:59 [UNKNOWN]: And it's so powerful.
02:59 --> 02:59 [UNKNOWN]: But
03:00 --> 03:09 [UNKNOWN]: As I was doing my review, I did find some things that I really liked a lot, and so I'll have more to say on those things.
03:10 --> 03:14 [UNKNOWN]: But, Goli, they're still just leaning to heavily on the PJ crutch.
03:15 --> 03:23 [UNKNOWN]: You know, there was one whole plot line that I just wish they didn't do that, but, you know, whatever.
03:24 --> 03:27 [UNKNOWN]: And they're still dangling the mystery of Theo before us, so.
03:28 --> 03:30 [UNKNOWN]: We shall see what transpires.
03:31 --> 03:32 [UNKNOWN]: What about you, David?
03:32 --> 03:39 [UNKNOWN]: Well, yeah, this was my least favorite episode so far.
03:39 --> 03:45 [UNKNOWN]: I felt it was a real stumble coming in from one and two, which I really enjoyed.
03:46 --> 03:57 [UNKNOWN]: The Sauron story continues to be, I think some of the most interesting stuff that they are doing in this series in Charlie Vickers is I'm just eating it up every time he's on screen.
03:58 --> 04:06 [UNKNOWN]: Lots of great lore things too, like they're back feeling a bunch of cool lore things around Sauron and Bardor and all kinds of stuff.
04:07 --> 04:09 [UNKNOWN]: The runes scenes were just really hard for me to watch.
04:09 --> 04:18 [UNKNOWN]: The production quality, just it felt like they were on a sound stage with a map painting of the thing in the back.
04:19 --> 04:21 [UNKNOWN]: the acting felt kind of really wouldn't.
04:22 --> 04:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not really sure about how they're doing the lore.
04:25 --> 04:28 [UNKNOWN]: I just don't know if I like Tom Bombadillo on secret squirrel missions.
04:29 --> 04:39 [UNKNOWN]: He was just, it just didn't click for me and that was really kind of disappointing and then the Allendeel and Anaryon.
04:39 --> 04:40 [UNKNOWN]: Anaryon's great.
04:40 --> 04:44 [UNKNOWN]: I'm really like glad that we got him finally on screen and he seems like a
04:44 --> 04:55 [UNKNOWN]: Cool guy, and you know, I do enjoy the good father and son's story, but some real like just really bad spycraft.
04:56 --> 05:02 [UNKNOWN]: here on their part, I dives sharp criticism for how they run their operations.
05:03 --> 05:04 [UNKNOWN]: But we can talk about what we get there.
05:05 --> 05:10 [UNKNOWN]: I did like, I do like what they're doing with the maps and the zooming around middle earth.
05:10 --> 05:17 [UNKNOWN]: I think that's a cool way of coming up and out and then we get a map and then we like move over the map and then the we zoom in on a location.
05:17 --> 05:19 [UNKNOWN]: I thought that's very clever.
05:19 --> 05:24 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm developing this interesting love hate, not hate is too strong of a word.
05:25 --> 05:30 [UNKNOWN]: But uh, uh, wow, I really love what they're doing in this scene or with these characters.
05:30 --> 05:33 [UNKNOWN]: And then I'll have these just real, like, big face palm moments.
05:33 --> 05:38 [UNKNOWN]: Like, oh my god, I can't believe this is what they're doing with this, particularly thinking.
05:38 --> 05:42 [UNKNOWN]: But then it did it will, um, you know, redeem itself in the next scene after.
05:43 --> 05:48 [UNKNOWN]: or the characters will later on redeem themselves in some way, so it's really interesting.
05:48 --> 05:49 [UNKNOWN]: I'm having a good time.
05:49 --> 05:50 [UNKNOWN]: I'm enjoying it.
05:50 --> 05:58 [UNKNOWN]: I wouldn't want to be anywhere else right now, but that's not going to stop me from shooting a few arrows at the screen when the probe.
05:58 --> 06:00 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I hope you shoot better than Isiel Dirk.
06:00 --> 06:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, for sure.
06:04 --> 06:04 [UNKNOWN]: John.
06:05 --> 06:07 [UNKNOWN]: I would also say this is my least favorite episode.
06:07 --> 06:13 [UNKNOWN]: I, you know, and not a bad episode, like I still am enjoying the show to be clear.
06:15 --> 06:21 [UNKNOWN]: I just think that they really are doing some lazy writing in the last video in this episode.
06:23 --> 06:25 [UNKNOWN]: There's a lot of comedy of error stuff going
06:31 --> 06:36 [UNKNOWN]: just about to come to the conclusion that you need to, and then you just don't.
06:37 --> 06:49 [UNKNOWN]: And yeah, like the way that some of the characters are acting feels very hand over the writer feels very much like you are trying to force this situation to happen rather than with the characters do with the characters want to do.
06:51 --> 06:53 [UNKNOWN]: That said, it's a visual spectacle.
06:54 --> 07:04 [UNKNOWN]: I enjoyed scoring a lot of internet points in that secret fire scene and like I'm mountain of Do you hear that be that's a truck pulling up into my driveway?
07:05 --> 07:09 [UNKNOWN]: Drop off my internet points, but we'll get to that.
07:09 --> 07:18 [UNKNOWN]: But you know, I again, this was a fun episode, but this was a more turn your brain off episode than the first two, which I thought were both enjoyable and
07:20 --> 07:22 [UNKNOWN]: had richness to it, had some meat to it.
07:22 --> 07:29 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm hoping that as we go forward in the season, the rest of the season is more like episodes one and two, at less like this episode.
07:30 --> 07:36 [UNKNOWN]: Well, what I want to know is why does John get a truckload of presumably heavy internet points?
07:37 --> 07:38 [UNKNOWN]: He's got an audio clip.
07:38 --> 07:39 [UNKNOWN]: When?
07:39 --> 07:41 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I got was a lousy bolisterial.
07:42 --> 07:43 [UNKNOWN]: Why not, Bill?
07:47 --> 07:52 [UNKNOWN]: I think there it is, it's parody, compounding interest on this particular one.
07:52 --> 07:53 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, you're right.
07:53 --> 08:10 [UNKNOWN]: When that he's got that goes way back, but he's got a, I heard him rummaging around in the Lorhound's closet, and there was like, okay, like kissing things and boots flying out and, you know, ran a kaleidoscope came, zipping out of there, I had to talk pretty fast.
08:10 --> 08:13 [UNKNOWN]: That's an inside joke for that was our second podcast coverage goal.
08:13 --> 08:14 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
08:14 --> 08:14 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
08:16 --> 08:20 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was our first dog though we were like let's let's just podcast one more show and then
08:29 --> 08:32 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, we hit like something out of it was it was painful.
08:32 --> 08:33 [UNKNOWN]: Oh dear.
08:33 --> 08:34 [UNKNOWN]: Oh dear.
08:34 --> 08:39 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, uh, I heard him runging around and I think he's going to, he's going to rub it in our faces.
08:39 --> 08:41 [UNKNOWN]: I had to go back to August 22nd, 2022.
08:42 --> 08:43 [UNKNOWN]: I'm surprised that you have the files.
08:43 --> 08:43 [UNKNOWN]: Wow.
08:44 --> 08:47 [UNKNOWN]: I went on our website where you could find the entire Laura Hounds archive.
08:47 --> 08:48 [UNKNOWN]: Oh.
08:48 --> 08:51 [UNKNOWN]: Certainly.
08:51 --> 08:53 [UNKNOWN]: Do you hear the pride in his voice listeners?
08:53 --> 08:53 [UNKNOWN]: I do.
08:55 --> 09:00 [UNKNOWN]: Well, maybe we should talk about some housekeeping so that we can actually get to the point where he can play the audio.
09:00 --> 09:01 [UNKNOWN]: That was to do it.
09:01 --> 09:06 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, well, I already spoiled my line about if it's Tuesday, it must be Belgium.
09:06 --> 09:06 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
09:07 --> 09:19 [UNKNOWN]: but if you don't recognize it, look it up, you'll see why I used it because this schedule is still bearing down, but we still bear up underneath it.
09:20 --> 09:28 [UNKNOWN]: We've got plans for recording episode 4 very soon and dropping them as soon as possible.
09:29 --> 09:31 [UNKNOWN]: Next week, being Thanksgiving, vacation week,
09:33 --> 09:36 [UNKNOWN]: course be somewhat disrupted because hey, it's vacation time.
09:36 --> 09:37 [UNKNOWN]: We get time off to.
09:38 --> 09:42 [UNKNOWN]: But we'll do our best to, you know, keep turning them out.
09:42 --> 09:49 [UNKNOWN]: And again, we are going to only have a wet episode per episode as it were in terms of coverage.
09:49 --> 09:51 [UNKNOWN]: We're doing a double header this week, right?
09:51 --> 10:01 [UNKNOWN]: So we're doing tonight and tonight, so you'll be getting the first four, we'll finally be done this week and then we're going to move on to five and six which just dropped today the day that we're recording this episode.
10:02 --> 10:09 [UNKNOWN]: And something I've noticed too, like on the just chatter on the discord and watching our download numbers, people are some people are running ahead.
10:09 --> 10:35 [UNKNOWN]: right which we expected but a lot of people are not running ahead on watching the episodes they're banking them and sort of watching them as they have time so I think it's the the right strategy and I heard a lot of people are see it saw a lot of people graciously appreciating the fact that we're doing a one-to-one episode of compressing these so I think we're doing fine and we're still getting posts on all the episodes that are currently built one through six it's
10:37 --> 10:39 [UNKNOWN]: Well, do you see our people talking about six already?
10:39 --> 10:49 [UNKNOWN]: Can some of them are or at least I haven't read it, of course, because I haven't even seen it in five yet, but you know, that it's the line is in bold.
10:49 --> 10:50 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
10:50 --> 10:50 [UNKNOWN]: It's the actual meaning.
10:51 --> 10:51 [UNKNOWN]: One message there.
10:52 --> 10:56 [UNKNOWN]: Well, that's a good segue into talking about our discord.
10:56 --> 10:59 [UNKNOWN]: If you are not on the community discord, you are welcome.
10:59 --> 11:05 [UNKNOWN]: It is available to any one on the internet who would like to swing by.
11:05 --> 11:08 [UNKNOWN]: It's our virtual water cooler for the Laura Hound's community.
11:08 --> 11:22 [UNKNOWN]: We have a whole special channel set up just for rings of power and each episode is siloed into its own little chat area so that you can talk in those channels without worrying about being spoiled so no matter where you are.
11:23 --> 11:30 [UNKNOWN]: There's a lot of conversation that's happening there and there's already there's people probably at the same pace that you're going because everybody's watching at it.
11:38 --> 11:56 [UNKNOWN]: great conversations there, great insights people like just it's really great to see a lot of old friends do that haven't been around for that much haven't been watching some of the other shows that we've been watching but they're they're back for this but it's ever a rule of rule is back hey I saw made an appearance in the general chat, uh, flaming.
11:56 --> 11:59 [UNKNOWN]: He's great for your worship and for your bowels.
12:00 --> 12:01 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
12:01 --> 12:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, good five.
12:01 --> 12:03 [UNKNOWN]: All right, we might bowels out of it.
12:03 --> 12:03 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
12:06 --> 12:23 [UNKNOWN]: That said, for anything that the Lourhounds are covering and all of our affiliate shows, everything from Silo and Alicia on the Worship Dust channel to Johnson's Dungeons do Rags and everything in between, we have a space for the conversation on our due discord.
12:23 --> 12:26 [UNKNOWN]: And we would like to invite you to come join the conversation.
12:27 --> 12:32 [UNKNOWN]: Um, the other thing I want to say really quick is feedback feedback.
12:32 --> 12:36 [UNKNOWN]: Please send us in an email with your feedback.
12:36 --> 12:37 [UNKNOWN]: It's really the best way.
12:37 --> 12:38 [UNKNOWN]: Nancy.
12:38 --> 12:39 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
12:39 --> 12:40 [UNKNOWN]: Nancy, Nancy, Nancy.
12:40 --> 12:41 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
12:41 --> 12:41 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
12:41 --> 12:42 [UNKNOWN]: Hand of the pod.
12:42 --> 12:48 [UNKNOWN]: She is co-lating the feedback for us and putting it into our documents all formatted and ready for us to go.
12:48 --> 12:51 [UNKNOWN]: And Nancy just loves interacting with the fandom.
12:51 --> 12:54 [UNKNOWN]: So send Nancy an email, just send it to LOTR at thelorounds.com.
12:55 --> 13:07 [UNKNOWN]: And Nancy will get it, and she might, you know, probably email with you back and forth a little bit, but it's really the best way to do feedback for this in the easiest way for us to co-related.
13:07 --> 13:09 [UNKNOWN]: Have one ever quick shout out.
13:10 --> 13:31 [UNKNOWN]: to the NAS gals podcast if you have not checked out the NAS gals you should go and do that stop what you're doing right now look it up on NAS gals and stop listening to our podcast point left just cue it cue it for your next podcast fair enough go I'm going to stop you there David and I'm not my supposed to you know cut out now and go what
13:35 --> 13:48 [UNKNOWN]: our dearest own jessica on the discord and her friends northe and rosy have a three-person podcast running and they're doing a episode to episode coverage.
13:48 --> 13:56 [UNKNOWN]: This is the first time that they've been podcasting they started this last summer and I am super enjoying their podcast like
13:58 --> 14:13 [UNKNOWN]: on a big show I will usually listen to one or two other podcasts out in the podcast land you know as a as companion and that's gals is my companion right now and they have some great insights and some great takes they really know their lore and their fun to listen to and they have
14:14 --> 14:18 [UNKNOWN]: They're just very funny and they have a really great logo artwork, great job Rosie.
14:18 --> 14:22 [UNKNOWN]: So, uh, big, for me, big shout out to the NASGALs.
14:22 --> 14:30 [UNKNOWN]: Congratulations, you guys have put together a really great podcast in everybody in the Lawrence community should go, uh, show some love, subscribe, and listen to their episodes.
14:32 --> 14:33 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
14:33 --> 14:33 [UNKNOWN]: That's it for me.
14:34 --> 14:35 [UNKNOWN]: Very good.
14:35 --> 14:36 [UNKNOWN]: Don't forget the season pass.
14:36 --> 14:45 [UNKNOWN]: Season pass available one time cost of 10 bucks and you will get had free episode and bonus content like our lore cast, which we're about to start doing.
14:47 --> 14:47 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
14:48 --> 14:48 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
14:49 --> 14:52 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I had one previous holdover from last episode.
14:53 --> 14:57 [UNKNOWN]: I wanted to talk about nation states in the principles of non-alignment
15:01 --> 15:11 [UNKNOWN]: Aaron Kay, who is one of the hosts of our other affiliates and a co-host of John's on the Cosmere Corner podcast, is actually a in-college studying international relations.
15:12 --> 15:18 [UNKNOWN]: And he said that would send in a voicemail to us talking about all this kind of stuff.
15:18 --> 15:23 [UNKNOWN]: Actually, he's done some coursework actually using hypothetical situations of Middle-Ear Earth Kingdoms.
15:24 --> 15:26 [UNKNOWN]: But I think just Aaron got a little busy maybe this week.
15:26 --> 15:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm guessing I'm just giving some latitude.
15:28 --> 15:30 [UNKNOWN]: So Aaron, get your voice back.
15:30 --> 15:36 [UNKNOWN]: play it, and YouTube can participate in our discussions.
15:37 --> 15:40 [UNKNOWN]: And I had one note to connect with last week's discussion.
15:40 --> 15:53 [UNKNOWN]: We were talking about the whole topic of assassination and was this in being with a faithful, clearly Muriel did not think it was, and others disagreed, but the results were not great.
15:54 --> 15:58 [UNKNOWN]: It reminded me of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who
16:00 --> 16:09 [UNKNOWN]: in Germany, the time of the Rise of Hitler, and he actually formed a plot to assassinate Hitler.
16:10 --> 16:13 [UNKNOWN]: It failed, and he was jailed and eventually executed.
16:13 --> 16:27 [UNKNOWN]: So it's the sort of thing that, you know, people of faith will wrestle with, and that this whole question of, you know, the moral goods and how do you weigh them and evaluate them as a Christian minister?
16:28 --> 16:28 [UNKNOWN]: He certainly
16:29 --> 16:44 [UNKNOWN]: been familiar with all the rubrics, but they're really reflecting a lot of real-world material in that particular plot of that particular location, so I wanted to bring that up.
16:44 --> 16:45 [UNKNOWN]: That's very interesting.
16:45 --> 16:46 [UNKNOWN]: I had no idea about that.
16:47 --> 17:01 [UNKNOWN]: And then there's right the assassination of right hard hydric as well, who was ostensibly Hitler's second in command and the retribution from that a successful assassination was horrific to say the least.
17:15 --> 17:39 [UNKNOWN]: Whole towns whole communities completely wiped out somewhat similar to what Roman's did Well a variety of different Pires over time And similar to what's happening with the faithful right now, right the retribution for example Actions, I'm sure nothing bad will happen in this episode, but let's get into the episode after this break
18:00 --> 18:02 [UNKNOWN]: We're back and ready to get into the episode.
18:02 --> 18:12 [UNKNOWN]: Don't forget, you too can follow along with this outline in the show guide which is available to full subscribers and season pass holders and linked in the show notes for those subscriber episodes.
18:18 --> 18:18 [UNKNOWN]: It's a great time.
18:19 --> 18:21 [UNKNOWN]: All right, so we're in Roon.
18:21 --> 18:26 [UNKNOWN]: The dark wizard is dismayed by his inability to make a flower bloom in Roon.
18:26 --> 18:29 [UNKNOWN]: He is notified that the gouged dream have returned.
18:30 --> 18:34 [UNKNOWN]: He promises to restore the green to Roon once he has a ring.
18:35 --> 18:40 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf watches the wizard go to meet with his Naznagole.
18:41 --> 18:43 [UNKNOWN]: Kamul, who refuses to give him the ring
18:48 --> 18:51 [UNKNOWN]: When Kamul grabs the wizard's staff, it cracks the jewel within it.
18:52 --> 19:00 [UNKNOWN]: The Dark Wizard tries to improvise but Kamul quickly takes charge and threatens to reveal what was done to the wizard's partner.
19:01 --> 19:06 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf and Tom Bombadil discuss how best to stop the two armies arising.
19:07 --> 19:13 [UNKNOWN]: Outside an accolade of the Dark Wizard tries to assassinate Gandalf but Gandalf throws him into an armored olefonte.
19:14 --> 19:18 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf uses his power to return the enraged animal to itself.
19:19 --> 19:23 [UNKNOWN]: He releases the elephant from its bonds and promises him his fill of grass soon.
19:25 --> 19:26 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry, but I can't hold it.
19:27 --> 19:27 [UNKNOWN]: I can't hold it.
19:28 --> 19:33 [UNKNOWN]: It's the later scene where we find out that the Dark Wizard is Palondo, one of the two blue wizards.
19:33 --> 19:33 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, right.
19:36 --> 19:36 [UNKNOWN]: Click your points now.
19:37 --> 19:38 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to click my points now.
19:38 --> 19:43 [UNKNOWN]: So back if you'll recall, this was again August 22, 2022.
19:44 --> 19:50 [UNKNOWN]: The second age chapter six, the aftermath discusses the coming of the story and how it's possible.
19:50 --> 19:52 [UNKNOWN]: We might see them in the rings of power.
19:52 --> 19:53 [UNKNOWN]: So let's hear past show them.
19:54 --> 19:55 [UNKNOWN]: There's five is story, right?
19:56 --> 20:01 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm going to start with the ones that nobody really knows a lot about, and that's the blue wizards.
20:05 --> 20:17 [UNKNOWN]: We may or may not see them in the series because they may have come in the second age according to some writings and other writings they came in the third age with the other as tarry, but they're known as the blue wizards.
20:17 --> 20:21 [UNKNOWN]: They probably went into the east or the south.
20:22 --> 20:28 [UNKNOWN]: They may have according to some speculation created secret cult and magic traditions that outlast the fall of saaron.
20:29 --> 20:32 [UNKNOWN]: So they're really mysterious figures and we don't know a lot about them but they could
20:36 --> 20:37 [UNKNOWN]: We sound so young.
20:38 --> 20:40 [UNKNOWN]: I don't write, and I'm not much younger.
20:41 --> 20:44 [UNKNOWN]: It's a part of it is, I have better microphone now.
20:45 --> 20:48 [UNKNOWN]: But you've trained yourself, and...
20:48 --> 20:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, in my last just tones.
20:50 --> 20:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
20:51 --> 20:55 [UNKNOWN]: Well, thank you, Bass John, for your primer on Polando, the Blue Wizard.
20:56 --> 21:00 [UNKNOWN]: And, Marilyn, do you want to add some more context to these Blue Wizard?
21:01 --> 21:06 [UNKNOWN]: Well, there's not a lot of context to add because Tolkien really never did say a whole lot about them.
21:06 --> 21:08 [UNKNOWN]: There's some brief comments in the letters.
21:09 --> 21:19 [UNKNOWN]: But I mean, you've covered it pretty thoroughly for all that we have been given from Tolkien, or in things like unfinished tales or the issues of the lyrics.
21:20 --> 21:26 [UNKNOWN]: I think the main thing to take away is there was flexibility in Tolkien's own mind.
21:27 --> 21:29 [UNKNOWN]: about when the wizard's claim.
21:29 --> 21:39 [UNKNOWN]: And in one of his last writings, he did talk about the schedule for the arrival of the study.
21:41 --> 21:45 [UNKNOWN]: And decided, you know, they probably had to have been here in the second age.
21:47 --> 22:00 [UNKNOWN]: So those folks who have been, you know, kind of upset because Ganoff isn't supposed to appear until the third age, that was certainly true in the reflected told King in the 30s, 40s, 50s.
22:01 --> 22:04 [UNKNOWN]: But towards the end of his life, he began to rethink a lot of things.
22:04 --> 22:11 [UNKNOWN]: And as you mentioned, David and I did a Laura Episodon at Works, which was very similar situation.
22:11 --> 22:11 [UNKNOWN]: So
22:13 --> 22:15 [UNKNOWN]: clearly, they decided to take advantage of this.
22:15 --> 22:23 [UNKNOWN]: And the whole right's question, I know little or nothing about it myself, but I think they probably got the blessing of the estate for this one.
22:24 --> 22:30 [UNKNOWN]: I think, well, if they had to, although I can't remember if those names were in the appendix.
22:30 --> 22:32 [UNKNOWN]: I don't believe they're named.
22:32 --> 22:33 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think you're right.
22:33 --> 22:34 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're right.
22:34 --> 22:35 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're right.
22:35 --> 22:37 [UNKNOWN]: There obviously it says there's five of my order.
22:38 --> 22:43 [UNKNOWN]: So the existence of the blue wizards is fine, but I don't believe that they are explicitly named.
22:43 --> 22:49 [UNKNOWN]: Also, they are not always named consistently, he has a couple options for at least one of them.
22:50 --> 22:55 [UNKNOWN]: But here we have confirmed Palando, one of the blue wizards who apparently murdered his brother.
22:55 --> 22:58 [UNKNOWN]: We never found out what happened to them in Tolkien's writing.
22:58 --> 23:01 [UNKNOWN]: So this is all, you know, new show creation.
23:01 --> 23:05 [UNKNOWN]: This is the kind of stuff that I think is good, is fun.
23:05 --> 23:11 [UNKNOWN]: And another thing that Tolkien said, I mean, yes, he did say that they quote him quote failed.
23:12 --> 23:17 [UNKNOWN]: In their mission and possibly they were responsible for evil cults and like kind of
23:19 --> 23:34 [UNKNOWN]: Another thing that he wrote was, we never hear from them again, but it's quite possible that they were responsible for preventing a whole swath of humans in joining up with Sauron.
23:34 --> 23:34 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
23:36 --> 23:40 [UNKNOWN]: And that's something that I'm going to take forward because I think they may be winning in that direction.
23:40 --> 23:44 [UNKNOWN]: You think, again, it's going to be successful in his mission to turn
23:46 --> 23:50 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I mean, that's the seems to be what they're pointing to, whether or not he's successful.
23:50 --> 23:52 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not going to speculate at this point.
23:52 --> 23:56 [UNKNOWN]: It's all about the is star heart and conflict with itself.
23:56 --> 23:59 [UNKNOWN]: Well, or is star hearts and conflict with each other?
23:59 --> 24:00 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, take your pick.
24:01 --> 24:02 [UNKNOWN]: They have big feet.
24:02 --> 24:05 [UNKNOWN]: Can I just say that you're never with that girl?
24:06 --> 24:08 [UNKNOWN]: I saw speculation that they're never coming back.
24:08 --> 24:10 [UNKNOWN]: That the harfots are never coming back on the show.
24:10 --> 24:11 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, no, no, no.
24:11 --> 24:12 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
24:12 --> 24:13 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know if that's true.
24:14 --> 24:16 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know, I would be okay with that.
24:16 --> 24:21 [UNKNOWN]: I know because I think that it's already a degree or a degree.
24:22 --> 24:23 [UNKNOWN]: No, I want them back.
24:23 --> 24:24 [UNKNOWN]: I want to see them again.
24:25 --> 24:29 [UNKNOWN]: But do you think we're kind of moving into a tone in the show that is not going to fit harfots?
24:29 --> 24:31 [UNKNOWN]: And we've kind of done their whole arc, right?
24:31 --> 24:35 [UNKNOWN]: They're being sent to the the shire and then they're going to go settle and then we're done.
24:35 --> 24:37 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, no, it all depends on where they end.
24:37 --> 24:38 [UNKNOWN]: It's season five.
24:39 --> 24:55 [UNKNOWN]: I have a number of possible lovely scenarios in my head, including hearing, you know, a little store-child running away from his grandmother who calls out, come back here, speaking, you know, I mean, it's not impossible.
24:56 --> 25:03 [UNKNOWN]: My favorite idea for the final image is seeing a river and a shallow river and you see
25:10 --> 25:30 [UNKNOWN]: I was going to say that with something in it, even if we don't see the harfots until like season five and some little clips of them setting up in the shy or something like that that all of it is going to be like heavily visually coded for Jackson, right?
25:30 --> 25:34 [UNKNOWN]: They're going to strip mine the movies for everything that they can lace in there.
25:34 --> 25:37 [UNKNOWN]: That's a loss because can I just say that this one's seeing
25:38 --> 25:47 [UNKNOWN]: This one's seen where Gandalf is bubbling his way through and he finds the elephant and so forth.
25:47 --> 25:52 [UNKNOWN]: But trying to not even knowing that he's trying to evade this possible assassin.
25:53 --> 26:01 [UNKNOWN]: And he's just kind of, you know, the crystal goes out and he's kind of banging on it and saying, Austin, like, crystal and then finally bush and whole workshop energy goes out.
26:02 --> 26:03 [UNKNOWN]: And it takes up his asset like,
26:05 --> 26:09 [UNKNOWN]: Ugh, you know, this sort of vaudeville-cut comedy, um, yeah.
26:09 --> 26:10 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't know.
26:10 --> 26:15 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, it was good for a laugh, at least attention, but...
26:15 --> 26:22 [UNKNOWN]: I will say though that when he did use his staff to create the diversion, it was very Obi-Wan Kenobi for me for some reason.
26:22 --> 26:30 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, when Obi-Wan's in the Death Star and he makes a clicking sound and it hurts the guards over there and it was like, yeah, there's not the rings you're looking for.
26:30 --> 26:31 [UNKNOWN]: You're basically...
26:31 --> 26:34 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, he's a gray robe wandering in a desert.
26:34 --> 26:35 [UNKNOWN]: So of course.
26:35 --> 26:39 [UNKNOWN]: And do we buy Tom Bombadil going on sort of spies and stuff?
26:39 --> 26:45 [UNKNOWN]: So off the only thing I could think was he's thinking this idiot still needs my protection.
26:45 --> 26:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
26:46 --> 26:50 [UNKNOWN]: I got a key to saving him because he has to featurely save the world.
26:50 --> 26:53 [UNKNOWN]: Doesn't seem like something that Tom would do.
26:53 --> 26:54 [UNKNOWN]: No, it does not.
26:54 --> 26:58 [UNKNOWN]: Well, the whole Tom Bombadil plotline, I think, was kind of just fan service.
26:59 --> 27:02 [UNKNOWN]: It really did not serve a big narrative purpose.
27:02 --> 27:07 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't think, and it really does go against the whole, like, hey, he just cares about the borders of his forest.
27:07 --> 27:07 [UNKNOWN]: That's it.
27:08 --> 27:09 [UNKNOWN]: If he got a ring, he'd forget about it.
27:09 --> 27:12 [UNKNOWN]: He has no concerns for, like, the, what's going on in the world.
27:13 --> 27:14 [UNKNOWN]: I have thoughts.
27:15 --> 27:15 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
27:15 --> 27:16 [UNKNOWN]: Which we will come up with.
27:16 --> 27:16 [UNKNOWN]: Please share.
27:17 --> 27:18 [UNKNOWN]: We will come up with you in due time.
27:18 --> 27:19 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
27:19 --> 27:19 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
27:21 --> 27:40 [UNKNOWN]: uh... so i'm a little common taken charge right that's that's that's what this scene was really about was common taken charge in maroon and you surfing the dark wizard so what's a dark wizard gonna do he's he's gonna have a dark night of the soul and uh... can get off swoop in and be like i have a way out
27:41 --> 27:48 [UNKNOWN]: He backpettled real fast when he realized the extent of the nasna ghoul's power.
27:48 --> 27:53 [UNKNOWN]: He was like, oh, you didn't tell me that, I'm so gosh, I'm sorry, here's the throw, go ahead.
27:53 --> 27:55 [UNKNOWN]: You yep, it's on yours.
27:55 --> 27:59 [UNKNOWN]: It's kind of a funny turn for preservation.
27:59 --> 28:00 [UNKNOWN]: He's not stupid.
28:01 --> 28:02 [UNKNOWN]: No, that is a good point.
28:02 --> 28:09 [UNKNOWN]: He is not stupid, but I do think you're right, John, that the pathway for Gandalf saving him.
28:09 --> 28:15 [UNKNOWN]: I sense the good in you, Dark Wizard, is available for the storyline now.
28:16 --> 28:17 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know how I feel about it.
28:17 --> 28:19 [UNKNOWN]: It really depends on how it's executed.
28:20 --> 28:29 [UNKNOWN]: This could be very cheesy, but it also could be very like, hey, let's give people chances to redeem themselves and talking is in for that, right?
28:29 --> 28:32 [UNKNOWN]: Like, let's give people a chance to go on there.
28:33 --> 28:34 [UNKNOWN]: There's a lot of that.
28:35 --> 28:35 [UNKNOWN]: Wait, what can't off.
28:36 --> 29:00 [UNKNOWN]: repeats to Frodo later of you know who are you to decide you know many many who live deserved that any who die deserve life who are you can you give it to them right can you give it to them if not them it was there was some definitely weird understandings of power of different beings because of this invention during servants and I think that's also
29:04 --> 29:07 [UNKNOWN]: the witch king split Gandalf's staff.
29:08 --> 29:24 [UNKNOWN]: Right before we hear the horns of Rohan, it just, I would found that soul-palling because Gandalf is not only, um, O'Loran, he's not only a Maya, but he returned from the dead and was
29:33 --> 29:39 [UNKNOWN]: obviously being empowered by self, but still, how could he possibly have more power again?
29:40 --> 29:47 [UNKNOWN]: So, here we see this a similar struggle between a human who really hasn't even had his ring very long.
29:47 --> 29:48 [UNKNOWN]: That's a good point.
29:48 --> 29:49 [UNKNOWN]: And, that's a good point.
29:49 --> 29:50 [UNKNOWN]: And East Star.
29:51 --> 29:51 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
29:52 --> 29:53 [UNKNOWN]: It's at the height of power right now.
29:54 --> 29:55 [UNKNOWN]: Like he's got a lot going on for him.
29:55 --> 29:58 [UNKNOWN]: David, I wanted to ask you about tusk thrashing a behavior.
29:58 --> 30:02 [UNKNOWN]: Oh yes, it came up in a completely different.
30:03 --> 30:04 [UNKNOWN]: Was it a completely impotcast?
30:04 --> 30:21 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, when you're on rings and rituals, you and Sarah, we're talking to that's, like, Anilope, I wrote in and was talking about animal behavior about when young, typically males are threat, you know, doing threat dominance behavior.
30:21 --> 30:23 [UNKNOWN]: Hey, look at me.
30:23 --> 30:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm tough.
30:23 --> 30:24 [UNKNOWN]: Don't mess with me.
30:24 --> 30:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm in charge in this area.
30:25 --> 30:26 [UNKNOWN]: That kind of stuff.
30:26 --> 30:29 [UNKNOWN]: One thing that Anilope's will do is they'll thrash.
30:30 --> 30:57 [UNKNOWN]: uh... shrubs with their horns they'll horn the shrub and uh... this is what i do to you've been given to my territory and uh... the el the olifons tusking the dirt is also a similar type of behavior uh... medial tusk threat you know horn stabby things and you know digging in the dirt so that's a that seemed very at least somebody was you know paying attention to animal behavior one-on-one
30:59 --> 31:08 [UNKNOWN]: And I also thought it's interesting this time, not only does the dark wizard have more accolites lined up, but there are men as well as women accolites.
31:09 --> 31:09 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
31:09 --> 31:10 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
31:10 --> 31:12 [UNKNOWN]: So there's been some development along those lines.
31:12 --> 31:15 [UNKNOWN]: Was the term gaudrem, did that?
31:15 --> 31:17 [UNKNOWN]: Was that a name that was used in past seasons?
31:18 --> 31:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
31:19 --> 31:19 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
31:19 --> 31:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
31:20 --> 31:24 [UNKNOWN]: So the first time we see them introduced at some point where they call themselves gaudrem.
31:24 --> 31:25 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
31:25 --> 31:25 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
31:25 --> 31:27 [UNKNOWN]: Which I think is a show invention.
31:28 --> 31:35 [UNKNOWN]: The rim is a, you know, an ending that signifies people of whatever the first part is.
31:35 --> 31:37 [UNKNOWN]: And I have an ed time to look up what Gao is.
31:37 --> 31:38 [UNKNOWN]: It's in doing it in quite a yes.
31:38 --> 31:53 [UNKNOWN]: So listeners, this is a perfect opportunity for you to write in to LOTR at thelorans.com and educate us because linguistics and philology are very low in my score for Lord Knowledge.
31:53 --> 32:05 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm on the one wiki to rule them all, the Lord of the Rings fandom, and it says specular of em, etymology is goudroom is a cinder in name, possibly meaning the machine hoard or machine people.
32:06 --> 32:18 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, me up of the noun goud device can try a machine from the root gau think out device can try and reen collect a plural meaning host, gluer, a group.
32:19 --> 32:21 [UNKNOWN]: So, uh, you're right, tracks to me.
32:23 --> 32:24 [UNKNOWN]: It does.
32:24 --> 32:24 [UNKNOWN]: That tracks.
32:25 --> 32:28 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, how much have we talked about the machine in Tolkien, right?
32:28 --> 32:30 [UNKNOWN]: Like, I like that.
32:30 --> 32:37 [UNKNOWN]: I'm a little doubtful that the Sindaran would have a word for machine, but- Well, they were saying it's like the device and- Yeah, device of whatever.
32:37 --> 32:38 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
32:38 --> 32:38 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
32:39 --> 32:42 [UNKNOWN]: And as we said before, the rings are certain machines.
32:42 --> 32:42 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
32:44 --> 32:54 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I'm excited to talk about the rest of this rune stuff, but if you know why don't we go ahead and find a final two neutral quick tiers of the Valar is that a thing.
32:54 --> 32:56 [UNKNOWN]: It's a made up guy in time.
32:57 --> 33:02 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, and obviously we just have to call out that again, I'll stand off with the Ola font.
33:03 --> 33:10 [UNKNOWN]: Putting his staff down is, you know, a very calls back to the ball wrong scene and sort of as well.
33:11 --> 33:11 [UNKNOWN]: So
33:13 --> 33:13 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
33:13 --> 33:16 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know if this shall pass the smell test.
33:19 --> 33:20 [UNKNOWN]: Let's go to the West.
33:20 --> 33:22 [UNKNOWN]: Shall we pass into the West?
33:22 --> 33:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
33:23 --> 33:26 [UNKNOWN]: Not in terms of Tolkien metaphor, not yet, please.
33:27 --> 33:31 [UNKNOWN]: Anarion trains the faithful for their inevitable conflict with the King's men.
33:32 --> 33:33 [UNKNOWN]: He urges them not to hesitate.
33:34 --> 33:37 [UNKNOWN]: Elendial arrives to warn his son about the smile in their mist.
33:37 --> 33:43 [UNKNOWN]: Mids, they are to intercept the spies meeting, with one of Farah's own men.
33:44 --> 33:49 [UNKNOWN]: Father and Son reminisce about family beach trips, but an Aryan worries that the war will never end.
33:50 --> 33:52 [UNKNOWN]: They agree to catch the spy alone.
33:52 --> 33:57 [UNKNOWN]: Outside the expected spy meeting, an Aryan is nervous at something as wrong.
33:57 --> 34:04 [UNKNOWN]: When a lendial demands the map at swordpoint, the spy reveals himself to be kemen, and a lendial is surrounded.
34:05 --> 34:10 [UNKNOWN]: Kemen Kruly, Tonsal, and deal with Erahrian's death, and Aryan decides to attack rather than run.
34:11 --> 34:16 [UNKNOWN]: He fills many men, but his father is taken away in a carriage before he can get to him.
34:19 --> 34:24 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm really annoyed by this.
34:24 --> 34:26 [UNKNOWN]: This is just a dumb move.
34:27 --> 34:35 [UNKNOWN]: You're going to go alone, okay, scout the area beforehand to check if there are hidden forces, at least have some troops.
34:35 --> 34:46 [UNKNOWN]: You don't have to tell them what you're doing, just to, you know, be on standby, to age you or to secure your exit, it just, just really annoyed me that, I mean, it, uh,
34:47 --> 34:52 [UNKNOWN]: fine, and Aryan's a young soldier type, and not necessarily a spy type.
34:52 --> 35:09 [UNKNOWN]: His dad, you know, a little bit better, but I just felt it was a little too hand of the writer to set up some stuff that's going to come in future probably, you know, with, you know, somebody being captured and questioned and sets up all kinds of moral dilemmas and stuff like that.
35:09 --> 35:10 [UNKNOWN]: And I just
35:11 --> 35:13 [UNKNOWN]: It just didn't make sense for me.
35:13 --> 35:19 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, find these guys or sea guards and stuff, but there's some basic operations here that are just, that just don't feel right.
35:20 --> 35:21 [UNKNOWN]: Well, they certainly don't feel right.
35:21 --> 35:26 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think, and then thelorious family are, particularly well-versed in the artist's bycraft.
35:28 --> 35:34 [UNKNOWN]: But when would they have ever developed that knowledge because up until this point, they never needed it?
35:34 --> 35:36 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I haven't needed that, but I also wouldn't go alone.
35:37 --> 35:45 [UNKNOWN]: You don't even, I've never been a spy, but like, if somebody were like, you have to catch a spy tonight, I'd be like, let me tell five of my closest friends where I'm going to be.
35:45 --> 35:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
35:46 --> 35:50 [UNKNOWN]: You know, like, at least, hey, if I don't check back in by, you know, such as such time, then.
35:50 --> 35:51 [UNKNOWN]: Right, looking for me.
35:51 --> 35:56 [UNKNOWN]: Like, I totally understand not wanting to broadcast this because you don't want to alert the spy.
35:56 --> 35:57 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
35:57 --> 36:01 [UNKNOWN]: You might have ten people that you trust that you can have in delicious.
36:02 --> 36:14 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I think they tried to dispel that a little bit by an audience saying, I know all these man, I know their families, I know their histories, I don't think any single one of them by and he wasn't wrong.
36:16 --> 36:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that is true.
36:18 --> 36:21 [UNKNOWN]: I will say an Oregon is the one who actually had more caution.
36:21 --> 36:25 [UNKNOWN]: Let me, let me steal man the other side here.
36:27 --> 36:42 [UNKNOWN]: Elendial is just like beacon of honor right is this a make-beth situation where the king can't see evil because he has no evil in him or is this a Stark Kind of thing start.
36:42 --> 36:44 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I'll let you know definitely Ned Starkish.
36:44 --> 36:47 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think the Ned Stark analogy is very good to
36:48 --> 36:55 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he's just, he's two, two, upstanding, there's a, there's a kind of stubbornness that comes with that.
36:56 --> 36:56 [UNKNOWN]: There are rules.
36:56 --> 36:58 [UNKNOWN]: We're all supposed to play by.
36:58 --> 37:00 [UNKNOWN]: And when you break those rules, it's hard for them to adapt.
37:01 --> 37:09 [UNKNOWN]: It's like when you break the norms that has been running a country for over a couple hundred years and everybody's like, Oh, wait, that's a norm and not a law.
37:09 --> 37:09 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, my God.
37:10 --> 37:15 [UNKNOWN]: And yeah, you said me breaking the rules that everybody assumed were in place.
37:15 --> 37:33 [UNKNOWN]: and i think that's part of the whole uh... photos on playbook here fair is that you startle people so much yeah and of course the whole this couldn't possibly happen here i believe it's been put as move fast and break things yes i was trying not to get too close to
37:34 --> 37:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you know, I'll take your point to a degree that they don't they're not really versed in counterintelligence and how you manage for a spy and whether you leave a spy in place or eliminate them.
37:46 --> 37:50 [UNKNOWN]: And if you leave them in place, you get a great information bubble around them.
37:50 --> 38:00 [UNKNOWN]: You know, otherwise, if you do eliminate them, you tip off your enemy, like there's some basic things that you could think through, but like, or just like do a sweep, they did not just sit there, right?
38:01 --> 38:05 [UNKNOWN]: Like you could, you could say, like, hey, you stay here and watch, but I'm going to do a sweep of the perimeter.
38:05 --> 38:05 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
38:05 --> 38:06 [UNKNOWN]: That they would know.
38:06 --> 38:07 [UNKNOWN]: That they would know.
38:07 --> 38:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
38:07 --> 38:09 [UNKNOWN]: That would, they would have known.
38:09 --> 38:13 [UNKNOWN]: Because the way the guy step out of the, you know, like, oh, haha, we've got you.
38:13 --> 38:15 [UNKNOWN]: And there's like, you know, we've got the drop on you with 10 guys.
38:16 --> 38:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you've sold me David that this was just lazy writing.
38:19 --> 38:29 [UNKNOWN]: Well, at the same time, the elves could have told differently, because the elves have been fighting just exactly these battles for a couple of thousand years now.
38:29 --> 38:37 [UNKNOWN]: But having men completely cut off at this point from any conversations with elves,
38:38 --> 38:41 [UNKNOWN]: It's just, it's not current knowledge.
38:41 --> 38:48 [UNKNOWN]: I would also like to say that I really doubt very seriously that anybody could get fresh oysters with their beer hands.
38:49 --> 38:49 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
38:50 --> 38:52 [UNKNOWN]: I live on the coast of Maine.
38:52 --> 38:53 [UNKNOWN]: I know what the rocks look like.
38:53 --> 38:55 [UNKNOWN]: I know what shellfish looks like.
38:55 --> 38:59 [UNKNOWN]: And they have these various, biky bits that are there for protection.
38:59 --> 39:00 [UNKNOWN]: And.
39:00 --> 39:02 [UNKNOWN]: But have you had a new Menorian oyster?
39:02 --> 39:03 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, please, John.
39:04 --> 39:06 [UNKNOWN]: It's like the horses there.
39:06 --> 39:08 [UNKNOWN]: They're just a little bigger, a little meaty, you know?
39:08 --> 39:11 [UNKNOWN]: But are they smooth of shell?
39:11 --> 39:15 [UNKNOWN]: Like, you know, you're... Tolkien didn't write on that in his letters, unfortunately.
39:16 --> 39:20 [UNKNOWN]: Well, he didn't have to, because I, well, this is supposed to be ours.
39:21 --> 39:26 [UNKNOWN]: Now, maybe it evolved over thousands of years when too many new minority and started pulling them off the rocks, is it okay?
39:26 --> 39:27 [UNKNOWN]: We gotta do something here.
39:27 --> 39:29 [UNKNOWN]: Let's start growing spikes.
39:31 --> 39:37 [UNKNOWN]: While we're on the beach there, John, can you play that first audio clip I put together called Anarion?
39:37 --> 39:38 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
39:39 --> 39:41 [UNKNOWN]: It's not going to end, isn't it?
39:41 --> 39:42 [UNKNOWN]: We come at them with a dagger.
39:42 --> 39:44 [UNKNOWN]: They come at us with a sword.
39:44 --> 39:46 [UNKNOWN]: We send one of them into a surgeon.
39:46 --> 39:47 [UNKNOWN]: They send one of us to a tomb.
39:48 --> 39:50 [UNKNOWN]: And our father wants to slaughter.
39:51 --> 39:55 [UNKNOWN]: Women and children that will never happen.
39:55 --> 39:57 [UNKNOWN]: Now, please play the next clip.
39:58 --> 40:09 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to get the capon and I'll show you guys He pulls a knife, you pull a gun He sends one of yours to the hospital You send one of his to the mall That's your bag away And that's how you get the capon
40:11 --> 40:20 [UNKNOWN]: And of course, that was a Sean Connery talking to Kevin Costner in the 1987 movie, The Untouchables, written by David Mammot and directed by Brian De Palma.
40:20 --> 40:33 [UNKNOWN]: And I think it was, oh, was it somebody in the discord, and I can see your discord thing, but I can't remember your name, I'm sorry, who actually called it out.
40:33 --> 40:34 [UNKNOWN]: And I was like, yes, that's it.
40:35 --> 40:58 [UNKNOWN]: from the intouchables, but just that line of like, you know, one of us for one of them, but escalating, escalating, yeah, so maybe there was a writer that's their favorite movie or something like that and so it got sort of worked in and put into the episode, but anyway, I had to call it out for those that who it stuck for them as well.
40:59 --> 41:00 [UNKNOWN]: Cincinnati.
41:00 --> 41:01 [UNKNOWN]: I believe it was Cincinnati.
41:01 --> 41:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, Cincinnati, Joe called it out.
41:02 --> 41:04 [UNKNOWN]: He he he posted the gift for it.
41:04 --> 41:05 [UNKNOWN]: Aha.
41:05 --> 41:06 [UNKNOWN]: Good job.
41:06 --> 41:08 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I couldn't I was looking for it, but I couldn't find it.
41:08 --> 41:10 [UNKNOWN]: So yeah, I knew I couldn't remember the movie.
41:10 --> 41:12 [UNKNOWN]: I heard it at her the line and it's like wait a minute.
41:14 --> 41:15 [UNKNOWN]: And so yeah, we got it.
41:15 --> 41:16 [UNKNOWN]: I was interesting.
41:16 --> 41:18 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't I've never seen them movies.
41:18 --> 41:19 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't get the vibe, obviously.
41:19 --> 41:19 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, wow.
41:20 --> 41:22 [UNKNOWN]: Um, but David, the list of movies I haven't
41:26 --> 41:27 [UNKNOWN]: Um, I was sad.
41:27 --> 41:31 [UNKNOWN]: I a friend invited me to go see Godzilla minus zero a couple nights ago, but I couldn't make it.
41:31 --> 41:32 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, bummer.
41:32 --> 41:34 [UNKNOWN]: Um, good, but I want to go see it eventually.
41:34 --> 41:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, see it on the big screen.
41:35 --> 41:37 [UNKNOWN]: Definitely see it on the big screen.
41:37 --> 41:37 [UNKNOWN]: It's worth it.
41:37 --> 41:39 [UNKNOWN]: Do I have to see the first one, though?
41:39 --> 41:40 [UNKNOWN]: No, you don't.
41:40 --> 41:41 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, you can, you can get by.
41:41 --> 41:43 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, you'll, you'll, it's, you'll be fine.
41:43 --> 41:44 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
41:44 --> 41:45 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it'll all, it'll all make sense.
41:46 --> 41:46 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
41:46 --> 41:47 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to trust you.
41:48 --> 41:49 [UNKNOWN]: And there's good monsters.
41:50 --> 41:51 [UNKNOWN]: What do you want?
41:51 --> 41:51 [UNKNOWN]: It's monsters.
41:52 --> 41:59 [UNKNOWN]: I really appreciate that an audience character is being developed in this direction because we know he left a long time ago.
42:01 --> 42:06 [UNKNOWN]: And so he had this vision or whatever you want to call it.
42:06 --> 42:14 [UNKNOWN]: He just he understood that there was going to be a fight coming long before a lendil accepted that was the case.
42:16 --> 42:19 [UNKNOWN]: And so it makes sense to me that he's training people in the arts of war.
42:20 --> 42:22 [UNKNOWN]: It makes sense to me that he knows how to do these things.
42:23 --> 42:29 [UNKNOWN]: But being isolated in this one region, the whole spycraft thing has not been necessary.
42:30 --> 42:31 [UNKNOWN]: And so it's completely evaded.
42:32 --> 43:01 [UNKNOWN]: right but he's also the one who goes this doesn't feel right exactly it's fine it's fine and I I just I do think it's a little unbelievable that said I'm not I don't want to dwell on this because it's just kind of and and how cruel is Kevin to taunt him with uh yeah like are we to believe that Kevin felt nothing for a area because if that's the case I just I don't think there's any redemption for this guy if he if he's able to fake
43:03 --> 43:06 [UNKNOWN]: if he doesn't feel I need grief for this woman he who he allegedly loved.
43:07 --> 43:08 [UNKNOWN]: Not anymore.
43:09 --> 43:11 [UNKNOWN]: He might have felt it in the episode one.
43:11 --> 43:12 [UNKNOWN]: I mean it's season one.
43:13 --> 43:21 [UNKNOWN]: But he has been committed all his life to making sure that he has his father's or trying to get his father's approval.
43:23 --> 43:27 [UNKNOWN]: And it was fine when Arian was joining up with them early on in
43:33 --> 43:40 [UNKNOWN]: I lendale by pointing up talent here, and you know, that whole thing that happened at Theodil's condition.
43:41 --> 43:52 [UNKNOWN]: And at some point, I think Kevin had to decide, all right, it's my father, or they out in, and she never really strongly committed to him to be protested.
43:53 --> 43:58 [UNKNOWN]: So why would he be significantly hurt?
43:59 --> 44:10 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know, I can't, if I were responsible for someone's death, even someone I didn't like, I, I couldn't turn off emotions like that.
44:10 --> 44:14 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm just saying it's tough for me to see a path forward.
44:14 --> 44:21 [UNKNOWN]: Like that was just such a cruel move that it might have been too cruel for the writers if they want to do a redemption arc for this guy.
44:22 --> 44:24 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I don't think they do to be personally honest.
44:25 --> 44:26 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think that's right.
44:26 --> 44:32 [UNKNOWN]: I wonder if his whole purpose is to teach a letting deal you can't save everyone.
44:34 --> 44:35 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
44:36 --> 44:36 [UNKNOWN]: You know?
44:37 --> 44:37 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
44:38 --> 44:40 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I think he's probably figured that up, I know.
44:42 --> 44:42 [UNKNOWN]: Or has he?
44:42 --> 44:46 [UNKNOWN]: Because right now his goal is put mural back on the throne.
44:47 --> 44:55 [UNKNOWN]: and get everyone happy, you know, friends again, he does this whole thing of like, we can't see them as them, right?
44:55 --> 44:57 [UNKNOWN]: We have to see it as together, we, it's not us and them.
44:58 --> 45:06 [UNKNOWN]: So I don't know, I think that a Lendil has something to learn about like, you have to let people have the consequence of their decisions too.
45:06 --> 45:10 [UNKNOWN]: A Lendil is not the primary presenter of that perspective.
45:11 --> 45:12 [UNKNOWN]: It's material.
45:12 --> 45:14 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm, oh, that's true, you're right.
45:15 --> 45:18 [UNKNOWN]: And so, Elendale can support her as much as possible.
45:18 --> 45:22 [UNKNOWN]: He could be her right arm, her champion, whatever.
45:23 --> 45:25 [UNKNOWN]: But he's only recently come back to the face.
45:26 --> 45:33 [UNKNOWN]: She never left, and there was one scene where he said to her, you were the reason why I came back.
45:34 --> 45:40 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that may have, he might have lost his faith back when his wife died and drowned.
45:41 --> 45:42 [UNKNOWN]: You know, there are a lot of things.
45:43 --> 45:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it also had some explaining to do after that, right?
45:46 --> 45:48 [UNKNOWN]: I think that was, I'll say, I don't think so.
45:48 --> 45:48 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
45:48 --> 45:50 [UNKNOWN]: I'll say is the one who drowns ships and people.
45:51 --> 45:51 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
45:51 --> 45:51 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
45:52 --> 45:59 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that'll make for some interesting juxtaposition between Elendil,
46:00 --> 46:02 [UNKNOWN]: and Farazone, right?
46:02 --> 46:06 [UNKNOWN]: The principle tension between the kingsmen and the faithful.
46:07 --> 46:26 [UNKNOWN]: And if we have L-indale as this moral, I don't think he's going to go Ned Stark and be totally stupid, but the fact we can only hope that he is going to be a embodiment of the values of the faithful in terms of,
46:29 --> 46:53 [UNKNOWN]: had tragedy in his life and now he's lost, you know, another family member, which I think he's not yet learned of and to like some point he's going to, well, that's that's exactly what Kevin does with him in this episode in this episode, yep, yep, yep, oh, that's right, right, right, sorry, I'm awesome, he talks on right there, yep, yeah, exactly, and so I think that that's going to, we're going to, it'll be interesting to see what arc they place a
46:56 --> 47:03 [UNKNOWN]: in terms of how all of these emotions and values turn and shift within him and can he find
47:05 --> 47:33 [UNKNOWN]: uh... you know what is justice in this question or what is forgiveness in this question what is uh... somebody not seeking retribution who would normally would say oh yeah it's totally fine like you know that this person did this really grievous and horrible thing against you and your family you know you want to seek some retribution it's probably okay we're gonna let that one slide you know can he inside of himself finds some other moral path path way for
47:34 --> 47:36 [UNKNOWN]: for his faith and his values to live out.
47:36 --> 47:41 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I think the question is, how is everybody going to answer the question the end's just by the means?
47:42 --> 47:43 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, very.
47:44 --> 48:06 [UNKNOWN]: I think that this is something where I don't envy the writers, because I don't think there's a good answer on how to adapt a lendial, because Pokemon is still merely writing, does these larger-than-life mythic characters like a lendial, where they are known for their deeds, not really their personas, and
48:07 --> 48:13 [UNKNOWN]: It's sort of like if you tried to adapt a biblical story and you were like, what would Nimrod have done?
48:14 --> 48:14 [UNKNOWN]: Right?
48:14 --> 48:25 [UNKNOWN]: Like, you, however choice you make, you're going to make somebody mad because you're necessarily to have a character, have dramatic tension.
48:25 --> 48:30 [UNKNOWN]: You need to, you need to compromise those giant values.
48:30 --> 48:30 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
48:31 --> 48:31 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
48:31 --> 48:32 [UNKNOWN]: Challenge them in some way.
48:32 --> 48:33 [UNKNOWN]: Put them under pressure.
48:33 --> 48:34 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
48:34 --> 48:34 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
48:34 --> 48:36 [UNKNOWN]: back him into a corner and see how they're going to respond.
48:37 --> 48:41 [UNKNOWN]: So if you don't do that, you're going to have an extremely boring character.
48:42 --> 48:48 [UNKNOWN]: And if you do do that, you're going to jeopardize people being like, well, that's not really what he was known for.
48:49 --> 48:54 [UNKNOWN]: And I just, I don't even feed the writers because I don't think there's a good answer to this.
48:54 --> 48:58 [UNKNOWN]: I think we're just going to have a decent, a lendial arc.
49:00 --> 49:02 [UNKNOWN]: We're going to have what we've seen about Galatheil.
49:02 --> 49:03 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
49:03 --> 49:20 [UNKNOWN]: People being very upset by her presentation in season one and two because they don't recognize at least the well, I shouldn't put on anybody else with their thinking and feel like the Galather that we see in the third age is not Galather or we see in the first age.
49:21 --> 49:21 [UNKNOWN]: How could it be?
49:22 --> 49:30 [UNKNOWN]: many thousands of years Beth, but the thing with Galadriel, though, is she has a character flaw in the Lord of the Rings.
49:30 --> 49:45 [UNKNOWN]: She has that moment where she goes, maybe I will take the ring, maybe I will become a great queen and then she overcomes that and succeeds, but there is that conflict within her and so she is inherently a more interesting character than a lendialist.
49:46 --> 49:55 [UNKNOWN]: Whereas a lendial is just beacon of hope and light and her fatherly wisdom and sort of deep, deep gravel evoiced.
49:55 --> 49:59 [UNKNOWN]: And with a hand clapped on your shoulder and a long soulful look into your eyes.
50:00 --> 50:06 [UNKNOWN]: I kind of have a feeling that a lendial is too middle-earth as George Washington is too.
50:06 --> 50:07 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm, it stands.
50:09 --> 50:12 [UNKNOWN]: From a long distance, we tend to see
50:14 --> 50:40 [UNKNOWN]: close to perfect characters and it is only if you are willing to dig into things you discovered this was a dude who put his socks on every morning a human being who is going to face the same kinds of challenges every day particularly if they are responsible for the lives of hundreds of thousands of soldiers and you have wooden dentures got well and he kept
50:42 --> 50:55 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and people today in our real world, in our real country, like a lot of people, not all people, obviously, but a lot of people like to whitewash that history, right?
50:55 --> 51:01 [UNKNOWN]: And they don't want to confront that, and they don't, and they erase things in museums, perhaps, when administrations come in.
51:02 --> 51:07 [UNKNOWN]: And they would rather turn a blind eye to it and allow those giants to continue being those giants.
51:07 --> 51:09 [UNKNOWN]: And I think you're right, Maryland.
51:09 --> 51:11 [UNKNOWN]: This is like a George Washington situation.
51:13 --> 51:22 [UNKNOWN]: People, I think, I think people generally, reasonable people understand in the real world you have to look at people more complicated than that.
51:23 --> 51:29 [UNKNOWN]: When you are reading fantasy, like Tolkien, there's not necessarily a moral responsibility to do that, right?
51:29 --> 51:30 [UNKNOWN]: They debate a play.
51:30 --> 51:32 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, you apply fantasy to real life.
51:33 --> 51:38 [UNKNOWN]: And you know, I don't think there's as clean a break of that as that implies.
51:38 --> 51:47 [UNKNOWN]: However, people give themselves more of a permission structure to have this almost religious devotion to the way a character is portrayed in a book.
51:47 --> 51:50 [UNKNOWN]: And so that is why people, I think, struggle a lot
51:52 --> 52:18 [UNKNOWN]: It's interesting because the real world is so disappointing and you know when you find that your national heroes were human beings with biases and prejudices and made morally bad choices you know in the light of of day judgment so to speak historically judging that having having
52:20 --> 52:25 [UNKNOWN]: characters in a fantasy that do hold and hue to these ideals.
52:25 --> 52:29 [UNKNOWN]: You really want hold onto them because you really need something like that to hold up.
52:29 --> 52:32 [UNKNOWN]: You need to hug you teddy bear or whatever it is, right?
52:32 --> 52:38 [UNKNOWN]: You need that thing that is just like it's not morally complex and I can relate to it.
52:38 --> 52:44 [UNKNOWN]: And I can feel my emotions and I can think my thoughts and it provides a pathway.
52:45 --> 52:46 [UNKNOWN]: I think about pets a lot of the times.
52:47 --> 52:56 [UNKNOWN]: You know, like with our cat, our family cat, our cat just gets love from us and it's just a thing, it's just a pathway for us to love and be loved without complication.
52:57 --> 53:09 [UNKNOWN]: And so to have heroes in our stories, that we can love or hate and be passionate about in different ways, it just allows us that free flow of thought and emotion.
53:10 --> 53:16 [UNKNOWN]: I find it very comforting to see heroic humans
53:18 --> 53:45 [UNKNOWN]: in, you know, 360 degrees, including their flaws, because that means that I can possibly enact a lot more here with my flaws than if I looked at, you know, a Ned Stark or, you know, whatever character you want to name, who seems impossibly, moral upright always makes the right
53:49 --> 53:55 [UNKNOWN]: That's a story, I mean, in fairy tales, good and evil are pretty clearly delineated.
53:57 --> 54:12 [UNKNOWN]: In the real world, not so much, and being faced with those more complicated choices, and still being a character who is only interested in doing what I quote good, or even the
54:18 --> 54:26 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, okay, so I'm thinking now if Pyrdon, I don't want Pyrdon to be, you know, morally complex, because that's not what he's there for.
54:27 --> 54:28 [UNKNOWN]: But he's also an elf.
54:29 --> 54:31 [UNKNOWN]: A very, very, very, very old elf.
54:33 --> 54:40 [UNKNOWN]: Whereas with the human characters, I want to see how Elen, they'll develop this reputation.
54:41 --> 54:44 [UNKNOWN]: Because I know he had to be flawed in some fashion because he was human.
54:47 --> 55:02 [UNKNOWN]: I am very, very interesting points you're raising, Marilyn, to me, you bring up Ned Stark kind of shows how I like a character like this to be adapted because Ned Stark is in a way infallible, right?
55:02 --> 55:04 [UNKNOWN]: Always doing what he believes is honorable.
55:04 --> 55:05 [UNKNOWN]: Until he wasn't.
55:05 --> 55:06 [UNKNOWN]: But that's the point, right?
55:07 --> 55:07 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
55:07 --> 55:08 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
55:08 --> 55:10 [UNKNOWN]: There were consequences to that.
55:10 --> 55:11 [UNKNOWN]: He wasn't perfect.
55:11 --> 55:14 [UNKNOWN]: He was dedicated to a fault.
55:15 --> 55:16 [UNKNOWN]: to an idea of honor.
55:17 --> 55:25 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that's how you have to treat a lendial too, because we're full swirlers on Lord of the Rings, not everything that's gonna happen in Newman Orn, or everything.
55:26 --> 55:28 [UNKNOWN]: But if you watch the Peter Jackson movies, you turn them on.
55:28 --> 55:30 [UNKNOWN]: The first thing you see is a lendial dying, right?
55:30 --> 55:34 [UNKNOWN]: A lendial is struck down at the very beginning of the Lord of the Rings.
55:34 --> 55:46 [UNKNOWN]: All right, and I will sequence in the battle sequence to with Galadriel narrating and so we know that this is a character who fails in some way Not at everything he tries to do, but he fails in some way
55:47 --> 55:51 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that that has to play a part in this.
55:51 --> 56:03 [UNKNOWN]: And if they do this right, they will see, they will show how this character can accomplish many things but is limited by his own adherence to specific principles.
56:04 --> 56:05 [UNKNOWN]: That's interesting.
56:05 --> 56:15 [UNKNOWN]: I would say the only way he failed was by dying.
56:16 --> 56:17 [UNKNOWN]: but he didn't kill Salon.
56:17 --> 56:19 [UNKNOWN]: He tried to kill Salon and he didn't.
56:19 --> 56:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he did.
56:20 --> 56:22 [UNKNOWN]: Together with other helpers.
56:23 --> 56:26 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, insofar as it was possible that he'll Salon.
56:27 --> 56:37 [UNKNOWN]: Eee, he, yeah, I see what you're saying, like they're, but he caused the influence of Salon to vanish from the world for about a thousand years.
56:37 --> 56:39 [UNKNOWN]: I think that's a pretty good success myself.
56:40 --> 56:42 [UNKNOWN]: Well, as she'll do, I can finish it off though.
56:42 --> 56:46 [UNKNOWN]: Sure, but like how many people wouldn't have been there if it's ill-dill and ill-dill.
56:46 --> 56:47 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
56:47 --> 56:48 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
56:48 --> 57:05 [UNKNOWN]: How, I always think of when we talk about here where characters and giving us hope and ideals that we can live in our real life, I think of Mary facing up the witch king, and how courage is contagious like that.
57:09 --> 57:30 [UNKNOWN]: I think maybe that's what's interesting about Elendiel in this is that he is kind of like we're just kind of like oh my god you got like I want to smash my head against a rock thinking about your sort of stubbornness and your sort of obtuseness but he is this he does make it to that point and how many soldiers would not be facing down the enemies of you know
57:38 --> 57:41 [UNKNOWN]: And so on one hand, George Washington was a failure.
57:41 --> 57:42 [UNKNOWN]: He owned slaves.
57:42 --> 57:45 [UNKNOWN]: He refused to emancipate his slaves on his death.
57:46 --> 57:46 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
57:47 --> 57:54 [UNKNOWN]: But you made a country that ended up in Civil War because they failed to make the compromise, they failed to win fourth and fourth and fourth.
57:54 --> 57:54 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
57:54 --> 57:55 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
57:55 --> 57:56 [UNKNOWN]: And that's what he was messy.
57:56 --> 57:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
57:57 --> 57:58 [UNKNOWN]: It was not George Washington.
57:58 --> 58:01 [UNKNOWN]: He was not involved in the congressional decision.
58:03 --> 58:04 [UNKNOWN]: in the making of the Constitution.
58:05 --> 58:06 [UNKNOWN]: No, but he did lead that country.
58:06 --> 58:09 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, well, we have to go back and watch the can found the fathers in general.
58:09 --> 58:11 [UNKNOWN]: No, I was in father's in general.
58:12 --> 58:16 [UNKNOWN]: Fail to create a lasting piece, right?
58:16 --> 58:23 [UNKNOWN]: Because within the country, because they did not address the hard question of, yes, of how do we stop?
58:23 --> 58:26 [UNKNOWN]: Well, you can't be no can't be sustained.
58:26 --> 58:27 [UNKNOWN]: And that's their fatal flaw.
58:27 --> 58:28 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
58:28 --> 58:28 [UNKNOWN]: That was the fatal flaw.
58:29 --> 58:31 [UNKNOWN]: But that's what breaks had this concept.
58:32 --> 58:33 [UNKNOWN]: What's the concept?
58:33 --> 58:34 [UNKNOWN]: The fatal flaw.
58:34 --> 58:34 [UNKNOWN]: The fatal flaw.
58:34 --> 58:34 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
58:35 --> 58:36 [UNKNOWN]: Every hero has the fatal flaw.
58:36 --> 58:37 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
58:37 --> 58:39 [UNKNOWN]: So, which makes it more interesting.
58:39 --> 58:53 [UNKNOWN]: The question is, can they turn a lendial this giant of the Silmarillion, this giant of the Eccalabeth, and of the appendices of the Lord of the Rings and legend, and beginning where Galadriel's narrating his march up to, you know, barred door?
58:54 --> 59:04 [UNKNOWN]: can they turn this into an interesting character, or will they have this be a much more push-in to awkward situations like they did in the scene?
59:04 --> 59:06 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's an interesting character already, but.
59:06 --> 59:07 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
59:08 --> 59:09 [UNKNOWN]: Alright.
59:09 --> 59:09 [UNKNOWN]: Just me.
59:10 --> 59:10 [UNKNOWN]: Alright.
59:11 --> 59:13 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I think we've debated a londial long enough.
59:13 --> 59:14 [UNKNOWN]: Let's move on.
59:14 --> 59:14 [UNKNOWN]: Let's move on.
59:15 --> 59:16 [UNKNOWN]: Let's move on.
59:16 --> 59:17 [UNKNOWN]: To goon the bad.
59:18 --> 59:20 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we're on our way to goon the bad, to be clear.
59:22 --> 59:26 [UNKNOWN]: Gladriel, Arandir, and Marnuk are on their way to Gwundabad.
59:27 --> 59:32 [UNKNOWN]: Marnuk complains about elf food, before the group finds the remnants of a battle.
59:33 --> 59:35 [UNKNOWN]: The elves make the ork go first in case it's a trap.
59:36 --> 59:38 [UNKNOWN]: Marnuk shares his poetry with the other in clings.
59:40 --> 59:44 [UNKNOWN]: Marnuk, a Gladriel's ring shines in the presence of the Naznugul.
59:45 --> 59:46 [UNKNOWN]: Cornered by the Naznugul,
59:47 --> 59:57 [UNKNOWN]: Gladryl uses the power of the ring to infuse Marnook's lunch butterfly with an illusion, making the nonsenigole believe they were on the wrong trail.
59:58 --> 01:00:03 [UNKNOWN]: The elves grow more suspicious of their guide and Marnook attempts to go to our endier to attack him.
01:00:04 --> 01:00:07 [UNKNOWN]: Marnug warns Galadriel that Arandir's anger will get them killed.
01:00:08 --> 01:00:12 [UNKNOWN]: Arandir asks Galadriel to trust in their fellowship and return to Rivendell.
01:00:13 --> 01:00:17 [UNKNOWN]: Galadriel tells Arandir that memory is clouding his judgment.
01:00:18 --> 01:00:29 [UNKNOWN]: a lot of real orders around here to leave them to seek Theo when around here sees the trebuchet's marnu warnd was about active.
01:00:29 --> 01:00:32 [UNKNOWN]: He realizes that she might be right.
01:00:32 --> 01:00:37 [UNKNOWN]: Outside good about marnu tells Galagriel to chain herself as his supposed prisoner.
01:00:37 --> 01:00:38 [UNKNOWN]: She won't do it but
01:00:47 --> 01:00:53 [UNKNOWN]: Luke and Han Solo and Chewbacca in the in the guards room trying to put on the manacles on on the wood.
01:00:56 --> 01:01:03 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I mean, they were clearly trying to do some member berries here with the with some lighting up for the goblins, right?
01:01:03 --> 01:01:09 [UNKNOWN]: I think from the horses, the camera angles, the whole thing.
01:01:09 --> 01:01:16 [UNKNOWN]: The just even going on at Journey with a foe, so to speak, to a dangerous place, all very jacksonian.
01:01:16 --> 01:01:21 [UNKNOWN]: The whole thing was just way too much similarity with Frotto Sam and Gomp.
01:01:21 --> 01:01:28 [UNKNOWN]: You've got two being of one kind and the third being of that kind who has been horribly changed.
01:01:29 --> 01:01:29 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:01:30 --> 01:01:37 [UNKNOWN]: You've got the mischap and creature being enabled to eat wholesome food, the hiding from a ring person underneath the roots of a tree,
01:01:39 --> 01:01:43 [UNKNOWN]: even the faithful servant being sent away and then returning.
01:01:43 --> 01:01:46 [UNKNOWN]: It's just, oh, yeah, I didn't even clog that.
01:01:46 --> 01:01:47 [UNKNOWN]: That's totally, yeah.
01:01:47 --> 01:01:49 [UNKNOWN]: It just goes on and on and on and on.
01:01:49 --> 01:01:56 [UNKNOWN]: And those stories, well, I mentioned that, how do I, and of course, the overarching question, what is this third person want?
01:01:56 --> 01:01:56 [UNKNOWN]: Are they trustworthy?
01:01:57 --> 01:01:58 [UNKNOWN]: Are they leading other two intro traps?
01:01:58 --> 01:02:02 [UNKNOWN]: It's just such a carbon.
01:02:02 --> 01:02:05 [UNKNOWN]: And didn't Gandalf speak to a moth on the top of yeah.
01:02:07 --> 01:02:09 [UNKNOWN]: but that was to send them off to find.
01:02:09 --> 01:02:09 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:02:09 --> 01:02:10 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, to send them message out.
01:02:10 --> 01:02:11 [UNKNOWN]: So let him, yeah.
01:02:11 --> 01:02:14 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it's still, it's still all of these memberberry stuff.
01:02:15 --> 01:02:18 [UNKNOWN]: I do think it was a little much when our onto your said, don't go where I can't follow.
01:02:20 --> 01:02:22 [UNKNOWN]: That didn't really happen, folks.
01:02:22 --> 01:02:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just, I'm just joking.
01:02:23 --> 01:02:23 [UNKNOWN]: They don't have to go back.
01:02:24 --> 01:02:27 [UNKNOWN]: I never really understood what the whole butterfly thing was supposed to do.
01:02:28 --> 01:02:29 [UNKNOWN]: I really did not.
01:02:29 --> 01:02:54 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't see the same thing for a moment, but then I, I, okay, I'm going to give them so much grace here because I, I do think that this was a poorly executed scene, but from what I gather and I wrote it like this in the show guide from what I can tell their idea was the Naz in the gold noticed that there was some kind of movement in that bush and
01:02:56 --> 01:03:06 [UNKNOWN]: the butterfly makes it a swarm of butterflies so that they will believe that the movements, the larger movements they saw in the bush, or actually just a swarm of butterflies.
01:03:07 --> 01:03:07 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:03:07 --> 01:03:08 [UNKNOWN]: Wow.
01:03:08 --> 01:03:13 [UNKNOWN]: I am being so generous with that generous because they just end it and you're like, yeah.
01:03:13 --> 01:03:18 [UNKNOWN]: Next thing there are, they're sitting around an open campfire on almost weathertop, right?
01:03:18 --> 01:03:20 [UNKNOWN]: Like to even stretch the story a little bit further out.
01:03:21 --> 01:03:28 [UNKNOWN]: Um, wait, you've just been height, there's, there's an orc enemy army, not far away.
01:03:28 --> 01:03:31 [UNKNOWN]: You can see the lights of the other place that they're supposed to be attacking.
01:03:31 --> 01:03:32 [UNKNOWN]: Too nasty, Google.
01:03:32 --> 01:03:35 [UNKNOWN]: We're just tracking you and you're going to sit around with an open campfire.
01:03:35 --> 01:03:36 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:03:36 --> 01:03:41 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, like, uh, Ergon would just be like, furious with you right now.
01:03:41 --> 01:03:41 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, we'll go.
01:03:42 --> 01:03:44 [UNKNOWN]: At least they didn't have the ring-servant sniffing.
01:03:45 --> 01:03:46 [UNKNOWN]: The ring.
01:03:46 --> 01:03:46 [UNKNOWN]: The fair.
01:03:47 --> 01:03:47 [UNKNOWN]: The fair.
01:03:50 --> 01:03:59 [UNKNOWN]: Oh my goodness, I have to make a note about, sorry, we're on a kind of a bender here, but Galadriel's breastplate.
01:04:01 --> 01:04:06 [UNKNOWN]: rule of cool absolutely it's awesome it looks great and it's a great practical piece of armor.
01:04:06 --> 01:04:10 [UNKNOWN]: It's all those little cutouts or just where a pointy thing would catch.
01:04:10 --> 01:04:21 [UNKNOWN]: I saw a YouTube video the other day or I don't know it was a clip or some I don't know where I see this stuff anymore and it was somebody who was like basically with a dagger pointy you know poking at.
01:04:21 --> 01:04:35 [UNKNOWN]: armor or different kinds of armor and showing how the little little lips and folds and little things are all does that everything that you see on a suit of plate nail armor is designed with a specific intent.
01:04:35 --> 01:04:39 [UNKNOWN]: If you see a little ridge of some kind, it's there for a reason.
01:04:39 --> 01:04:39 [UNKNOWN]: It's to like,
01:04:40 --> 01:04:42 [UNKNOWN]: There's a little ridge sometimes on a breastplate.
01:04:42 --> 01:04:58 [UNKNOWN]: So if there's an arrow hits you and it shatters upwards, there's a little piece that sticks out that sort of deflects all that stuff from keeping it from coming up in your face, like this is all super well-designed and that her alpha armor is cool as hell and it's just practical.
01:04:58 --> 01:05:02 [UNKNOWN]: And try to sneak around in PlayDarmer, and I think you'll understand why.
01:05:02 --> 01:05:06 [UNKNOWN]: No, you usually fail your stealth checks when you're playing dead.
01:05:06 --> 01:05:07 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's like automatically.
01:05:07 --> 01:05:08 [UNKNOWN]: You cannot do it in PlayDarmer.
01:05:08 --> 01:05:11 [UNKNOWN]: Rattle, Rattle, Rattle, Rattle.
01:05:11 --> 01:05:11 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:05:11 --> 01:05:17 [UNKNOWN]: There is a long tradition in fantasy of women wearing impractical armor.
01:05:17 --> 01:05:20 [UNKNOWN]: Like that is just, you know, a tale is old as time.
01:05:20 --> 01:05:24 [UNKNOWN]: Give them men, the bulky armor, give the women something that looks cute.
01:05:25 --> 01:05:43 [UNKNOWN]: No, something I will, two things I really want to praise this scene for one are the Trebuchet and the other is that Marnook shows care for a fellow dead work.
01:05:45 --> 01:05:46 [UNKNOWN]: It is interesting, right?
01:05:47 --> 01:05:59 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that when we talk about Orcs and, you know, we saw an Orc family mother and child in, was it season one, I believe it was that we saw that.
01:05:59 --> 01:06:00 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:06:03 --> 01:06:25 [UNKNOWN]: That was season two season two and and that were you know, they're very conscious of the the question of can you you know a bio essentialism and and just inherent Oh, this race is bad you know that we just have to be that way about it that they're showing another dimension of
01:06:27 --> 01:06:38 [UNKNOWN]: or existence by showing him caring for a fallen fellow comrade and wanting to do something to honor his death.
01:06:38 --> 01:07:00 [UNKNOWN]: And correct me if I'm wrong, I think both of you might have more knowledge on this than I do, but isn't death rituals some of the earliest documented parts of human culture that we have, like bodies being entombed and bodies being buried with things, like it goes back to humanoid existence, you know, conscientious sentient beings.
01:07:01 --> 01:07:03 [UNKNOWN]: Death is this thing that it's just
01:07:06 --> 01:07:08 [UNKNOWN]: We can't know what's on the other side of death kind of thing.
01:07:08 --> 01:07:12 [UNKNOWN]: And so we make up a lot of stuff and it's ritual and meaning.
01:07:13 --> 01:07:18 [UNKNOWN]: So to have an orc care for another fallen comrade, I think it's really.
01:07:18 --> 01:07:22 [UNKNOWN]: It's a blinking emissive moment and there's a lot that else is going on in the scene.
01:07:22 --> 01:07:25 [UNKNOWN]: And I just think it's important that it gets acknowledged.
01:07:25 --> 01:07:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think it becomes an important marker.
01:07:31 --> 01:07:32 [UNKNOWN]: from there.
01:07:33 --> 01:07:36 [UNKNOWN]: But Galadriel has already seen or rituals for the dead.
01:07:37 --> 01:07:37 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:07:37 --> 01:07:45 [UNKNOWN]: When she was sneaking out of the camp before Region was utterly destroyed in season two.
01:07:46 --> 01:07:49 [UNKNOWN]: She saw Adar.
01:07:51 --> 01:08:05 [UNKNOWN]: repeating a phrase over and over and touching each of the bodies, the bodies were shrouded, they were going to the fire, but that's the most practical solution, but we have found the Andorthal, right?
01:08:06 --> 01:08:10 [UNKNOWN]: of buried people with flowers on top of them.
01:08:11 --> 01:08:12 [UNKNOWN]: So you're absolutely right,
01:08:20 --> 01:08:27 [UNKNOWN]: you know, sentient beings, we're aware of our exit, I think, therefore, I am, whatever, you know, like, I'm aware that I persist in this world.
01:08:28 --> 01:08:37 [UNKNOWN]: And then so the idea that I will no longer persist, or my family or friends will are no longer persisting, and I don't know what happens to them.
01:08:39 --> 01:08:45 [UNKNOWN]: Well, as part of the phenomena of existing and being a consciousness in the world,
01:08:46 --> 01:08:52 [UNKNOWN]: and then recognizing that there's a state change and then being moved by that.
01:08:53 --> 01:08:55 [UNKNOWN]: Hey, that was my buddy.
01:08:55 --> 01:08:56 [UNKNOWN]: I don't want to leave him here in the mud.
01:08:57 --> 01:08:58 [UNKNOWN]: That's profound.
01:08:59 --> 01:09:00 [UNKNOWN]: Elephants bury their dead.
01:09:01 --> 01:09:01 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:09:01 --> 01:09:03 [UNKNOWN]: Dolphins mourn their dead.
01:09:03 --> 01:09:03 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:09:03 --> 01:09:09 [UNKNOWN]: There was a Orca mother in the prison down in the sea who was carrying the her dead.
01:09:09 --> 01:09:10 [UNKNOWN]: The dead baby.
01:09:10 --> 01:09:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, for like months.
01:09:12 --> 01:09:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:09:16 --> 01:09:18 [UNKNOWN]: I guess it depends on how you're defining sentient.
01:09:18 --> 01:09:21 [UNKNOWN]: I think there are many, I think most animals species are sentient.
01:09:22 --> 01:09:24 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, the orders of intelligence, I guess.
01:09:24 --> 01:09:26 [UNKNOWN]: Or just a point that's for sure.
01:09:26 --> 01:09:35 [UNKNOWN]: But some people have very sapient as like humans and then sentient as some lower forms of intelligence.
01:09:35 --> 01:09:35 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
01:09:36 --> 01:09:38 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I mean, I don't even want to talk about this.
01:09:38 --> 01:09:38 [UNKNOWN]: He's very long.
01:09:38 --> 01:09:40 [UNKNOWN]: Because it's really not a lot of content.
01:09:40 --> 01:09:45 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's mostly just like around your kind of eating going introverted.
01:09:46 --> 01:09:47 [UNKNOWN]: And you got his crackers.
01:09:48 --> 01:09:52 [UNKNOWN]: He's crunched crackers and then he's like, all right, all right, fine.
01:09:52 --> 01:09:56 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe I maybe I am being an asshole, but basically his whole arc.
01:09:59 --> 01:10:01 [UNKNOWN]: All right, quickly on the Trebuchets.
01:10:01 --> 01:10:06 [UNKNOWN]: I just thought it was interesting that Marnook mentioned Trebuchets and not catapults.
01:10:06 --> 01:10:09 [UNKNOWN]: And just really quickly, I'll be very brief about this.
01:10:09 --> 01:10:19 [UNKNOWN]: A Trebuchet is a type of catapult, but a catapult that we mostly think of is a torsion catapult where the energy is stored in twisted ropes.
01:10:20 --> 01:10:31 [UNKNOWN]: Whereas a treble-shay is a counterweight that uses gravity acting on a falling counterweight to rotate a lever and swing a sling to launch a projectile.
01:10:32 --> 01:10:41 [UNKNOWN]: And you can have a traction treble-shay, which is powered by teams of people pulling on ropes, or you can have a counterweight treble-shay, which is gravity, which sort of swings around and throws it.
01:10:42 --> 01:10:48 [UNKNOWN]: A lot of people like all treble shades are so cool and all this kind of stuff neither is inherently better or worse.
01:10:48 --> 01:10:54 [UNKNOWN]: They're just two different tools and they perform similar functions.
01:10:54 --> 01:10:58 [UNKNOWN]: treble shades can throw bigger stones further, but they're much more mechanically complex.
01:11:01 --> 01:11:17 [UNKNOWN]: A torsion catapults is mechanically complex, but it's typically smaller and easier to construct, but it takes a lot more technological care to handle the twisting ropes, the right fibers, and layering everything correctly, so.
01:11:18 --> 01:11:22 [UNKNOWN]: I just thought it was interesting that Marnook said Trebuchet, so I fell down a Trebuchet rabbit hole.
01:11:22 --> 01:11:24 [UNKNOWN]: And he'll get really offended if you can't even wrong one.
01:11:24 --> 01:11:26 [UNKNOWN]: Like he's like, he's no, it's a Trebuchet.
01:11:26 --> 01:11:27 [UNKNOWN]: It's a Trebuchet.
01:11:28 --> 01:11:30 [UNKNOWN]: You should get together with Brent Devaroe.
01:11:30 --> 01:11:32 [UNKNOWN]: He's very well known in Tolkien circles.
01:11:32 --> 01:11:35 [UNKNOWN]: He has a a medieval armor log type.
01:11:36 --> 01:11:36 [UNKNOWN]: He is.
01:11:37 --> 01:11:40 [UNKNOWN]: I can't remember if it's a blog of unmitigated pedentry.
01:11:41 --> 01:11:47 [UNKNOWN]: But he focuses on a number of different Tolkien presentations, including the Jackson films and
01:11:48 --> 01:11:54 [UNKNOWN]: You know, talks about why Salaron was a dummy woman and had no clue of how to handle it.
01:11:54 --> 01:11:55 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:11:55 --> 01:11:56 [UNKNOWN]: A seizure, turning them the kind.
01:11:56 --> 01:12:02 [UNKNOWN]: So I'd love to put you two together in your room and up the mics and just sit and listen for four hours.
01:12:02 --> 01:12:03 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe maybe we could have him on.
01:12:04 --> 01:12:05 [UNKNOWN]: It would be a lot of fun.
01:12:05 --> 01:12:05 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:12:06 --> 01:12:07 [UNKNOWN]: I can't say I know him.
01:12:07 --> 01:12:08 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:12:08 --> 01:12:09 [UNKNOWN]: You know, I can.
01:12:09 --> 01:12:09 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe he knows you.
01:12:10 --> 01:12:11 [UNKNOWN]: I doubt it.
01:12:11 --> 01:12:11 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:12:12 --> 01:12:12 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway.
01:12:13 --> 01:12:13 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:12:13 --> 01:12:15 [UNKNOWN]: Well, let's move on after this break.
01:12:37 --> 01:12:38 [UNKNOWN]: We are back and we need some intel.
01:12:39 --> 01:12:41 [UNKNOWN]: One of the nuzzle-goole turns a bird into a crow.
01:12:42 --> 01:12:43 [UNKNOWN]: It seems like a crow to me.
01:12:43 --> 01:12:44 [UNKNOWN]: Do you too agree?
01:12:45 --> 01:13:07 [UNKNOWN]: it was a corvette of some kind of a black bird it's certainly it certainly wasn't a raven somebody someone said to me if you're wondering if it's a raven it's not a raven but it right no ravens are quite quite distinct if somebody said crackle and because they no no seriously because they noticed of the sort of the iridescent colors that crackles can sometimes have
01:13:09 --> 01:13:16 [UNKNOWN]: It rattles love to go in flux, but yeah, I mean, grapples don't seem to be nearly menacing enough, so.
01:13:16 --> 01:13:21 [UNKNOWN]: And it looked like an oversized house sparrows, so it started off life as that.
01:13:23 --> 01:13:27 [UNKNOWN]: I can grow allies to meet the other spies circling Sauron on his balcony.
01:13:29 --> 01:13:34 [UNKNOWN]: Saron discusses with one of his works that, Marnook is leading the Elves North.
01:13:35 --> 01:13:37 [UNKNOWN]: He demands more information about Marnook.
01:13:38 --> 01:13:43 [UNKNOWN]: Later, Saron learns that Marnook was at Auregion, as he claims a new Naznic rule.
01:13:45 --> 01:13:51 [UNKNOWN]: Saron interrogates the Auregion Elves Caramir and Ellis, who were in a labor pit.
01:13:51 --> 01:13:53 [UNKNOWN]: He offers them water, but they are suspicious.
01:13:54 --> 01:13:56 [UNKNOWN]: He also offers Ellis a brooch that he has repaired.
01:13:57 --> 01:14:01 [UNKNOWN]: When Ella's drinks the water, she quickly shows signs of fire drug poisoning.
01:14:02 --> 01:14:07 [UNKNOWN]: Sarah on offers the interview, and to note only, if they will help him with their knowledge of Marnook.
01:14:08 --> 01:14:15 [UNKNOWN]: Caramir says he and Ellis were left in with the care of the another work as Marnu had led the other prisoners north.
01:14:16 --> 01:14:23 [UNKNOWN]: Saran gives him the antidote and determines there is a Smith left and he must beat the elves to her.
01:14:23 --> 01:14:27 [UNKNOWN]: Before Caramir can get the antidote open Ellis breathe fire.
01:14:28 --> 01:14:33 [UNKNOWN]: Saran asks the orc to settle his flying beast.
01:14:36 --> 01:14:42 [UNKNOWN]: one of the interesting things in this is that Sauron appears to be genuinely unaware of what Marnook is up to.
01:14:42 --> 01:15:00 [UNKNOWN]: I know there was some back and forth discussion is this, you know, false defection operation, sort of provocative agent thing or, you know, what did Marnook actually tell him or not is Marnook really is this just like a deception with an deception kind of
01:15:06 --> 01:15:08 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think so.
01:15:09 --> 01:15:10 [UNKNOWN]: That seems to be what they're giving us.
01:15:12 --> 01:15:18 [UNKNOWN]: Now, if you are running a false deception or a false defection operation,
01:15:20 --> 01:15:41 [UNKNOWN]: having your own side chase you, certainly adds to your bonafights, and hey yeah, this guy is like really legit, because they really are hunting him, but then you can't trust that your own side wouldn't, you know, get you, like no, no, no, really, it was a, it was a, it was a, you know, a false false thing all along.
01:15:42 --> 01:15:42 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:15:42 --> 01:15:54 [UNKNOWN]: And there's very few actual documented cases of somebody defecting, but as a false defection to trick both sides.
01:15:54 --> 01:16:03 [UNKNOWN]: But then really, no, I was on my side the the whole time, you know, on the originating side the whole time, but it's a pretty standard movie trope.
01:16:03 --> 01:16:07 [UNKNOWN]: So, you know, I think they're and I think they're building it so that we're not going to know
01:16:09 --> 01:16:33 [UNKNOWN]: Ultimate motivations until we know what his ultimate boat like when they tell us then we'll know but other than other than That we're gonna be in this like is he isn't he kind of thing all the way through a storyline and we'll only know the answer Once when we do we leave the whole situation or he dies before we leave the whole situation And all this layer upon layer upon layers yeah
01:16:35 --> 01:16:38 [UNKNOWN]: I could never do that kind of thing, I just- dramatic tension.
01:16:38 --> 01:16:39 [UNKNOWN]: dramatic tension.
01:16:40 --> 01:16:47 [UNKNOWN]: I did notice that, uh, Sauron's balcony window though, it is very much eye-shaped, it's very, oh void.
01:16:47 --> 01:16:48 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
01:16:48 --> 01:17:01 [UNKNOWN]: Well, there's one, there's one's oval kind of the thing, but there's also very wide, flat balcony, which again, I think, imitates, but Kella put a barhead in his, oh, study space.
01:17:01 --> 01:17:01 [UNKNOWN]: Rimmby?
01:17:03 --> 01:17:06 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that was new to you, calling in Brimby.
01:17:07 --> 01:17:10 [UNKNOWN]: Everybody on the, yeah, people were on the discord where we're chatting about that today.
01:17:10 --> 01:17:16 [UNKNOWN]: I was trying to get a few people to write in some more of the more humorous nicknames that some of the characters have.
01:17:17 --> 01:17:19 [UNKNOWN]: There have been a lot of them for killing a little bit and more, that's for sure.
01:17:19 --> 01:17:20 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:17:20 --> 01:17:22 [UNKNOWN]: So David, I see you have a lower question.
01:17:23 --> 01:17:26 [UNKNOWN]: I do, which Laura question I have a fire Drake question.
01:17:26 --> 01:17:27 [UNKNOWN]: That's the one.
01:17:27 --> 01:17:33 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, so I do have to say, I think the best, the funniest thing in the scene was the Elvis exploding.
01:17:33 --> 01:17:34 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
01:17:34 --> 01:17:34 [UNKNOWN]: I thought I'm so weird.
01:17:36 --> 01:17:45 [UNKNOWN]: They cut the edited it perfectly like don't go boom and it was a it was a great bit of visual Commit you know a physical humor.
01:17:45 --> 01:17:47 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm sorry elves that blew up.
01:17:47 --> 01:17:49 [UNKNOWN]: Well What's funny about it?
01:17:50 --> 01:17:50 [UNKNOWN]: What's funny about that?
01:17:51 --> 01:17:54 [UNKNOWN]: I really didn't what I put it go ahead say say what's happened say what's funny David?
01:17:56 --> 01:18:00 [UNKNOWN]: It was, it was a visual argument, all right, all right.
01:18:00 --> 01:18:01 [UNKNOWN]: She was, I was meant to burp with it.
01:18:01 --> 01:18:06 [UNKNOWN]: She burped and she blew up the, the Elf Protection Agency will be calling in.
01:18:06 --> 01:18:06 [UNKNOWN]: That's fine.
01:18:06 --> 01:18:07 [UNKNOWN]: That's fine.
01:18:08 --> 01:18:10 [UNKNOWN]: I was so sad for her partner.
01:18:10 --> 01:18:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, it's not for her.
01:18:12 --> 01:18:14 [UNKNOWN]: Couldn't open the damn, I may be there.
01:18:14 --> 01:18:15 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, the file.
01:18:15 --> 01:18:17 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe it wasn't even an antidote, you know.
01:18:17 --> 01:18:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's a sound.
01:18:18 --> 01:18:19 [UNKNOWN]: We're dealing with.
01:18:19 --> 01:18:19 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
01:18:19 --> 01:18:21 [UNKNOWN]: I think regardless of what they did,
01:18:22 --> 01:18:50 [UNKNOWN]: they were they were doing true anyway so yeah it was a very standard like I'm gonna give you water but it's actually gonna be poison now and to my questions before I give you the antidote I was like all right this is a very like doctor evil type of you know Sarah on stroking a white cat well he's question yeah well we seem to be losing some of Sarah's layers if you will or
01:18:53 --> 01:18:56 [UNKNOWN]: We had them when he was working with Kele Brumboar.
01:18:58 --> 01:19:00 [UNKNOWN]: But he doesn't appear to be terribly nuanced.
01:19:01 --> 01:19:01 [UNKNOWN]: He's just gone.
01:19:01 --> 01:19:03 [UNKNOWN]: No, no, he's fully open to you.
01:19:03 --> 01:19:06 [UNKNOWN]: Both of you, let's be the Dark Lord.
01:19:06 --> 01:19:07 [UNKNOWN]: And that's that.
01:19:07 --> 01:19:14 [UNKNOWN]: So what is it for you?
01:19:14 --> 01:19:16 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry, I, we got it.
01:19:16 --> 01:19:19 [UNKNOWN]: God, just go back to the fire drink thing.
01:19:20 --> 01:19:21 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:19:21 --> 01:19:22 [UNKNOWN]: A fire drink.
01:19:23 --> 01:19:46 [UNKNOWN]: or an urlokki, I love koini because it's so much like a finish, is there are those of the fire breathing dragons in Tolkien's writings, and it's possible they were subspecies because there are some dragons that don't breathe fire, but that Carl ran into with the things, smile against the most favours, example of an urlokki, but he's also a
01:19:53 --> 01:19:55 [UNKNOWN]: or we've earned this another term for that.
01:19:56 --> 01:19:56 [UNKNOWN]: Interesting.
01:19:57 --> 01:20:03 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, there were several fire drakes at the siege of Gondolin, but all of it, a few of them were killed.
01:20:04 --> 01:20:11 [UNKNOWN]: And the remnant fled to the northern regions way further inland of Balaurean, of course.
01:20:13 --> 01:20:18 [UNKNOWN]: And similar locations to Gandabad, but possibly even further east than that,
01:20:24 --> 01:20:35 [UNKNOWN]: as we know from reading the Hobbit that once the lonely mountain dwarves had built up their treasures and whatnot, that was when smout became interested in drooling down and caused havoc.
01:20:36 --> 01:20:37 [UNKNOWN]: So that's a fire drake.
01:20:37 --> 01:20:46 [UNKNOWN]: I've never heard of using fire drake venom or saliva or whatever was he was supposed to be using, but that's, that's a thing, that's fine.
01:20:47 --> 01:20:51 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I think it's totally within Saran's purview, right?
01:20:51 --> 01:21:00 [UNKNOWN]: Like this, this turning people against each other with this kind of deception, toying with them, to make them feel like they have hope.
01:21:00 --> 01:21:02 [UNKNOWN]: That reads very saran for me.
01:21:03 --> 01:21:13 [UNKNOWN]: As much as it was a cartoonish moment, I do think that saran gets to that level of cartoonish villainy, villainhood villainy at certain points.
01:21:14 --> 01:21:16 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and that comes back to what I was saying before.
01:21:16 --> 01:21:19 [UNKNOWN]: He'd no longer has nuance.
01:21:20 --> 01:21:24 [UNKNOWN]: It's really getting pretty difficult to have any, yeah, exactly David.
01:21:24 --> 01:21:25 [UNKNOWN]: He's doing the mustache poorly near.
01:21:26 --> 01:21:33 [UNKNOWN]: It's very difficult to have anything even resembling a semblance of an Iota of a jot.
01:21:33 --> 01:21:38 [UNKNOWN]: Well, and the question is, was he at all sympathetic in previous seasons?
01:21:38 --> 01:21:40 [UNKNOWN]: Or was that all that act in a deception?
01:21:41 --> 01:21:42 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think it was an act.
01:21:43 --> 01:21:47 [UNKNOWN]: No, you think he had real feelings for Galadriel and he wanted to raise her up as a queen.
01:21:47 --> 01:21:49 [UNKNOWN]: And yes, okay.
01:21:49 --> 01:21:56 [UNKNOWN]: Believes that he did, you know, whether when push comes to shove, whether it would actually have born true, I don't know.
01:21:57 --> 01:22:00 [UNKNOWN]: His therapist says the real deception is the one he gives himself as that we're saying.
01:22:01 --> 01:22:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:22:01 --> 01:22:04 [UNKNOWN]: Well, and that's exactly what the ghost of the Libre and more says to him.
01:22:05 --> 01:22:05 [UNKNOWN]: Jack.
01:22:06 --> 01:22:10 [UNKNOWN]: You know, you are the Lordist or this is before he was the ghost, he said,
01:22:10 --> 01:22:13 [UNKNOWN]: you and Deter the Lord of deception, you can even deceive yourself.
01:22:14 --> 01:22:20 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, but I would laugh if we had him, I want to see Charlie Vickers lying down on a couch and then work therapist.
01:22:21 --> 01:22:22 [UNKNOWN]: What's I supposed to be the problem?
01:22:25 --> 01:22:27 [UNKNOWN]: There you two hot on yourself, Doc Lord.
01:22:29 --> 01:22:35 [UNKNOWN]: There was a moment when he was talking with Theo in the last episode.
01:22:36 --> 01:22:43 [UNKNOWN]: where as Theo is talking about his history and his family and stuff like that, that I thought I read on Charlie Vickers face.
01:22:45 --> 01:23:01 [UNKNOWN]: actual empathy, like that Sauron was really empathizing with him, not just sympathizing and so it's not that he can't feel those emotions or have those emotions.
01:23:01 --> 01:23:05 [UNKNOWN]: But he is also trying to he's working for a better world, right?
01:23:05 --> 01:23:08 [UNKNOWN]: You know, once, you know, I've got a grand plan that's
01:23:16 --> 01:23:29 [UNKNOWN]: But if he has empathy, he's using it, he uses it against these two at poor elves that he ends up blowing up and because he's totally manipulating the spouse, right?
01:23:29 --> 01:23:31 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think he has empathy, David.
01:23:31 --> 01:23:32 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:23:32 --> 01:23:35 [UNKNOWN]: Again, the Kelley put in Barco's to sister him.
01:23:36 --> 01:23:37 [UNKNOWN]: Missing machinery.
01:23:37 --> 01:23:37 [UNKNOWN]: Connection?
01:23:37 --> 01:23:41 [UNKNOWN]: You're missing the, you're missing the capacity for that.
01:23:41 --> 01:23:44 [UNKNOWN]: So don't confuse yourself that we were partners.
01:23:45 --> 01:23:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think we do.
01:23:46 --> 01:23:58 [UNKNOWN]: I think we do need to I think we do need to psychoanalyze a salarone at some point here We're gonna get somebody on He has got more got that issue so bad.
01:23:58 --> 01:23:59 [UNKNOWN]: He's under percent.
01:23:59 --> 01:24:11 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah So yeah, we plenty plenty to go on with salarone here, but I want to talk about some other my R And so we need the secret fire
01:24:12 --> 01:24:13 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, really quick to up before we do that.
01:24:14 --> 01:24:19 [UNKNOWN]: It's just annoying that they're hiding the whole like, who was that ring bear that he just crowned?
01:24:19 --> 01:24:20 [UNKNOWN]: So was it Theo?
01:24:20 --> 01:24:23 [UNKNOWN]: It's like, that was cheaply and lazy.
01:24:23 --> 01:24:26 [UNKNOWN]: I just, that is lazy to not just reveal it.
01:24:26 --> 01:24:28 [UNKNOWN]: Again, it's the best they're doing it for a purpose.
01:24:29 --> 01:24:32 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, the best plot twist or not, what will happen?
01:24:32 --> 01:24:34 [UNKNOWN]: It's what will happen next.
01:24:34 --> 01:24:37 [UNKNOWN]: And what is the reaction going to be of other people?
01:24:38 --> 01:24:41 [UNKNOWN]: It is, how, what are the implications of this?
01:24:41 --> 01:24:43 [UNKNOWN]: That's the best cliffhanger.
01:24:44 --> 01:24:49 [UNKNOWN]: Cliffhanger's versus game changers is the best way I've heard it termed.
01:24:50 --> 01:24:51 [UNKNOWN]: And this was not a game changer.
01:24:52 --> 01:24:52 [UNKNOWN]: This was a cliffhanger.
01:24:53 --> 01:24:54 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I don't know what I'm going to say.
01:24:54 --> 01:24:55 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it is my way.
01:24:55 --> 01:24:56 [UNKNOWN]: Let's talk about rabbits and fire.
01:24:57 --> 01:24:58 [UNKNOWN]: Let's talk about rabbits and fires.
01:24:58 --> 01:25:00 [UNKNOWN]: And Tom Bobbittal, whatever he is.
01:25:01 --> 01:25:01 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, that.
01:25:02 --> 01:25:08 [UNKNOWN]: Moving on to the secret fire at Tom's house, Gandalf proposes, turning their effort defeating the dark wizard.
01:25:09 --> 01:25:11 [UNKNOWN]: Tom is skeptical of the simplicity.
01:25:12 --> 01:25:15 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf becomes angry and demands answers.
01:25:15 --> 01:25:23 [UNKNOWN]: In plain speaking, Tom suggests he returned to the Willy window and called Barry, but Gandalf stops him and receives a hint to his quest in song.
01:25:25 --> 01:25:32 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf does, as Tom asks, and hunts a rabbit, but as he chases it through a stone arch, the rabbit turns into a flame.
01:25:33 --> 01:25:38 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf recognizes the secret fire which speaks to him of being within all beings.
01:25:39 --> 01:25:43 [UNKNOWN]: The secret fire reveals the Gandalf that there were five wizards sent to save Middle Earth.
01:25:44 --> 01:25:49 [UNKNOWN]: The dark wizard was once called Palando and he was sent to protect the land with his partner.
01:25:51 --> 01:25:54 [UNKNOWN]: When he killed his partner, Rune was laid to waste.
01:25:55 --> 01:26:01 [UNKNOWN]: The secret fire tells Gandalf to save Palando and together prevent the armies of Rune from joining Sauron.
01:26:01 --> 01:26:04 [UNKNOWN]: Gandalf returns to an empty house and claims Tom's hat.
01:26:07 --> 01:26:15 [UNKNOWN]: And if you check the show guide, my god, did I get a still of him looking exactly like Ian McKellon?
01:26:15 --> 01:26:16 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, really?
01:26:16 --> 01:26:17 [UNKNOWN]: Nice.
01:26:17 --> 01:26:19 [UNKNOWN]: I'm gonna go look at that now.
01:26:19 --> 01:26:21 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was so deliberate.
01:26:21 --> 01:26:26 [UNKNOWN]: Like they freeze him exactly right to look like sur McKellon.
01:26:26 --> 01:26:27 [UNKNOWN]: In the doorway, yeah.
01:26:28 --> 01:26:28 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:26:28 --> 01:26:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:26:29 --> 01:26:32 [UNKNOWN]: Did we like the hat getting stuff?
01:26:34 --> 01:26:34 [UNKNOWN]: It's fine.
01:26:35 --> 01:26:37 [UNKNOWN]: It was like, I, I, I feel nothing about it.
01:26:37 --> 01:26:41 [UNKNOWN]: You know what, there was no, I wasn't like, oh my God, he has the hat.
01:26:41 --> 01:26:43 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, okay, he's got the hat.
01:26:43 --> 01:26:44 [UNKNOWN]: He's got the hat.
01:26:44 --> 01:26:45 [UNKNOWN]: He's got the staff.
01:26:45 --> 01:26:50 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we knew he would get it from the very first time he saw Tom, because everybody said, oh, oh, let's get all's hat.
01:26:50 --> 01:26:51 [UNKNOWN]: What does Tom bomb it all doing?
01:26:51 --> 01:26:52 [UNKNOWN]: What's getting all's hat?
01:26:52 --> 01:26:52 [UNKNOWN]: Well, no, we know.
01:26:53 --> 01:26:53 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
01:26:54 --> 01:26:57 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't hear everybody saying that, but I can see why they would say that.
01:26:58 --> 01:26:58 [UNKNOWN]: So.
01:26:59 --> 01:27:03 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I guess I, and, and have it, or frequent more talking stuff.
01:27:06 --> 01:27:15 [UNKNOWN]: So, first of all, I just want to say beautiful, beautiful shots here, beautiful cinematography, beautiful CGI work, like it was very tasteful, I thought.
01:27:17 --> 01:27:21 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I mean, it was a beautiful, everyone's calling this the Burning Bush, right?
01:27:21 --> 01:27:25 [UNKNOWN]: Like David, you mentioned that I immediately was like, oh, we're doing Moses.
01:27:26 --> 01:27:47 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, a lot of people on the discord were about me were me Leo pointing uh oh it's Moses in the burning bush I have another theory, but let's go for the rest first got it Uh uh let's a couple of things to clear off for the quick here The trope watch killing the evil wizard to dispel the spell that's holding everybody else around them, right?
01:27:47 --> 01:27:53 [UNKNOWN]: So it's like killing the computer that's controlling all the evil robots or killing the hive queen to you know
01:27:53 --> 01:27:56 [UNKNOWN]: stop all the drones from, you know, doing all the stuff.
01:27:56 --> 01:28:04 [UNKNOWN]: So just kind of a funny thing that Gandalf calls out the, oh, maybe if we just take out him and we'll like dispel all the spells.
01:28:04 --> 01:28:11 [UNKNOWN]: So well, but I also think it's it's reflective of the real world where I think a lot of people are like, well,
01:28:11 --> 01:28:19 [UNKNOWN]: perhaps after certain leaders are out of power, everyone who helps them do the bad things will suddenly behave better.
01:28:19 --> 01:28:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:28:20 --> 01:28:21 [UNKNOWN]: And that's not how it works, right?
01:28:21 --> 01:28:25 [UNKNOWN]: Like the rot may come from the top, but it doesn't stop there.
01:28:25 --> 01:28:26 [UNKNOWN]: It's has spread.
01:28:26 --> 01:28:32 [UNKNOWN]: And you need to work together with this other guy to heal the body, not just cut off the head.
01:28:33 --> 01:28:34 [UNKNOWN]: Come to our, come as the person.
01:28:36 --> 01:28:42 [UNKNOWN]: Let's hope that that is the more nuanced storytelling that they're here about to engage in.
01:28:42 --> 01:28:44 [UNKNOWN]: I think they're leading to that.
01:28:44 --> 01:28:46 [UNKNOWN]: I think that is what they intend with this.
01:28:46 --> 01:28:52 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was incredibly hand-fisted to have this exposition dump of a secret flame.
01:28:53 --> 01:28:56 [UNKNOWN]: Just come out and be like, first of all, I talk now.
01:28:57 --> 01:29:01 [UNKNOWN]: Like, a hero is finally manifesting on Earth just to talk.
01:29:01 --> 01:29:02 [UNKNOWN]: What is happening here?
01:29:02 --> 01:29:03 [UNKNOWN]: No, no, no, no.
01:29:04 --> 01:29:07 [UNKNOWN]: That was one of my big questions for you both.
01:29:07 --> 01:29:10 [UNKNOWN]: There's like where the literature is arrow does arrow show up like this.
01:29:10 --> 01:29:13 [UNKNOWN]: So this is this I really want to hear Marilyn on this.
01:29:13 --> 01:29:17 [UNKNOWN]: So, Marilyn, let me set you up here and then I want you to go as, you know, for 20 minutes.
01:29:17 --> 01:29:18 [UNKNOWN]: I've ever learned things yet.
01:29:19 --> 01:29:26 [UNKNOWN]: But to me, I have always seen arrow as more of a deist type of entity, right?
01:29:27 --> 01:29:29 [UNKNOWN]: Of, I have set this into motion.
01:29:29 --> 01:29:38 [UNKNOWN]: And I might nudge a little here and there, but really, my agents like the Valar are going to see that the plan is executed.
01:29:39 --> 01:29:47 [UNKNOWN]: And it might need your reaction to this scene is to be very bothered that Erus speaks directly to get in off.
01:29:48 --> 01:29:48 [UNKNOWN]: What do you think?
01:29:51 --> 01:29:55 [UNKNOWN]: I think that they were dealing with a concept that
01:29:57 --> 01:29:58 [UNKNOWN]: This was not Eru speaking.
01:29:59 --> 01:30:00 [UNKNOWN]: Eru doesn't have vocal cords.
01:30:00 --> 01:30:08 [UNKNOWN]: Well, Eru sings, but I think this is how Gandalf is receiving the information.
01:30:09 --> 01:30:11 [UNKNOWN]: To him, there is a voice speaking to him.
01:30:12 --> 01:30:14 [UNKNOWN]: How many times have you heard religious people say I heard a voice?
01:30:15 --> 01:30:19 [UNKNOWN]: They don't mean literally in my ears like I had to turn off the radio to listen to it.
01:30:20 --> 01:30:28 [UNKNOWN]: they mean I received something and the best sense I can prefer to it is I heard something.
01:30:29 --> 01:30:42 [UNKNOWN]: So, no, I don't think, I'm not sure about the definition of deist, but I don't think that's exactly how Tolkien proceeds out of because you're forgetting Spivimi, shall prove
01:30:49 --> 01:30:52 [UNKNOWN]: they're the cure into the flaws.
01:30:53 --> 01:30:59 [UNKNOWN]: But that's kind of where I'm at is like, every is more like, I have set up this whole world.
01:30:59 --> 01:31:03 [UNKNOWN]: So that when you try to do a bad thing, it will be turned good, right?
01:31:03 --> 01:31:05 [UNKNOWN]: It's not that error is coming in every time a bad thing happens.
01:31:05 --> 01:31:06 [UNKNOWN]: No, no, no.
01:31:06 --> 01:31:08 [UNKNOWN]: Not running it or twisting it.
01:31:08 --> 01:31:16 [UNKNOWN]: It's that the world as designed does not allow a bad thing to only creep bad things.
01:31:16 --> 01:31:18 [UNKNOWN]: Well, let me ask you how would you
01:31:20 --> 01:31:25 [UNKNOWN]: a character that has only just recently recovered his own name and still doesn't understand his purposefully.
01:31:26 --> 01:31:27 [UNKNOWN]: Suddenly receives that information.
01:31:28 --> 01:31:34 [UNKNOWN]: Does that mean to receive it or should that be so ingrained in him that he figures it out for himself?
01:31:34 --> 01:31:35 [UNKNOWN]: Do you know what I mean?
01:31:35 --> 01:31:48 [UNKNOWN]: Like that says more to me how Tolkien's world works is that these people have this in these I know are have these instrumental qualities that manifest through
01:31:50 --> 01:31:56 [UNKNOWN]: And to me, it is very lazy for the conductor to stop the orchestra and say, violinist, you need to play these notes.
01:31:57 --> 01:31:59 [UNKNOWN]: No, one that's not what Edo does.
01:31:59 --> 01:32:01 [UNKNOWN]: But again, we're dealing with metaphors.
01:32:01 --> 01:32:03 [UNKNOWN]: We're dealing with a visual medium.
01:32:05 --> 01:32:09 [UNKNOWN]: If you look at strictly the print version, Edo sings the song.
01:32:10 --> 01:32:11 [UNKNOWN]: Everybody listens a long time.
01:32:12 --> 01:32:15 [UNKNOWN]: eventually they start to sing along one by one.
01:32:16 --> 01:32:19 [UNKNOWN]: Figuring out what is my part in this song?
01:32:19 --> 01:32:20 [UNKNOWN]: What am I doing?
01:32:21 --> 01:32:22 [UNKNOWN]: How am I supposed to fit in?
01:32:23 --> 01:32:28 [UNKNOWN]: And then over in the corner there, a melcore picks up a saxophone and starts to riff.
01:32:30 --> 01:32:32 [UNKNOWN]: That's not original to me, but I think it works.
01:32:32 --> 01:32:34 [UNKNOWN]: Totally what happens.
01:32:34 --> 01:32:39 [UNKNOWN]: So how do you how do you convey that in visual terms?
01:32:41 --> 01:32:42 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not like this.
01:32:42 --> 01:32:43 [UNKNOWN]: I agree it was clumsy.
01:32:43 --> 01:32:45 [UNKNOWN]: I agree there could have been much better ways of doing it.
01:32:46 --> 01:33:03 [UNKNOWN]: But once you have Tom Bombadillo in the scene and a lot of the supposed dramatic tension is gained all continuing to demand answers from him and Tom Beak, I can't give him to you because you're thinking a completely different terms.
01:33:04 --> 01:33:07 [UNKNOWN]: You're speaking Welsh and I'm speaking German.
01:33:08 --> 01:33:13 [UNKNOWN]: You're not listening to me because the way I speak is not something you can understand.
01:33:14 --> 01:33:19 [UNKNOWN]: For example, he says the only mess three Tom knows is to be a servant.
01:33:21 --> 01:33:23 [UNKNOWN]: Gendell still is not thinking in those terms.
01:33:23 --> 01:33:36 [UNKNOWN]: We've heard this message before, but he's so focused on how do I gain my power and he learns a little more each step along the way, from inner understanding, from experiential learning,
01:33:37 --> 01:33:38 [UNKNOWN]: whatever you want to call it.
01:33:39 --> 01:33:49 [UNKNOWN]: But my understanding, well, the only mastery that Tom knows is singing, which is why he starts in Wake Now, my very lead.
01:33:49 --> 01:33:53 [UNKNOWN]: Wake up, listen to what I've been telling you.
01:33:54 --> 01:34:00 [UNKNOWN]: I'm the embodiment of the song, and so when I sing, it's not just some silly little nursery rhyme.
01:34:01 --> 01:34:04 [UNKNOWN]: I am singing the way Ed or sang at the very beginning.
01:34:06 --> 01:34:07 [UNKNOWN]: He remembers the music.
01:34:08 --> 01:34:11 [UNKNOWN]: I think he's the embodiment of the music on Arata.
01:34:11 --> 01:34:21 [UNKNOWN]: Music is how Elru communicated with the Inaur and so music is how Tom communicates with Gandalf.
01:34:21 --> 01:34:26 [UNKNOWN]: And with the Hobbits, he focuses in according to the receiver.
01:34:28 --> 01:34:30 [UNKNOWN]: But he tells him, don't forget to sing along.
01:34:31 --> 01:34:33 [UNKNOWN]: Sing and Tom will be with you.
01:34:34 --> 01:34:43 [UNKNOWN]: Now we get a slightly different version of that in Lord of the Rings where he says to the Hobbits as they head towards the Baratheards if you get in trouble, sing this song and I'll come help you.
01:34:44 --> 01:34:46 [UNKNOWN]: Very simple straightforward, these are simple straightforward beings.
01:34:47 --> 01:34:49 [UNKNOWN]: He's talking to Amaya.
01:34:50 --> 01:34:54 [UNKNOWN]: He needs the Maya to recover and remember his Mayaness if you will.
01:34:55 --> 01:34:57 [UNKNOWN]: And I can't blame Gandalf from this understanding.
01:34:57 --> 01:34:58 [UNKNOWN]: He is incorporated.
01:34:59 --> 01:35:03 [UNKNOWN]: This is the first time we know of Maya being present in a physical format.
01:35:04 --> 01:35:06 [UNKNOWN]: It's all going to be very confusing.
01:35:07 --> 01:35:11 [UNKNOWN]: So, sing and Tom will be present, and that's exactly what happens.
01:35:13 --> 01:35:18 [UNKNOWN]: So, they name the speaker, the secret fire, because that's not what we all know.
01:35:18 --> 01:35:18 [UNKNOWN]: Go ahead.
01:35:19 --> 01:35:28 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, just real quick, the from a show writing standpoint and story crafting, and what they gave us on screen.
01:35:30 --> 01:35:41 [UNKNOWN]: felt really disjointed for me because on the one hand they were going with Tom and we have a great email from Marine about the songs as well so we need to make sure we get into that.
01:35:43 --> 01:35:47 [UNKNOWN]: But they were going for a kind of Mr. Miyagi wax on wax off kind of thing.
01:35:48 --> 01:35:50 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to show you how to do it by.
01:35:50 --> 01:35:56 [UNKNOWN]: So if you just sort of, you can't understand me because I'm talking in this really weird abstract way.
01:35:56 --> 01:35:59 [UNKNOWN]: You're trying to be very practical and down to Earth about it.
01:36:00 --> 01:36:05 [UNKNOWN]: Just follow what I do, just sort of mimic me and through these motions,
01:36:09 --> 01:36:27 [UNKNOWN]: that'll start to trigger your latent quote unquote memories or your hidden DNA sequencing that's going to activate your bias or whatever you anyway you the truth will be known and you will inhabit your power but then we go and then we're suddenly talking to a burning bush
01:36:33 --> 01:36:33 [UNKNOWN]: things.
01:36:33 --> 01:36:43 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, if it's like, if Arrow is, if we're in episode six, and and Gandalf is still not getting it, and Arrow is just like, oh, for God's sake.
01:36:43 --> 01:36:45 [UNKNOWN]: So I have to do the burning first thing for you.
01:36:45 --> 01:36:46 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, here I am.
01:36:46 --> 01:36:47 [UNKNOWN]: Here, I'm going to tell you what you need to do.
01:36:48 --> 01:36:57 [UNKNOWN]: So we just had this really for me from a story standpoint, just too disjointed processes by which truth is revealed.
01:36:57 --> 01:37:02 [UNKNOWN]: Well, and I think that they went to the concrete as much for the audience's sake as for kids.
01:37:02 --> 01:37:05 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you just had to move this along.
01:37:05 --> 01:37:08 [UNKNOWN]: Tom is a classic spiritual teacher.
01:37:08 --> 01:37:09 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:37:09 --> 01:37:14 [UNKNOWN]: You can listen to a text all day long, but you will not comprehend it.
01:37:14 --> 01:37:14 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:37:15 --> 01:37:20 [UNKNOWN]: If you're simply reading a reciting it, you have to listen with a capital L.
01:37:21 --> 01:37:27 [UNKNOWN]: listen with things other than your ears, and know that you won't get it right the first time or the 20th time.
01:37:27 --> 01:37:36 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, think of the, the colon in the, um, this end tradition, you know, it's a saying that doesn't make any sense at all.
01:37:36 --> 01:37:38 [UNKNOWN]: What was the sound of one, your clap?
01:37:38 --> 01:37:40 [UNKNOWN]: No, what was your face like before you were born?
01:37:40 --> 01:37:41 [UNKNOWN]: What is the sound of one hand clapping?
01:37:41 --> 01:37:43 [UNKNOWN]: Those are probably the best moments.
01:37:43 --> 01:37:47 [UNKNOWN]: That's not something that can be answered with logic or mental processing.
01:37:49 --> 01:37:51 [UNKNOWN]: it has to come about differently.
01:37:52 --> 01:37:56 [UNKNOWN]: And he's because he's focused on getting his power.
01:37:58 --> 01:38:00 [UNKNOWN]: Tom has to finally put it in plain words.
01:38:00 --> 01:38:02 [UNKNOWN]: You are not sentimental earth to defeat him.
01:38:03 --> 01:38:03 [UNKNOWN]: He's dope.
01:38:04 --> 01:38:05 [UNKNOWN]: Just stay in the film.
01:38:06 --> 01:38:14 [UNKNOWN]: But you see, the dope smack is not as valuable and is ingrained as the personal realization.
01:38:15 --> 01:38:18 [UNKNOWN]: You can true people, you can tell people all day long.
01:38:18 --> 01:38:21 [UNKNOWN]: Yep, yep, sit and silence for an hour and listen to the inner voice.
01:38:22 --> 01:38:25 [UNKNOWN]: A truth that you discover for yourself is always going to be more potent and powerful.
01:38:26 --> 01:38:26 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
01:38:26 --> 01:38:30 [UNKNOWN]: Then what a truth that is told to you or something that you read.
01:38:30 --> 01:38:32 [UNKNOWN]: And before you experience it, it's just a concept.
01:38:33 --> 01:38:33 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:38:34 --> 01:38:38 [UNKNOWN]: So you will eventually hear that voice sitting first to how silence for an hour.
01:38:39 --> 01:38:41 [UNKNOWN]: Writing a bar is something you have to do.
01:38:42 --> 01:38:45 [UNKNOWN]: And then once you have balance, you will have it forever.
01:38:450 --> 01:38:47 [UNKNOWN]: But I can't explain it to you.
01:38:48 --> 01:38:48 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:38:48 --> 01:38:51 [UNKNOWN]: First, you sit and science, and all you hear is your head.
01:38:51 --> 01:38:51 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:38:52 --> 01:39:00 [UNKNOWN]: and eventually you start to think about things other than just yourself and event you'll eventually the whole word is eventually well they didn't have eventually.
01:39:00 --> 01:39:01 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:39:01 --> 01:39:04 [UNKNOWN]: We're already season three in season five we got a lot of crown to cover.
01:39:05 --> 01:39:09 [UNKNOWN]: What I'm calling it is this this is Gandalf's wizard school.
01:39:10 --> 01:39:12 [UNKNOWN]: He got his BA when he said I am good.
01:39:13 --> 01:39:20 [UNKNOWN]: He got his MA when he finally got his staff and now he's got his PhD so he gets his hat.
01:39:21 --> 01:39:24 [UNKNOWN]: Because he's really... John, you're choked up with this.
01:39:26 --> 01:39:26 [UNKNOWN]: I just...
01:39:29 --> 01:39:35 [UNKNOWN]: I would say I would be a lot more generous with this scene if it happened at the end of season one.
01:39:360 --> 01:39:38 [UNKNOWN]: That's the last time I think.
01:39:38 --> 01:39:41 [UNKNOWN]: That was the last opportunity to do this scene.
01:39:41 --> 01:39:42 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:39:42 --> 01:39:43 [UNKNOWN]: Because...
01:39:43 --> 01:39:44 [UNKNOWN]: So compressed.
01:39:45 --> 01:39:50 [UNKNOWN]: You made a whole thing on a two season mystery box of who this guy is.
01:39:50 --> 01:39:53 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you can't now turn around.
01:39:55 --> 01:39:58 [UNKNOWN]: and short cut it because that made the first two seasons pointless.
01:39:59 --> 01:39:59 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're right.
01:39:59 --> 01:40:01 [UNKNOWN]: I think that's what the hero scene is.
01:40:01 --> 01:40:02 [UNKNOWN]: It's just like, oh shit.
01:40:02 --> 01:40:02 [UNKNOWN]: We're in a box.
01:40:02 --> 01:40:03 [UNKNOWN]: We got to just get out of this.
01:40:04 --> 01:40:04 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:40:04 --> 01:40:06 [UNKNOWN]: I literally did a sex marketer.
01:40:07 --> 01:40:12 [UNKNOWN]: I probably like they, they heard criticism of his arc going nowhere on the first two seasons.
01:40:12 --> 01:40:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:40:12 --> 01:40:13 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:40:13 --> 01:40:16 [UNKNOWN]: And they said, let's go in and let's spoon feed it.
01:40:17 --> 01:40:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yep, and that wasn't the pivot they needed.
01:40:20 --> 01:40:22 [UNKNOWN]: They needed to do more compelling writing on the slow burn.
01:40:23 --> 01:40:42 [UNKNOWN]: If they were going to go that way, or turn back time and give Gandalf his mission in season one, I could see even a one season mission on who is this guy, but two seasons, his whole arc being who am I, was just exhausting, and the way that he gets his name, don't you,
01:40:47 --> 01:40:53 [UNKNOWN]: This does not feel like somebody, five years have passed between seasons two and three.
01:40:54 --> 01:41:01 [UNKNOWN]: Are you telling me that Gandalf learned nothing in those five years and was going in the exact wrong direction while he was living with Tom Bambadil?
01:41:01 --> 01:41:03 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not sorry, but this is not credible to me.
01:41:04 --> 01:41:05 [UNKNOWN]: No, not at all.
01:41:05 --> 01:41:05 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying it at all.
01:41:05 --> 01:41:07 [UNKNOWN]: I'm saying I'm not saying you are.
01:41:07 --> 01:41:08 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying you are.
01:41:08 --> 01:41:09 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying you are.
01:41:09 --> 01:41:09 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying you are.
01:41:09 --> 01:41:10 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying you are.
01:41:10 --> 01:41:10 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:10 --> 01:41:10 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:10 --> 01:41:11 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:11 --> 01:41:11 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:11 --> 01:41:11 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:11 --> 01:41:11 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:12 --> 01:41:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:12 --> 01:41:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:12 --> 01:41:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:12 --> 01:41:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:12 --> 01:41:13 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:13 --> 01:41:13 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:13 --> 01:41:14 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:14 --> 01:41:14 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:14 --> 01:41:14 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:14 --> 01:41:15 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:15 --> 01:41:15 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:15 --> 01:41:15 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:15 --> 01:41:16 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:17 --> 01:41:17 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:17 --> 01:41:17 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:17 --> 01:41:18 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:18 --> 01:41:19 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:19 --> 01:41:19 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:19 --> 01:41:20 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:20 --> 01:41:20 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:20 --> 01:41:20 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:20 --> 01:41:21 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:21 --> 01:41:22 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:22 --> 01:41:22 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:22 --> 01:41:22 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:22 --> 01:41:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:23 --> 01:41:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:23 --> 01:41:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:24 --> 01:41:24 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:24 --> 01:41:24 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:24 --> 01:41:24 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:25 --> 01:41:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:25 --> 01:41:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:25 --> 01:41:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:25 --> 01:41:26 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not.
01:41:26 --> 01:41:26 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not
01:41:33 --> 01:41:56 [UNKNOWN]: the the vignette in one of the Douglas atom stories about the whale that is created over the surface of whatever planet that was and is the whale is falling through the sky going oh I've got a big tail and I got thrashed around and what is this for and then like before once he finally realizes that he's a whale slams into the surface the plan of the surface sorry spoilers for hitchhikers guide but
01:41:57 --> 01:42:19 [UNKNOWN]: the I am with John on this that it's it's sort of an exhausting thing and I really do think that they literally they were like uh... crud and then so they've just jacked they literally day a sex market nut it is that the expo you know enlightenment takes decades they didn't have decades but see I'm doing the enlightenment for five years that's my problem
01:42:20 --> 01:42:33 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, in the five years his solution is go beat up the bad guy and that's just not it does it I think David to this for, but it's just such a heel turn yeah like it's just so like
01:42:35 --> 01:42:37 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going from I need to beat the bad guy.
01:42:37 --> 01:42:39 [UNKNOWN]: His solution is violence, right?
01:42:39 --> 01:42:43 [UNKNOWN]: To know, do the exact opposite thing.
01:42:43 --> 01:42:51 [UNKNOWN]: And I just feel like if you're going to set up this whole thing where he's with Tom Bambito for five years, Mr. Miyagi, he better have something to show for that.
01:42:52 --> 01:42:55 [UNKNOWN]: Because otherwise, what the heck was he doing for five years?
01:42:55 --> 01:43:17 [UNKNOWN]: I totally would have bought a Tom Bombadill Enlightenment thing where something, you know, we go along, we go along, we go along and then suddenly Tom sings or does the thing and then like, Gandalf's eyes pop open and go, oh, I know what I am and what I need to go to.
01:43:18 --> 01:43:20 [UNKNOWN]: Well, let me tell you about hairs.
01:43:21 --> 01:43:23 [UNKNOWN]: not rabbits, but hairs.
01:43:23 --> 01:43:24 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:43:24 --> 01:43:27 [UNKNOWN]: They have strong association with pagan mythology and folklore.
01:43:27 --> 01:43:30 [UNKNOWN]: A white hair in particular is known to be a guide.
01:43:31 --> 01:43:31 [UNKNOWN]: And Omen.
01:43:32 --> 01:43:37 [UNKNOWN]: a liminal creature who moves between the world's, okay?
01:43:37 --> 01:43:38 [UNKNOWN]: Think about that.
01:43:38 --> 01:43:44 [UNKNOWN]: So at least they layered in something proper pure with the, with the, uh, the leg of morphs.
01:43:44 --> 01:43:53 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and they're, they're viewed as other because of things like they're really weird courting rituals in March when they literally box one of the other, yes.
01:43:53 --> 01:43:56 [UNKNOWN]: Up on their hind legs, so that's where you get matters in March here.
01:43:58 --> 01:44:01 [UNKNOWN]: There's all kinds of examples in British and English folklore.
01:44:01 --> 01:44:04 [UNKNOWN]: Now, you mentioned Alice on Wonderland in your notes.
01:44:05 --> 01:44:08 [UNKNOWN]: But there's also the Children's Green No Series.
01:44:09 --> 01:44:14 [UNKNOWN]: But most specifically, Terry Pratchett's Tiffany Aking story, I shall wear midnight.
01:44:15 --> 01:44:32 [UNKNOWN]: Centers around the behavior of hairs at a harvest season when the last cornstarchs are burned in the ground, and all the critters who were nesting their flee for their lives, and the hair is believed being pervious to fame, because it is so often seen to be leaping away from the flames during the burning.
01:44:33 --> 01:44:35 [UNKNOWN]: So a very powerful symbol of guidance,
01:44:36 --> 01:44:39 [UNKNOWN]: The fire being present, that's very druid.
01:44:39 --> 01:44:44 [UNKNOWN]: The fire at the center of stone circles, very druidic practice.
01:44:44 --> 01:44:47 [UNKNOWN]: It represents the off-win, the spirit of nature.
01:44:48 --> 01:44:49 [UNKNOWN]: Guys, I think symbolically.
01:44:50 --> 01:44:58 [UNKNOWN]: And to me, I just kept getting symbol after symbol, after symbol, I can't say whether or not the show runners with any of this.
01:44:59 --> 01:45:05 [UNKNOWN]: But I think the going to the Moses image is the first place that most people would go to.
01:45:08 --> 01:45:12 [UNKNOWN]: probably information that's very specific to England and to the British Isles.
01:45:12 --> 01:45:13 [UNKNOWN]: So thank you.
01:45:13 --> 01:45:22 [UNKNOWN]: There's a podcast that we can listen to to get these deeper, ritual meanings and symbolological, and symbolological, ice-beating, which well.
01:45:24 --> 01:45:27 [UNKNOWN]: these, uh, these, uh, hidden meanings.
01:45:27 --> 01:45:28 [UNKNOWN]: So that was good.
01:45:28 --> 01:45:30 [UNKNOWN]: Because I was like, what are these rabbits doing running around here?
01:45:30 --> 01:45:35 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, you know, and did you notice he first first following a gray hair?
01:45:36 --> 01:45:36 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:45:36 --> 01:45:38 [UNKNOWN]: And then it was a white hair.
01:45:38 --> 01:45:43 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, not unlike his own journey of getting off the gray to get off the white.
01:45:43 --> 01:45:44 [UNKNOWN]: I rest my kids.
01:45:45 --> 01:45:45 [UNKNOWN]: I rest my kids.
01:45:45 --> 01:45:47 [UNKNOWN]: My eyes recently popped open and I've hit every
01:45:49 --> 01:45:52 [UNKNOWN]: But that's what it feels like, that's exactly what happens.
01:45:52 --> 01:45:55 [UNKNOWN]: The Marilyn Miyagi School of Blacks on Blacks off.
01:45:56 --> 01:46:00 [UNKNOWN]: No, but being willing to go a little less literal.
01:46:02 --> 01:46:06 [UNKNOWN]: careful, but it's also very difficult because that's not over accustomed to.
01:46:07 --> 01:46:10 [UNKNOWN]: The druids got a very bad rap from the Romans.
01:46:11 --> 01:46:13 [UNKNOWN]: They cast all kinds of dispersions on them.
01:46:14 --> 01:46:22 [UNKNOWN]: And so, contemporary knowledge of it, it was mostly Christians who were practicing druids in the 16th and 17th centuries, which was kind of interesting.
01:46:22 --> 01:46:26 [UNKNOWN]: But they were looking at classical texts, but they moved beyond that because they weren't going to
01:46:31 --> 01:46:32 [UNKNOWN]: in the beginning.
01:46:33 --> 01:46:42 [UNKNOWN]: It's been refuted that they constructed Stonehenge, but you know, all kinds of things start to gather around powerful symbols.
01:46:43 --> 01:46:48 [UNKNOWN]: And a lot of what helps you interpret it is what you bring to it.
01:46:50 --> 01:46:53 [UNKNOWN]: So I think you can make a case that
01:46:55 --> 01:47:00 [UNKNOWN]: There was more going on here, and the only way they could represent it was in this visual.
01:47:00 --> 01:47:03 [UNKNOWN]: Now, saying all of that, John, I didn't like it much either.
01:47:03 --> 01:47:05 [UNKNOWN]: You're perfectly honest.
01:47:05 --> 01:47:11 [UNKNOWN]: You've been extraordinarily generous with this whole thing.
01:47:11 --> 01:47:15 [UNKNOWN]: They did later in the symbology quite well though.
01:47:15 --> 01:47:16 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:47:16 --> 01:47:20 [UNKNOWN]: There's aspects of it that I like, like I, first of all, beautiful, beautiful imagery.
01:47:20 --> 01:47:21 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, gorgeous.
01:47:22 --> 01:47:25 [UNKNOWN]: But it just felt like too little too late to me.
01:47:25 --> 01:47:31 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's less about the scene and more about the pivot when it comes to this character.
01:47:31 --> 01:47:32 [UNKNOWN]: I got it.
01:47:33 --> 01:47:36 [UNKNOWN]: What was he doing for five years where he needed this yield turn?
01:47:36 --> 01:47:39 [UNKNOWN]: He was in the desert for five years.
01:47:39 --> 01:47:40 [UNKNOWN]: Five years?
01:47:41 --> 01:47:41 [UNKNOWN]: Takes yes.
01:47:41 --> 01:47:45 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, Jesus wanted in the desert for 40 days and 40 nights.
01:47:45 --> 01:47:49 [UNKNOWN]: So he took the short route, but then he had kind of an end with, you know.
01:47:49 --> 01:47:50 [UNKNOWN]: He needed more time than Jesus.
01:47:52 --> 01:47:56 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, because he came in the comet, didn't know his own name, couldn't even speak.
01:47:57 --> 01:48:09 [UNKNOWN]: But that was very typical of a spiritual experience where you go along, you do the forms, you do what you're told, you follow the methods, all the violence I think, what the hell is this for?
01:48:10 --> 01:48:12 [UNKNOWN]: And then why day it comes clear?
01:48:13 --> 01:48:14 [UNKNOWN]: Which is the Miyagi story.
01:48:15 --> 01:48:15 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:48:16 --> 01:48:20 [UNKNOWN]: Which they didn't do in this, they did an exposition dump of a burning bush.
01:48:21 --> 01:48:36 [UNKNOWN]: and gave the audience some important information and it was in the meantime yes wasn't really even the burning bush it was just a flame yeah i know i'm sorry oh my god the rabbit burned up and i'm like yeah really not really what he's making a hash of the scene
01:48:36 --> 01:48:44 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, because it was a awkward because I'm like anything we'd seen previously We got almost no context for it.
01:48:44 --> 01:48:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and I could easily John I could easily envision the writer's room saying oh my god We got to hurry up this story.
01:48:50 --> 01:49:01 [UNKNOWN]: So let's boom just do this and people will understand or they won't and that's a band-aid off Can I tell you the easiest way to solve this problem without them hand-fisting the story?
01:49:02 --> 01:49:10 [UNKNOWN]: is Gandalf's whole thing is learning pity from Niana and using that as his superpower, right?
01:49:10 --> 01:49:12 [UNKNOWN]: Pity is his superpower into empathy.
01:49:13 --> 01:49:19 [UNKNOWN]: And it's done in his quotes to Frodo that are off-coded.
01:49:21 --> 01:49:28 [UNKNOWN]: We talked about it earlier today about, can you give them life, or if so, don't give them death?
01:49:28 --> 01:49:32 [UNKNOWN]: Talk about, talk about Gollum in general, like, you know, a pity state has had.
01:49:33 --> 01:49:38 [UNKNOWN]: And you could absolutely have him see the dark wizard beat down,
01:49:40 --> 01:49:52 [UNKNOWN]: and talk to Tom Bambadil and Tom Bambadil sort of talking him through those complicated feelings of I feel like I need to defeat this guy but I pity him.
01:49:54 --> 01:50:11 [UNKNOWN]: at this juncture like I feel like he's down and maybe there's an opening there and perhaps maybe one day he's doing something and he's just pondering the words of one of Tom songs and it kind of comes to him slowly like I think there's an opportunity here.
01:50:12 --> 01:50:21 [UNKNOWN]: There was a way to do this in a much less clumsy way and instead they went for spectacle over heart and that's what bothers me about
01:50:21 --> 01:50:25 [UNKNOWN]: You're going to hate this, John, but I'll tell you exactly where the show gained off the pity.
01:50:26 --> 01:50:27 [UNKNOWN]: It was from the hardwoods.
01:50:28 --> 01:50:28 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
01:50:29 --> 01:50:30 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're right.
01:50:31 --> 01:50:36 [UNKNOWN]: Other than the people they leave behind, but, you know, we could have the conversation again if you want to.
01:50:37 --> 01:50:37 [UNKNOWN]: I know.
01:50:37 --> 01:50:38 [UNKNOWN]: I know.
01:50:38 --> 01:50:39 [UNKNOWN]: We don't have to rehast this.
01:50:40 --> 01:50:40 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:50:40 --> 01:50:43 [UNKNOWN]: The fact is, season one, listeners, you'll hear all about it.
01:50:43 --> 01:50:44 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:44 --> 01:50:44 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:44 --> 01:50:45 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:45 --> 01:50:46 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:46 --> 01:50:47 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:47 --> 01:50:48 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:48 --> 01:50:49 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:49 --> 01:50:49 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:49 --> 01:50:50 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:50 --> 01:50:51 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:51 --> 01:50:52 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:52 --> 01:50:53 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:53 --> 01:50:54 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:54 --> 01:50:55 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:55 --> 01:50:56 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:56 --> 01:50:56 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:56 --> 01:50:57 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:57 --> 01:50:58 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:50:58 --> 01:51:00 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:51:00 --> 01:51:01 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:51:01 --> 01:51:01 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:51:01 --> 01:51:02 [UNKNOWN]: They have big hearts.
01:51:03 --> 01:51:06 [UNKNOWN]: They just had the long stick and they're just pushing people off the car.
01:51:07 --> 01:51:13 [UNKNOWN]: I was going to see if Marilyn would maybe read marines e-mail for us.
01:51:13 --> 01:51:14 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I'd love to.
01:51:15 --> 01:51:16 [UNKNOWN]: I enjoy marine great much.
01:51:16 --> 01:51:21 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sure you've been talking circles and she's a wonderful part of our
01:51:23 --> 01:51:24 [UNKNOWN]: and she is.
01:51:25 --> 01:51:38 [UNKNOWN]: She wrote in quite the, quite the, she was the, on the discord, it was like boom, she was just right there with the Tom Bombadil song stuff and I was like, oh, thank goodness for our community because I know that there are people who know this stuff out there because I did have a question about the songs.
01:51:38 --> 01:51:44 [UNKNOWN]: I think she says at the end that she gave a signal paper about this, but yeah, we're getting better.
01:51:44 --> 01:51:46 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, she, Tom Bombadil.
01:51:47 --> 01:51:58 [UNKNOWN]: So she writes, the song that Tom Bombadil sings to Gandalf, and episode three, is the incantation that he sings in book one, chapter eight, the fog, on the Barodian.
01:51:59 --> 01:52:09 [UNKNOWN]: To Waken Samarion Tippen from the Trance of the Barrowite, in the chapter Frodo, who was not yet in trance, found courage and resisted the temptation to flee.
01:52:11 --> 01:52:14 [UNKNOWN]: He fought the Barrowite and cut off its hand and Frodo,
01:52:15 --> 01:52:19 [UNKNOWN]: still needs help after this and remembers how to summon Tom.
01:52:20 --> 01:52:21 [UNKNOWN]: He taught them a rhyme to sing.
01:52:22 --> 01:52:28 [UNKNOWN]: Ho Tom Bombadil Tom Bombadilow by Waterwood and Hill by the Read and Milo.
01:52:29 --> 01:52:32 [UNKNOWN]: By fire, Sun and Moon, Harkin' Now and Hear us.
01:52:32 --> 01:52:35 [UNKNOWN]: Come Tom Bombadil for our need is near us.
01:52:36 --> 01:52:39 [UNKNOWN]: Interestingly, this is not the song Tom sings in this episode.
01:52:40 --> 01:52:44 [UNKNOWN]: Instead, he sings the incantation he uses to, ah, wait, wait, wait.
01:52:45 --> 01:52:46 [UNKNOWN]: Wake up!
01:52:47 --> 01:52:48 [UNKNOWN]: Bahabets from the spell.
01:52:49 --> 01:52:55 [UNKNOWN]: Wake now, my Mary Lads, wake in hear me calling, warm now, be heart and lamb, the stone, cold stone is fallen.
01:52:57 --> 01:53:03 [UNKNOWN]: Dark Doris, standing wide, dead hand is broken, night, under night is flown, and the gate is open.
01:53:04 --> 01:53:08 [UNKNOWN]: But Tom seems to be telling Gandalf to sing this song if he runs into trouble.
01:53:09 --> 01:53:13 [UNKNOWN]: Say, don't forget to sing, sing and Tom will be with you.
01:53:14 --> 01:53:17 [UNKNOWN]: Will we see Gandalf needing to summon Tom again down the road?
01:53:18 --> 01:53:24 [UNKNOWN]: Also, Tom's attire and dancing in this scene echoes an illustration by the Brother's Hildabrat from the 1976 J.R.R.R.
01:53:25 --> 01:53:26 [UNKNOWN]: Tolkien calendar.
01:53:28 --> 01:53:36 [UNKNOWN]: In addition, the stone room of the hut and light coming through the windows is also reminiscent of the text, and many illustrations of the barrels.
01:53:37 --> 01:53:47 [UNKNOWN]: Low door-like opening appeared at the end of the chamber beyond Brotus' feet, and there was Tom's head, hat feather in all, framed against the light of the rising sun, red behind him.
01:53:48 --> 01:53:52 [UNKNOWN]: The light fell upon the floor and upon the faces of three hobbits, lying the side Frodo.
01:53:53 --> 01:54:02 [UNKNOWN]: And she finishes by saying, I did a Signum Moot representation on illustrations for this chapter a couple of years ago, so I could go on all day, LOL.
01:54:03 --> 01:54:04 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks again for your coverage.
01:54:04 --> 01:54:16 [UNKNOWN]: Now, I want to go back to something she said that he does not sing the same song, and it's against the incantation.
01:54:16 --> 01:54:18 [UNKNOWN]: Wake now, my Mary, let's wake and hear me calling.
01:54:19 --> 01:54:21 [UNKNOWN]: If that is a spiritual direction, I don't know what it is.
01:54:23 --> 01:54:23 [UNKNOWN]: Wake up!
01:54:24 --> 01:54:25 [UNKNOWN]: Wake up!
01:54:25 --> 01:54:28 [UNKNOWN]: How long do I have to tell you and sing to you?
01:54:29 --> 01:54:35 [UNKNOWN]: I can't lay it out in, you know, paragraph one two three and four because that's not what we're talking about.
01:54:35 --> 01:54:41 [UNKNOWN]: This is about spiritual enlightenment and it's a very different thing.
01:54:44 --> 01:54:45 [UNKNOWN]: Which I hate to harp on it.
01:54:46 --> 01:54:51 [UNKNOWN]: It's incongruous because he didn't have the action
01:54:53 --> 01:55:00 [UNKNOWN]: that led to his realization and the embodiment of the truth, a burning thing just appeared before him.
01:55:01 --> 01:55:05 [UNKNOWN]: And that just feels like a little shortcut.
01:55:05 --> 01:55:08 [UNKNOWN]: It appeared before him because he did what Tom told him.
01:55:09 --> 01:55:09 [UNKNOWN]: Chase the rabbit.
01:55:09 --> 01:55:14 [UNKNOWN]: Followed the hair and he listened and he sung the song.
01:55:14 --> 01:55:41 [UNKNOWN]: okay okay so he was doing he was doing the things he was reciting his mantra you like I mean I do get to the point that we're you're like wine now right like there's it has there been a realization or a change that suddenly it's time to just be explicit there sure has that that's gonna appear in the hall yep stay
01:55:45 --> 01:55:45 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:55:46 --> 01:55:47 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:55:48 --> 01:55:49 [UNKNOWN]: I do.
01:55:49 --> 01:55:56 [UNKNOWN]: I do enjoy this idea that he can summon Tom at a very wands like he's in like a D&D party and they have to do his mind.
01:55:56 --> 01:55:58 [UNKNOWN]: They got to summon their their age.
01:55:59 --> 01:56:00 [UNKNOWN]: Broly and relax and check.
01:56:01 --> 01:56:06 [UNKNOWN]: I will be interested to see if the show enters decide to have Gantel.
01:56:07 --> 01:56:09 [UNKNOWN]: singing or reciting these words in the future.
01:56:10 --> 01:56:12 [UNKNOWN]: Whether or not Tom appears, I don't think he's going to.
01:56:13 --> 01:56:25 [UNKNOWN]: That seemed like a pretty clear exit, you know, what he walks back in and the the house's dark and it's dusty and all the windows are busted up and everything and the only thing that remains is the hat, just his mark of his PhD.
01:56:27 --> 01:56:42 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I do love this feedback, Maureen, so thank you for that, and it does make me feel better about the scene that he was using the wake-up song that he used to wake the Hobbit.
01:56:42 --> 01:56:43 [UNKNOWN]: That's fun.
01:56:43 --> 01:56:43 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
01:56:44 --> 01:56:44 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:56:44 --> 01:56:44 [UNKNOWN]: No.
01:56:44 --> 01:56:45 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks, Maureen.
01:56:45 --> 01:56:45 [UNKNOWN]: It was great.
01:56:48 --> 01:56:50 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I don't want to harp on this scene much.
01:56:50 --> 01:56:53 [UNKNOWN]: I, this is my hope for it because I did like the episode overall.
01:56:54 --> 01:56:57 [UNKNOWN]: My hope for it is they realized they needed a shortcut.
01:56:57 --> 01:56:57 [UNKNOWN]: They did it.
01:56:57 --> 01:56:58 [UNKNOWN]: It's done.
01:56:58 --> 01:57:00 [UNKNOWN]: Now we can have a good Gand off arc.
01:57:00 --> 01:57:00 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:57:01 --> 01:57:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:57:01 --> 01:57:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:57:01 --> 01:57:03 [UNKNOWN]: Let's move along with a Gand off story.
01:57:04 --> 01:57:04 [UNKNOWN]: I can tell you.
01:57:04 --> 01:57:06 [UNKNOWN]: I will forgive it if the rest of the arc is good.
01:57:07 --> 01:57:08 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, I'm with you.
01:57:09 --> 01:57:22 [UNKNOWN]: And we get to see these these two wizards try to reconcile and that could be some potentially interesting storylines about forgiveness and healing and sort of realization.
01:57:23 --> 01:57:24 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, wow, I did get off on the wrong.
01:57:24 --> 01:57:26 [UNKNOWN]: I'm on the wrong path and what happened.
01:57:26 --> 01:57:27 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, there could be some interesting stuff.
01:57:27 --> 01:57:37 [UNKNOWN]: Well, the other question I have is, will we get sort of a, uh, a success of Gandalf to turn back a wizard gone wrong?
01:57:38 --> 01:57:42 [UNKNOWN]: And that is why he tries to talk sense into Sarmon in the Lord of the Rings.
01:57:43 --> 01:57:45 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm, that would be nice.
01:57:45 --> 01:57:46 [UNKNOWN]: That's nice.
01:57:46 --> 01:57:54 [UNKNOWN]: I also have a thought based upon what we were talking about earlier, that the, the two blue wizards went into the east and failed.
01:57:55 --> 01:58:03 [UNKNOWN]: And a lot of people are unhappy about Gandalf appearing so early, maybe he's going to come back again in the third age.
01:58:03 --> 01:58:11 [UNKNOWN]: He's still getting off the gray, but having done his thing to minimize the ruin involvement with Sauron.
01:58:13 --> 01:58:16 [UNKNOWN]: He may well quote unquote die in the process.
01:58:17 --> 01:58:17 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:58:18 --> 01:58:20 [UNKNOWN]: And then be sent back after having some more chats with Nian.
01:58:20 --> 01:58:20 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:58:20 --> 01:58:21 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:58:22 --> 01:58:23 [UNKNOWN]: He's always getting response.
01:58:24 --> 01:58:24 [UNKNOWN]: Always getting extra life.
01:58:26 --> 01:58:32 [UNKNOWN]: I do like the idea, John, just from a, even from a minimal, like just a head cannon standpoint.
01:58:32 --> 01:58:51 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yeah, when he's talking to Saramon, he's seen this before, and he's trying, and maybe, yeah, like he's trying what maybe worked last time and it's not necessarily working this time, but I like the idea that that experience and knowledge is somewhere rattling around inside his head when he's arguing with Saramon.
01:58:51 --> 01:58:57 [UNKNOWN]: And this could also explain the line from Lord of the Rings, in which Gandalf recites his many names.
01:58:57 --> 01:59:01 [UNKNOWN]: Phantom of Inner, and ends by saying, to the East, I go not.
01:59:03 --> 01:59:03 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:59:04 --> 01:59:05 [UNKNOWN]: He doesn't say, I've never been there.
01:59:05 --> 01:59:06 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:59:07 --> 01:59:08 [UNKNOWN]: Or, I will never go there.
01:59:08 --> 01:59:10 [UNKNOWN]: He said, I will not.
01:59:10 --> 01:59:10 [UNKNOWN]: Now.
01:59:11 --> 01:59:11 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:59:12 --> 01:59:14 [UNKNOWN]: I, the East, I go not.
01:59:15 --> 01:59:18 [UNKNOWN]: Now, because I'm there already, and I know what went out.
01:59:19 --> 01:59:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, they're going to, they're going to change the writing in that in that they're going to retconner and go in the east.
01:59:23 --> 01:59:24 [UNKNOWN]: They call me Grand Elf.
01:59:25 --> 01:59:27 [UNKNOWN]: No, please go.
01:59:28 --> 01:59:30 [UNKNOWN]: We got one more piece of feedback.
01:59:30 --> 01:59:31 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:59:33 --> 01:59:33 [UNKNOWN]: To show all read it.
01:59:34 --> 01:59:34 [UNKNOWN]: Where do you want to go?
01:59:35 --> 01:59:35 [UNKNOWN]: John.
01:59:36 --> 01:59:36 [UNKNOWN]: I'll read it.
01:59:36 --> 01:59:40 [UNKNOWN]: You know what, Pellay writes in a friend of the pot.
01:59:41 --> 01:59:42 [UNKNOWN]: We have not seen for some time.
01:59:42 --> 01:59:44 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, Lord Gaper is back.
01:59:45 --> 01:59:49 [UNKNOWN]: And Haley says, I don't have a ton to say, well, I think you do.
01:59:50 --> 01:59:51 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're funny.
01:59:51 --> 01:59:57 [UNKNOWN]: Let's say on the discord, I love Marnuk and I hope he doesn't die anytime soon, but I don't believe he lasts much longer.
01:59:58 --> 02:00:06 [UNKNOWN]: What on earth is Galatriel doing writing into an orchestra on hold with the one thing she knows Sarah on really needs the ring stays in Rivendell.
02:00:06 --> 02:00:11 [UNKNOWN]: I got so mad she brought it I almost turned the show off that's incredibly irresponsible.
02:00:11 --> 02:00:15 [UNKNOWN]: It might even be the single stupidest move in the history of TV because she knows better.
02:00:15 --> 02:00:16 [UNKNOWN]: Is it arrogance addiction?
02:00:16 --> 02:00:19 [UNKNOWN]: A crunch to deal with in a hard time ahead?
02:00:19 --> 02:00:20 [UNKNOWN]: Either way, don't do that.
02:00:22 --> 02:00:23 [UNKNOWN]: I agree completely.
02:00:23 --> 02:00:26 [UNKNOWN]: I do think that's again, hand to the writer a bit.
02:00:27 --> 02:00:32 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, this episode had a bit too much Peter Jackson echo for my taste, you're with Marilyn.
02:00:33 --> 02:00:36 [UNKNOWN]: And the burning bush was a bit much last slot.
02:00:36 --> 02:00:43 [UNKNOWN]: I thought it was said that the blue wizards was off the table for Amazon to play with, but it seems that's no longer the case.
02:00:44 --> 02:00:47 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks for all the hard work this incredibly hard season.
02:00:48 --> 02:00:52 [UNKNOWN]: I have a hard time keeping up and all I have to do is watch and listen.
02:00:53 --> 02:00:55 [UNKNOWN]: See you on Discord and in episode 4.
02:00:56 --> 02:00:56 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks, Pilly.
02:00:57 --> 02:01:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so on the right thing, I don't fully understand their deal with the token estate.
02:01:02 --> 02:01:05 [UNKNOWN]: It's like a carve out for TV rather than
02:01:07 --> 02:01:09 [UNKNOWN]: Uh, you movies and we we had talked about this.
02:01:09 --> 02:01:12 [UNKNOWN]: We did like an episode bonus episode in the third age.
02:01:12 --> 02:01:12 [UNKNOWN]: Is second age.
02:01:12 --> 02:01:13 [UNKNOWN]: Oh my god.
02:01:13 --> 02:01:14 [UNKNOWN]: The second age.
02:01:14 --> 02:01:20 [UNKNOWN]: Um, that said I think they had to get special permission for that name because.
02:01:20 --> 02:01:21 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yeah.
02:01:21 --> 02:01:24 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think that that's anywhere on the lower to the rings.
02:01:24 --> 02:01:29 [UNKNOWN]: I want to double check that, but I'm 99% sure the polano is not named in the lower to the rings.
02:01:30 --> 02:01:45 [UNKNOWN]: they might have been writing up the storyline and then just said, you know, they might, I'm sure there's conversations going back between the, between the state and the studio and maybe the the state said, when you have requests, yeah, we'll entertain them.
02:01:45 --> 02:01:45 [UNKNOWN]: We knew that.
02:01:45 --> 02:01:48 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, they, they said that they would be on case by case basis.
02:01:49 --> 02:01:49 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:01:49 --> 02:01:51 [UNKNOWN]: So this is a case, this is a case, this is a case.
02:01:510 --> 02:01:59 [UNKNOWN]: I did just, I have the Kindle version of the Lord of the Rings complete and I did do a search for Palando and no, no, no, no,
02:02:00 --> 02:02:08 [UNKNOWN]: No, I think the first time we read those names is in unfinished tales, and I know that they appear in History of the Middle Earth.
02:02:09 --> 02:02:25 [UNKNOWN]: But I think you both have also already said that they have to re-op permissions every year, and you were speculating that was why they can own longer name a place in Nimenor,
02:02:27 --> 02:02:35 [UNKNOWN]: the previous season because they tried and lost that particular, or maybe they just said, you know, never mind that, we're more interested in this.
02:02:36 --> 02:02:46 [UNKNOWN]: So the whole thing about permissions seems to be pretty funjibble, so I mean, say, they can definitely mention anything that's named in the Lord of the Rings.
02:02:47 --> 02:02:49 [UNKNOWN]: Anything that is in the Lord of the Rings they can use.
02:02:56 --> 02:02:57 [UNKNOWN]: in the original edition.
02:02:57 --> 02:03:00 [UNKNOWN]: It wasn't until 1962 that they found the him in.
02:03:00 --> 02:03:02 [UNKNOWN]: So well, such a lawyer.
02:03:02 --> 02:03:03 [UNKNOWN]: They're talking sell the rights.
02:03:03 --> 02:03:10 [UNKNOWN]: What you're what year to talk in sell the rights to the Lord.
02:03:10 --> 02:03:11 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
02:03:12 --> 02:03:14 [UNKNOWN]: Why in expenses?
02:03:14 --> 02:03:15 [UNKNOWN]: 1969 he sold it.
02:03:15 --> 02:03:16 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, 60 is okay.
02:03:16 --> 02:03:19 [UNKNOWN]: It would have been including the appendices.
02:03:19 --> 02:03:22 [UNKNOWN]: And we knew that they had access to the appendices, anyway, they not said that.
02:03:22 --> 02:03:24 [UNKNOWN]: So sold it for a penny.
02:03:24 --> 02:03:25 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
02:03:25 --> 02:03:34 [UNKNOWN]: No, well, comparatively speaking, he sold it for a lot of money, but he needed it to pay his tax bill because, unexpectedly, the Lord of the Rings was a massive success.
02:03:34 --> 02:03:38 [UNKNOWN]: And suddenly he held this wealth coming in that he was hit not planned for, which...
02:03:38 --> 02:03:38 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
02:03:39 --> 02:03:41 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, how many of us wouldn't like to have that kind of problem, but still.
02:03:41 --> 02:03:42 [UNKNOWN]: He was like, oh no.
02:03:43 --> 02:03:44 [UNKNOWN]: But it was a problem.
02:03:45 --> 02:03:47 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he's wiping his face away with dollar bills.
02:03:48 --> 02:03:49 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
02:03:49 --> 02:03:49 [UNKNOWN]: Power bills.
02:03:50 --> 02:03:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:03:51 --> 02:03:53 [UNKNOWN]: Also, I wanted to just address one other point.
02:03:54 --> 02:03:55 [UNKNOWN]: Why does Galadriel bring the ring well?
02:03:56 --> 02:04:03 [UNKNOWN]: We see at least once why because it warns her of the approach of the rings.
02:04:03 --> 02:04:04 [UNKNOWN]: It helps help keep them safe.
02:04:05 --> 02:04:10 [UNKNOWN]: I get the sense that she won't part with it at all, that she's there will be no I might be a real real.
02:04:11 --> 02:04:20 [UNKNOWN]: I know when she will, at least when she will take it off, but I think it's a case of Lotho.
02:04:22 --> 02:04:25 [UNKNOWN]: I don't want to be accused of spying, I just mean a spoiling good lord.
02:04:25 --> 02:04:27 [UNKNOWN]: Are you talking about it in Lord of the Rings?
02:04:29 --> 02:04:35 [UNKNOWN]: I'm talking about the story that we understand from, I think it is from the second age.
02:04:38 --> 02:04:41 [UNKNOWN]: that they have altered significantly.
02:04:42 --> 02:04:42 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yes.
02:04:43 --> 02:04:44 [UNKNOWN]: I know I know what you're talking about.
02:04:44 --> 02:04:44 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:04:45 --> 02:04:45 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:04:45 --> 02:04:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:04:46 --> 02:04:46 [UNKNOWN]: I'm with you.
02:04:48 --> 02:04:51 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, well, I think that's it for our episode.
02:04:51 --> 02:04:58 [UNKNOWN]: Don't forget, you can get bonus content once we start putting those out, which we will very soon on the lower cast in the season pass.
02:04:58 --> 02:05:03 [UNKNOWN]: You can get the show guide, which is updated through episode four right now.
02:05:03 --> 02:05:06 [UNKNOWN]: That's what we updated further.
02:05:07 --> 02:05:09 [UNKNOWN]: That has a visual breakdown of the episode.
02:05:09 --> 02:05:10 [UNKNOWN]: It's the characters, the...
02:05:12 --> 02:05:14 [UNKNOWN]: the artifacts and the places.
02:05:14 --> 02:05:15 [UNKNOWN]: Oh my.
02:05:15 --> 02:05:16 [UNKNOWN]: It's a great time.
02:05:16 --> 02:05:18 [UNKNOWN]: So join us over there.
02:05:18 --> 02:05:22 [UNKNOWN]: There's even a power levels and elf flow chart.
02:05:23 --> 02:05:32 [UNKNOWN]: There's a how how how does this stuff all work together the elves and where they're from and and what they've seen and my god.
02:05:34 --> 02:05:34 [UNKNOWN]: I wonder who made it.
02:05:34 --> 02:05:35 [UNKNOWN]: They were brilliant.
02:05:36 --> 02:05:41 [UNKNOWN]: They absolutely were, they put it in a lot of time and effort and work, and we are all very grateful to him John Lorhead.
02:05:41 --> 02:05:45 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it was a lot of time last year, so we're let two years ago.
02:05:45 --> 02:05:50 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm glad that we still have it because it's nice to be like, oh, who was this actor?
02:05:50 --> 02:05:51 [UNKNOWN]: And then I can click on it.
02:05:52 --> 02:05:59 [UNKNOWN]: I've been fun this season too, because I've gotten to move people from the only
02:06:05 --> 02:06:08 [UNKNOWN]: And you got to move a few characters in the direction, didn't you?
02:06:09 --> 02:06:11 [UNKNOWN]: Well, they don't go to the historical least.
02:06:11 --> 02:06:13 [UNKNOWN]: They'll stay on screen, but I did label them to cease.
02:06:13 --> 02:06:15 [UNKNOWN]: To cease, exactly.
02:06:15 --> 02:06:15 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:06:16 --> 02:06:20 [UNKNOWN]: The Halls of Mando's in the section section of, uh, Oh, that's a great idea.
02:06:21 --> 02:06:22 [UNKNOWN]: I'm gonna change that now.
02:06:23 --> 02:06:25 [UNKNOWN]: If they're, uh, well, actually, I guess, there is.
02:06:25 --> 02:06:27 [UNKNOWN]: Everybody takes a little trip there.
02:06:27 --> 02:06:30 [UNKNOWN]: Human's go there first, but then they go somewhere else.
02:06:30 --> 02:06:30 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:06:32 --> 02:06:32 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:06:32 --> 02:06:34 [UNKNOWN]: Well, call it the Halls of Mando's.
02:06:35 --> 02:06:38 [UNKNOWN]: Well, don't forget to check out all our other shows.
02:06:38 --> 02:06:39 [UNKNOWN]: David, what do we have going on?
02:06:39 --> 02:06:43 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we had a Percy Jackson season preview with Marilyn and Alicia.
02:06:43 --> 02:06:45 [UNKNOWN]: That was just went out the other week.
02:06:46 --> 02:06:50 [UNKNOWN]: And we're going to be doing a mid-season chicken and a season wrap up on that.
02:06:51 --> 02:06:54 [UNKNOWN]: Our Godzilla coverage has concluded.
02:06:54 --> 02:06:56 [UNKNOWN]: We have a three-part series on Godzilla.
02:06:56 --> 02:07:03 [UNKNOWN]: We just did 40th anniversary for Aliens, the 1986 movie, and we had a really fun time on the community live watch.
02:07:04 --> 02:07:10 [UNKNOWN]: Vision Quest has concluded Alicia and John have recorded their final episode for that, and I believe
02:07:11 --> 02:07:17 [UNKNOWN]: that today they recorded their clay face episode so keep your eyes peeled for that to pop up in your feeds.
02:07:19 --> 02:07:36 [UNKNOWN]: Ron Dawson from Dunston's do rags and I will be covering Blade Runner 299 when that comes out and we've got a bunch of movie coverage coming up as well and got doomsday and doon 3 obviously we have to John we have to talk about.
02:07:38 --> 02:08:04 [UNKNOWN]: uh... naughty christmas the violent sand violent night what does that i know violent night to yeah that looks like a lot of fun in the mall yeah great so we were going to do some holiday movie coverage coming up in December so lots happening properly howard they're well into their next season of uh... unexpected uh... uh... double features as what you call them and uh... they just had an episode on the
02:08:05 --> 02:08:11 [UNKNOWN]: The movie Oh God with George Burns and you remember that Marilyn I loved it.
02:08:11 --> 02:08:12 [UNKNOWN]: I loved it.
02:08:12 --> 02:08:21 [UNKNOWN]: John Denver What was he thinking of when he gave it avocado such a big Exactly, no, not the neck of a giraffe
02:08:22 --> 02:08:34 [UNKNOWN]: So, and, uh, engines and do rags, they just, uh, they were covering carry, they just talked about, um, uh, you can see everything, and then they will be, uh, talking about rings of power as well.
02:08:34 --> 02:08:37 [UNKNOWN]: So, that should be very interesting.
02:08:38 --> 02:09:06 [UNKNOWN]: and uh... never mind the music continues uh... cosmic corner is that happening it's happening i would wear behind a week everybody was sick last week but uh... yeah it's it's coming we're almost over the first book so cool and there's some uh... cilmerian stuff bubbling in the background is cilmerian stuff the episodes are in the hopper i'll push him out excellent well uh... yeah maybe maybe next week we'll put out uh... uh... a uh... door yet that episode the net worth of the bides yeah
02:09:08 --> 02:09:11 [UNKNOWN]: Alright, well, thank you everyone for listening Marilyn.
02:09:11 --> 02:09:13 [UNKNOWN]: Are you in the mood for some names?
02:09:14 --> 02:09:15 [UNKNOWN]: I can certainly do that now.
02:09:16 --> 02:09:21 [UNKNOWN]: I rumor has it that we might be talking about the faithful here.
02:09:22 --> 02:09:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, we are.
02:09:23 --> 02:09:23 [UNKNOWN]: I think.
02:09:23 --> 02:09:29 [UNKNOWN]: And where should I apply that at the very beginning, or I'm thinking for the down the line?
02:09:29 --> 02:09:33 [UNKNOWN]: I think we're all, I mean, I think that's the discord server booster.
02:09:33 --> 02:09:33 [UNKNOWN]: It should be the same.
02:09:33 --> 02:09:34 [UNKNOWN]: I think so too.
02:09:34 --> 02:09:38 [UNKNOWN]: That was what I, that was where I landed, but you know, I have to check.
02:09:38 --> 02:09:39 [UNKNOWN]: I have to check.
02:09:39 --> 02:09:46 [UNKNOWN]: So, we are so grateful to all our community volunteers who are known, lovingly as the student
02:09:48 --> 02:09:50 [UNKNOWN]: The hand of the pod, Nancy, A.K.A.
02:09:50 --> 02:09:51 [UNKNOWN]: to kids too dog.
02:09:51 --> 02:09:55 [UNKNOWN]: The master of the poles and captain of the pole heroine, Peter O'H.
02:09:56 --> 02:09:58 [UNKNOWN]: The keeper of the show tracker, Sub-Zero.
02:09:59 --> 02:10:08 [UNKNOWN]: Laura Barion, Brian 863, moderators, Brian 863, and Erin K. And Adryon, also known as Vah Hammer.
02:10:09 --> 02:10:26 [UNKNOWN]: And then we have the faithful, those who are discord server boosters, Aaron K. Teller the Thriller, doves 71, Athena Azulaya, Lestu, Nancy M. Ghost, the partition, radioactive-riched, and avarion, and we have our loremasters.
02:10:28 --> 02:10:44 [UNKNOWN]: Samarshan, Michael G, Michelle E, S, C, Peter O'H, Nitsy, M, D, 71, Brian 863, Frederick H, Sarah L, Garrett C, Andra B, Kwong Yu, Nathan T, Sub-Zero, Aaron K, Dally V, Mothership 61, Nars?
02:10:47 --> 02:10:57 [UNKNOWN]: Cathy W. Lestu, Jeffrey B. Elisa U. Ben B. Scott F. Steven N. Julia F. Callie S. Ilmariel, Rocky Zim, Jessica A.
02:10:57 --> 02:10:59 [UNKNOWN]: Red Zippy, also known as Lisa.
02:10:59 --> 02:11:01 [UNKNOWN]: The TCS, LNR.
02:11:01 --> 02:11:03 [UNKNOWN]: Mrs. Tenant, AC Wilson, LW.
02:11:17 --> 02:11:19 [UNKNOWN]: and last, but never least, I'll let it up.
02:11:22 --> 02:11:23 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you, everyone.
02:11:23 --> 02:11:26 [UNKNOWN]: We will see you, or hopefully a less-widey episode.
02:11:26 --> 02:11:29 [UNKNOWN]: Ah, I'm so excited for that.
02:11:29 --> 02:11:30 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I don't know about that.
02:11:31 --> 02:11:31 [UNKNOWN]: We'll see.
02:11:33 --> 02:11:35 [UNKNOWN]: The Lorhound's podcast is produced in published by the Lorhound's.
02:11:36 --> 02:11:41 [UNKNOWN]: You can send questions and feedback and voicemails at the Lorhound's.com slash contact.
02:11:42 --> 02:11:47 [UNKNOWN]: Get early and add free access to all Lorhound's podcasts at patreon.com slash the Lorhound's.
02:11:47 --> 02:11:52 [UNKNOWN]: Any opinion stated or ours personally and do not reflect the opinion of or belong to any employers or other entities.
02:11:53 --> 02:11:53 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks for listening.
