The Rings of Power - S03E04 - Gundabad
The LorehoundsNovember 20, 202602:26:20133.98 MB

The Rings of Power - S03E04 - Gundabad

David, John, and Marilyn recap Season 3, Episode 4 of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power on Prime Video. They discuss the return of an elven favorite, the complicated morality of an orc, and how a certain dwarf manifests his rage.

Contact Us

Questions or comments? Visit us at our website where you can use the contact form or use the voicemail feature. Or, send an email to lotr@thelorehounds.com


Sign up for the One-Time Rings of Power Season Pass:

TRoP Season Pass


Links to Patreon, Supercast, Discord, and Network Affiliates

linktr.ee/thelorehounds


Any opinions stated are ours personally and do not reflect the opinion of or belong to any employers or other entities.



Our Sponsors:
* Check out Uncommon Goods and use the code uncommongoods.com/LOREHOUNDS for a great deal: https://www.uncommongoods.com


Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

00:19 --> 00:24 [UNKNOWN]: Welcome to the Rings of Power Podcast, we are the Lorhounds, your guides to Tolkien's world of Middle-earth.
00:25 --> 00:30 [UNKNOWN]: I'm your host, John, and with me on my fellow Lorhounds, David and Marilyn are favorite Tolkien scholar.
00:31 --> 00:35 [UNKNOWN]: This is our coverage of Prime Video's original series, The Lord of the Rings.
00:35 --> 00:40 [UNKNOWN]: The Rings of Power, season three, episode four, Gwndabad.
00:40 --> 00:42 [UNKNOWN]: In this podcast, we're going to start off with our hot takes.
00:42 --> 00:46 [UNKNOWN]: We've got a little bit of feedback woven in through the entire episode.
00:47 --> 00:53 [UNKNOWN]: And we will cover some of that as we get through our scene by scene breakdown of the episode.
00:54 --> 01:07 [UNKNOWN]: If you'd like to get into contact with us send emails to lotrthelorhounds.com and if you want to join our discord or support the community by subscribing with either supercaster patreon, check out the link tree in the show notes below.
01:08 --> 01:20 [UNKNOWN]: And we have a season pass, a well priced and overstuffed value added season pass and we'll have more details on that right after our hot takes.
01:20 --> 01:22 [UNKNOWN]: Hot takes and fresh off the press.
01:23 --> 01:25 [UNKNOWN]: Get a roller-hot Marilyn hit us off.
01:26 --> 01:30 [UNKNOWN]: You saw me swear in the discord about this episode.
01:30 --> 01:31 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:32 --> 01:34 [UNKNOWN]: I was devastated by that final scene.
01:34 --> 01:40 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, it was craftily played by the showrunners, but I'm still having a fun little problem with it.
01:40 --> 01:42 [UNKNOWN]: I'll just put that right out there.
01:44 --> 01:57 [UNKNOWN]: They found an excellent mode of last-minute transportation, which was a big relief, and also beautifully, beautifully realized and shot and CGI didn't all the rest of it.
01:58 --> 02:00 [UNKNOWN]: Why couldn't they just ride the Eagles to go into bad?
02:02 --> 02:03 [UNKNOWN]: No, come in.
02:04 --> 02:09 [UNKNOWN]: And finally, we get one of the scenes that was featured so very strongly in most of the
02:12 --> 02:20 [UNKNOWN]: And this new character had a very economic process of building his character under free time.
02:20 --> 02:27 [UNKNOWN]: And so, I thought it was an excellent use of dialogue, you know, few words conveyed a great deal.
02:27 --> 02:28 [UNKNOWN]: So, that was very good.
02:28 --> 02:29 [UNKNOWN]: I enjoyed that part.
02:30 --> 02:32 [UNKNOWN]: And that was also devastating.
02:32 --> 02:35 [UNKNOWN]: By the door of plot line, that left me with some questions.
02:37 --> 02:44 [UNKNOWN]: from some previous images that I saw prior to the opening of this season, I had a pretty clear idea of what was going to happen, what was going to go down.
02:45 --> 02:48 [UNKNOWN]: But again, the how it happened was was pretty painful.
02:50 --> 02:52 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, lots of pain in this one for me.
02:52 --> 02:53 [UNKNOWN]: David, what about you?
02:54 --> 02:58 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I thought this was a much better episode than the last one.
02:58 --> 03:01 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, not cringing as hard.
03:01 --> 03:03 [UNKNOWN]: So I don't think I really cringed much.
03:04 --> 03:10 [UNKNOWN]: I was mad at the dwarf storyline though, and for reasons that we'll talk about.
03:11 --> 03:27 [UNKNOWN]: I think they did a bad job with it and they could have told it a different way, so I have principled reasons for my anger and we can talk it through and we had a big conversation on the discord about it too and yeah, so there's some things to break down there.
03:27 --> 03:36 [UNKNOWN]: So looking forward to that one thing that I really was wondering that I was really enjoying Sauron and his little minimis and I was
03:36 --> 03:55 [UNKNOWN]: And, and I really got a Darth Vader vibe from the ring bearers, the Nasdawn and the ghouls running around as like man, what if Darth Vader had like four or five minimies running around with him in like rogue wander and a new hope like he would be well The inquisitors are those minimies.
03:55 --> 03:58 [UNKNOWN]: They've just added them in the animated stuff
03:59 --> 04:03 [UNKNOWN]: They're not as powerful like these these ringmaces are powerful.
04:03 --> 04:06 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, the inquisitors are They're not as sure that's true.
04:06 --> 04:09 [UNKNOWN]: We're always seeing fighting like got to get you on the end.
04:09 --> 04:14 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah Well, but it's not even exclusive in the animated they were all some in love action
04:14 --> 04:15 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yes.
04:16 --> 04:20 [UNKNOWN]: And we always see them fighting similar powered creatures.
04:21 --> 04:23 [UNKNOWN]: And so I guess maybe I don't have a scale for them anyway.
04:23 --> 04:25 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was just a cool thing.
04:25 --> 04:32 [UNKNOWN]: It just made me think about how powerful this unit is running around the middle earth.
04:33 --> 04:38 [UNKNOWN]: The whole true false deflection of Marnook was interesting.
04:38 --> 04:40 [UNKNOWN]: And I was like, is he isn't he?
04:44 --> 04:46 [UNKNOWN]: And yeah, there were some definitely cool things.
04:46 --> 04:49 [UNKNOWN]: I have a small TED talk on Eagles this time.
04:49 --> 04:50 [UNKNOWN]: I had a pulse last night.
04:50 --> 04:51 [UNKNOWN]: I've got Eagles tonight.
04:51 --> 04:52 [UNKNOWN]: You sure do.
04:53 --> 04:55 [UNKNOWN]: So yeah, I had a good time with this episode.
04:56 --> 04:57 [UNKNOWN]: And I don't know.
04:57 --> 05:01 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know that I was so devastated by a rendezier.
05:01 --> 05:09 [UNKNOWN]: I was shocked, like the Butcher's Bill on this episode was pretty high, and but I also respect to show
05:10 --> 05:14 [UNKNOWN]: that is willing to take out a main character from time to time.
05:14 --> 05:21 [UNKNOWN]: I think it adds to stakes and so I'm bummed, but yeah, I don't know.
05:21 --> 05:23 [UNKNOWN]: I think it kind of worked for me.
05:23 --> 05:23 [UNKNOWN]: I'm good.
05:23 --> 05:24 [UNKNOWN]: What about you, John?
05:25 --> 05:26 [UNKNOWN]: It is a tough thing.
05:26 --> 05:28 [UNKNOWN]: I want to start off on that last lot of years.
05:28 --> 05:33 [UNKNOWN]: It is a tough thing when you have a show with establish historical characters.
05:33 --> 05:35 [UNKNOWN]: that we know need to live on.
05:35 --> 05:36 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah.
05:36 --> 05:38 [UNKNOWN]: To create ultimate stage.
05:38 --> 05:40 [UNKNOWN]: It's the prequel trap.
05:41 --> 05:43 [UNKNOWN]: That how do you create stakes on a story?
05:43 --> 05:43 [UNKNOWN]: You know the ending, too.
05:45 --> 05:48 [UNKNOWN]: And it could have felt a lot like being a fridge to me.
05:51 --> 06:03 [UNKNOWN]: It honestly helped me re-contextualize ARD in a little bit, and I didn't mention it in our last episode, but before that, even I had read some of the pushback I got for my saying it was a woman who was diagnosed trope instance.
06:03 --> 06:07 [UNKNOWN]: Actually, upon reflection, I think I was a little hasty in that judgment.
06:07 --> 06:10 [UNKNOWN]: I think that she did have a full arc.
06:10 --> 06:16 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know if it was the best executed arc I've ever seen, but there was a purpose to her being in the show other than,
06:16 --> 06:28 [UNKNOWN]: giving a seal door and lend you all their motivations that in it you're not I will defend your right to call out the trope though and have a sensitivity to it.
06:29 --> 06:29 [UNKNOWN]: I am very sure.
06:30 --> 06:31 [UNKNOWN]: I have to it because that's fine.
06:31 --> 06:39 [UNKNOWN]: It has showed up in other properties that I love and I think it was that it was almost a fatal mistake in the wheel of time show.
06:41 --> 06:48 [UNKNOWN]: Now, um, when, but having considered that, um, I don't think it was a woman always dies trope.
06:48 --> 07:00 [UNKNOWN]: That said, I, uh, or at least not an egregious version of it, seeing around your diet this episode now, I'm kind of like, are we creating characters just to off them so that we can have those stakes?
07:01 --> 07:05 [UNKNOWN]: And I don't want to feel like that either, because that feels lazy to me.
07:05 --> 07:13 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I have some feedback from a listener who really helped me reframe it quite a lot, and oh, by the way, that was a spoiler.
07:13 --> 07:15 [UNKNOWN]: I hope that doesn't matter.
07:15 --> 07:18 [UNKNOWN]: No, whatever episode we're on, we can talk about the spoilers of.
07:19 --> 07:20 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I thought hot takes.
07:21 --> 07:22 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
07:22 --> 07:26 [UNKNOWN]: This one, you should have watched episode four before you listen to this.
07:26 --> 07:27 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, knowingly.
07:27 --> 07:28 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, fair play.
07:29 --> 07:29 [UNKNOWN]: Fair play.
07:30 --> 07:53 [UNKNOWN]: But yeah, and I'm sure we'll get into that some more that that said there was a lot to like this episode Just tail on really quick Cincinnati Joe on the discord had a some feedback that got pulled into the document And this is a good place as a sure anywhere It seems like the show runners are killing off or moving on from characters that weren't in the book Probably to focus more on the canon characters.
07:53 --> 07:56 [UNKNOWN]: I'm getting that sense to that was kind of I was going with this.
07:57 --> 07:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah
07:57 --> 08:00 [UNKNOWN]: And that's not necessarily a bad thing, but I do.
08:00 --> 08:03 [UNKNOWN]: It is kind of disappointing for them not to.
08:03 --> 08:12 [UNKNOWN]: If you're gonna create non-canning characters, original characters, do something with them, make them matter a little more, I think, to the end game.
08:13 --> 08:23 [UNKNOWN]: And I, look, I'm not saying that they didn't matter at all, but like, I think we should, I think we should have seen one or two original characters make it the end.
08:24 --> 08:25 [UNKNOWN]: That would have been often to the night.
08:25 --> 08:26 [UNKNOWN]: It would have been cool.
08:26 --> 08:27 [UNKNOWN]: I think we will.
08:27 --> 08:28 [UNKNOWN]: I hope we will.
08:28 --> 08:30 [UNKNOWN]: And I left on a original.
08:31 --> 08:32 [UNKNOWN]: Are you guys Deesa?
08:32 --> 08:33 [UNKNOWN]: Deesa?
08:34 --> 08:37 [UNKNOWN]: And do it on, I mean, we have a name, but we don't really know much about the character.
08:37 --> 08:38 [UNKNOWN]: They're two children.
08:39 --> 08:41 [UNKNOWN]: Um, be careful what you ask for, child.
08:42 --> 08:49 [UNKNOWN]: But as far as, as far as, um, you know, main characters, Deesa's kind of it, right?
08:49 --> 08:50 [UNKNOWN]: Like, I figured right.
08:50 --> 08:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
08:51 --> 09:09 [UNKNOWN]: for original But during is a named character like I know I know he's not super flushed out, but a lot of things are very flushed out So I don't know that that would be my minor minor critique That said I'm not like devastated that around years gone.
09:09 --> 09:15 [UNKNOWN]: He was a fun character, but I never really He never made his way in my heart fully.
09:16 --> 09:16 [UNKNOWN]: I think
09:17 --> 09:22 [UNKNOWN]: Well, he did it to mind, but I also think it's as much the way he died that is so devastating.
09:24 --> 09:33 [UNKNOWN]: And it is an end part of the problem for me is, and this is my fault, is I was a Googling to do the show guide, and I accidentally found out that there was an announcement.
09:34 --> 09:37 [UNKNOWN]: I got the naznogal reveal spoiled for me.
09:37 --> 09:37 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
09:38 --> 09:41 [UNKNOWN]: Well, like episode one, and I was like, no, no.
09:41 --> 09:43 [UNKNOWN]: I think if you hadn't, it would have hit a lot.
09:43 --> 09:44 [UNKNOWN]: I do think so.
09:44 --> 09:45 [UNKNOWN]: This is my fault.
09:45 --> 09:49 [UNKNOWN]: And I made my sacrifice for the people, with the sake of the show guy.
09:51 --> 09:52 [UNKNOWN]: Um, I did like a lot of this episode.
09:52 --> 10:02 [UNKNOWN]: I David and I were talking on on our private chat about how I think neither was really like the whole like comedy of errors, but in, you know, we can't take a lot of reals name.
10:02 --> 10:06 [UNKNOWN]: We're going to keep getting inconveniently interrupted right before we say it didn't love that.
10:08 --> 10:11 [UNKNOWN]: That just felt like like leave that stuff in the dwarf spotlight.
10:12 --> 10:18 [UNKNOWN]: Right, I'm okay with it in the hard-foot platform, but the elves have to be like, I don't know, they they they're like a leaps to me.
10:18 --> 10:22 [UNKNOWN]: Like they have to they have to have this level of seriousness, I think.
10:22 --> 10:29 [UNKNOWN]: Well, let's say when you're going to enjoy and Gil Gallad Gil Gallad did my saying that right now my head just with spirals.
10:29 --> 10:37 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you when they're talking it's all very CG and deep meditative audio is is have we lost hope and and stuff.
10:37 --> 10:37 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
10:38 --> 10:44 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and not that there can't be joy, but I think silliness is a step too far for that kind of thing, you know what I mean?
10:46 --> 10:57 [UNKNOWN]: I say that, as of course, El Rond is like, giddy in the Hobbit and you know, there's instances even in the Lord of the Rings of elves being more giddy and less super serious.
10:57 --> 10:58 [UNKNOWN]: Wouldn't you say Marilyn?
10:58 --> 10:59 [UNKNOWN]: Tra-la-la-la-la-la-la.
10:59 --> 11:04 [UNKNOWN]: So, yeah, Tra-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la
11:06 --> 11:20 [UNKNOWN]: I know he's out to hear you're talking about this is you they meet in the forest right when they leave the shire This is all the elves at Riven dole when they reach Riven dole and have this thing Oh, I thought that was Frodo meeting the elves right inside of Riven does matter we're off track
11:21 --> 11:21 [UNKNOWN]: We're off track.
11:21 --> 11:23 [UNKNOWN]: We're going into the Lord of the Rings now.
11:23 --> 11:24 [UNKNOWN]: We are.
11:24 --> 11:25 [UNKNOWN]: We are.
11:25 --> 11:25 [UNKNOWN]: That's okay.
11:25 --> 11:28 [UNKNOWN]: The show is doing it enough for us anyway.
11:28 --> 11:32 [UNKNOWN]: So we can't be blamed if we slide sideways and to Lord of the Rings.
11:33 --> 11:33 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
11:34 --> 11:35 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, I'm having fun with the show.
11:37 --> 11:40 [UNKNOWN]: The last two episodes really were big serial episodes for me.
11:41 --> 11:44 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, all right, someone took their action figures out.
11:44 --> 11:45 [UNKNOWN]: They're Lord of the Rings action figures.
11:46 --> 11:47 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm going to see what they're doing with them.
11:48 --> 11:49 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm going to put on my jamies and my cereal.
11:50 --> 11:53 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't really want this to be a serial show, but I'll live with it if it is.
11:54 --> 11:58 [UNKNOWN]: Wow, episode four was not serial for me, I'm telling you.
11:59 --> 12:02 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was me, I think it was me getting spoiled.
12:03 --> 12:09 [UNKNOWN]: I have to think it had a lot to do with that, Sean, but, you know, I have no more spoilers going forward.
12:09 --> 12:21 [UNKNOWN]: So I'm hoping that that, that gives me, and like, there was other stuff, like, it wasn't just in the off-plat line that the Comative Errors have got me, but like,
12:21 --> 12:30 [UNKNOWN]: during finding out just before his battle, this misunderstanding of what happened with his life and we're going to talk about it.
12:30 --> 12:37 [UNKNOWN]: I'm like, I do find that to be the lowest form of storytelling is misunderstanding's leading to dramatic.
12:37 --> 12:38 [UNKNOWN]: I don't have time to tell you.
12:39 --> 12:42 [UNKNOWN]: We must go now, but I'm going to keep telling you that I can't tell you because we have no time.
12:43 --> 12:43 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
12:43 --> 12:47 [UNKNOWN]: Therefore, you can't learn the plot device because I'm telling you that we don't have time.
12:48 --> 12:48 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
12:48 --> 12:49 [UNKNOWN]: I hate that.
12:49 --> 12:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, I hate it too.
12:50 --> 12:54 [UNKNOWN]: I, again, I will continue to call it the lowest form of story telling.
12:54 --> 12:54 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
12:54 --> 12:55 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
12:55 --> 12:57 [UNKNOWN]: But, you know, it's still fun.
12:57 --> 12:58 [UNKNOWN]: It's still a fun show.
12:58 --> 13:00 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not going to be a negative person.
13:00 --> 13:01 [UNKNOWN]: This whole podcast, don't worry.
13:08 --> 13:09 [UNKNOWN]: We were very fair.
13:09 --> 13:15 [UNKNOWN]: I think we were fairly fair to it and we weren't negative about it Like we were we had joy in our hearts as we painted.
13:16 --> 13:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, bigger than our feet Oh, he said it this time.
13:20 --> 13:21 [UNKNOWN]: I said it this time.
13:22 --> 13:24 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, the call is coming from any side of the house
13:25 --> 13:26 [UNKNOWN]: So let's get into our housekeeping quick.
13:26 --> 13:28 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think we need to do our full housekeeping.
13:28 --> 13:30 [UNKNOWN]: So let's get into our housekeeping quick, I don't think we need to do our full housekeeping.
13:30 --> 13:32 [UNKNOWN]: So let's get into our housekeeping quick, I don't think we need to do our full housekeeping.
13:32 --> 13:33 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, we're going to have to upload yesterday.
13:33 --> 13:34 [UNKNOWN]: Just don't forget, you can get the season pass.
13:34 --> 13:35 [UNKNOWN]: We're getting these episodes out as quickly as we can.
13:35 --> 13:37 [UNKNOWN]: We're going to start dropping forecasts soon.
13:37 --> 13:38 [UNKNOWN]: I think David's out next week.
13:38 --> 13:40 [UNKNOWN]: So Marilyn and I are going to handle a couple of forecasts.
13:41 --> 13:42 [UNKNOWN]: That sounds like a good idea.
13:42 --> 13:44 [UNKNOWN]: The season pass will get you bonus content.
13:44 --> 13:45 [UNKNOWN]: It'll get you the show guide.
13:46 --> 13:48 [UNKNOWN]: It'll get you permanent ad-free access.
13:48 --> 13:49 [UNKNOWN]: So.
13:50 --> 13:50 [UNKNOWN]: it's great time.
13:51 --> 13:56 [UNKNOWN]: One thing I did see on the Discord today and again we do have the community Discord all are welcome on our Discord.
13:57 --> 14:14 [UNKNOWN]: We have channels set up that they're all siloed and so you don't have to worry about getting spoiled as you watch at various spaces because people there's people who already caught up to six and those just came out last night and so the rest of us who are moving at mortal pace you can dip in and out on the channels as you need that said
14:15 --> 14:22 [UNKNOWN]: they did post that are some various community members posted that I'm trying to scroll back to it.
14:22 --> 14:27 [UNKNOWN]: I asked to die and I believe Connor are green lantern liaison officer posted that it sounds like episode seven and eight are going to be released a day earlier.
14:27 --> 14:42 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah,
14:43 --> 14:47 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, in the theater, yeah, in the final episode, it must be doubles.
14:48 --> 14:50 [UNKNOWN]: It's just seven, but it's got to be seven and eight, right?
14:51 --> 14:53 [UNKNOWN]: How am I supposed to do that?
14:53 --> 14:55 [UNKNOWN]: It's got to be seven and even for the penultimate episode.
14:55 --> 15:01 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly, it's the will of the Valar, otherwise known as the show right there.
15:01 --> 15:02 [UNKNOWN]: And Amazon, so.
15:02 --> 15:05 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, but anyway, there were three or four more.
15:05 --> 15:08 [UNKNOWN]: Beautiful, almost as a screwdriver as Andrew himself.
15:08 --> 15:09 [UNKNOWN]: Indeed.
15:09 --> 15:16 [UNKNOWN]: And so all of this, of course, folks, means that we've halfway through, we've got four more to go, but it's going to be covered.
15:16 --> 15:19 [UNKNOWN]: I just dropped it at this point because, you know, Thanksgiving week.
15:19 --> 15:22 [UNKNOWN]: So we'll do what we can to give you things to listen to.
15:23 --> 15:27 [UNKNOWN]: We haven't really figured out yet when we're going to finally get all the way through to this date.
15:28 --> 15:28 [UNKNOWN]: So,
15:29 --> 15:33 [UNKNOWN]: Hopefully you will find enough things to entertain you that you'll stick with us through.
15:33 --> 15:34 [UNKNOWN]: But we'll get there.
15:34 --> 15:35 [UNKNOWN]: The solution.
15:35 --> 15:36 [UNKNOWN]: We will get there.
15:36 --> 15:37 [UNKNOWN]: Absolutely.
15:37 --> 15:38 [UNKNOWN]: And big shout out to Nancy.
15:38 --> 15:42 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks, Nancy, for all the work that you are doing on the feedback.
15:42 --> 15:43 [UNKNOWN]: We got a ton of feedback today.
15:43 --> 15:45 [UNKNOWN]: So thank you everyone for writing it down.
15:46 --> 16:07 [UNKNOWN]: Sending messages and thank you Nancy for the amazing job of threading it all into our outline and such like that So if you do want to give your thoughts and your comments about podcast about the content on the podcast L-O-T-R at the Lorentz.com and don't be surprised if Nancy emails you back and you have a fun little interaction with her So we have some previous episode feedback.
16:07 --> 16:08 [UNKNOWN]: David, do you want to lead us through that?
16:09 --> 16:10 [UNKNOWN]: Uh, do I have to read?
16:11 --> 16:21 [UNKNOWN]: I, I, I, I'll, I'll, David, if that was the first time you heard or registered Brimby wait till you hear the current ones.
16:21 --> 16:22 [UNKNOWN]: Kella Brimboons.
16:22 --> 16:23 [UNKNOWN]: I saw my favorite.
16:23 --> 16:24 [UNKNOWN]: I like that one.
16:24 --> 16:25 [UNKNOWN]: Skella Brimboor.
16:26 --> 16:28 [UNKNOWN]: And Kella Brimboast.
16:28 --> 16:29 [UNKNOWN]: Kella Brimboast.
16:29 --> 16:30 [UNKNOWN]: That's really good.
16:30 --> 16:31 [UNKNOWN]: I like that too.
16:31 --> 16:35 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I cannot take credit for any of the above, other hands and minds came up with those.
16:35 --> 16:38 [UNKNOWN]: I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I, I.
16:39 --> 16:40 [UNKNOWN]: I have some marnook one.
16:41 --> 16:42 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, that's marnook.
16:43 --> 16:44 [UNKNOWN]: Marpookie?
16:44 --> 16:45 [UNKNOWN]: Marpookie?
16:45 --> 16:47 [UNKNOWN]: For those of us who would die for him.
16:47 --> 16:51 [UNKNOWN]: Also, what do you call a cozy reading area for Uruks?
16:51 --> 16:54 [UNKNOWN]: A marbooknook.
16:55 --> 16:58 [UNKNOWN]: What do you call a cheesy vegan topping in Uruks?
17:00 --> 17:02 [UNKNOWN]: What do you call the cheesy vegan topping?
17:02 --> 17:06 [UNKNOWN]: An uruk may put on his or her centipede snack.
17:07 --> 17:07 [UNKNOWN]: Marnuch.
17:08 --> 17:09 [UNKNOWN]: This one's for all my vegans.
17:10 --> 17:11 [UNKNOWN]: I don't understand that at all.
17:12 --> 17:13 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's pronounced Marnuch.
17:13 --> 17:14 [UNKNOWN]: Marnuch?
17:15 --> 17:19 [UNKNOWN]: And I think so, and I think it may be, yeah, it's the cheesy vegan topping.
17:19 --> 17:21 [UNKNOWN]: So it's- I'm gonna- It's a sauce.
17:21 --> 17:22 [UNKNOWN]: It's a cheese sauce.
17:22 --> 17:22 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
17:23 --> 17:28 [UNKNOWN]: Is it like a, uh, a, uh, Vegemite kind of spread like something like that?
17:28 --> 17:29 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think so.
17:29 --> 17:30 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's really out of this.
17:32 --> 17:32 [UNKNOWN]: And they did it.
17:33 --> 17:34 [UNKNOWN]: And the UK for that matter.
17:34 --> 17:37 [UNKNOWN]: We're, we're doing with New Zealand here, you know, that's what, that's where we are.
17:39 --> 17:43 [UNKNOWN]: Our New Zealand comes up later in the episode about Eagles too, so interesting to the enough.
17:44 --> 17:49 [UNKNOWN]: So, Gijo P also wrote it on Patreon and said hi to you guys.
17:49 --> 17:56 [UNKNOWN]: Join us during Lantern's coverage and was a faithful writer in, so it's lovely to see Gijo joining us over here on the Rings of Power.
17:56 --> 17:57 [UNKNOWN]: A very nice.
17:58 --> 18:02 [UNKNOWN]: Hey guys, I crack up at Marilyn trying to do the spoilers and I appreciate John for running interference.
18:03 --> 18:06 [UNKNOWN]: As you know, I'm very adverse to spoilers, so I appreciate it.
18:06 --> 18:08 [UNKNOWN]: I love this dynamic, really enjoying the show.
18:08 --> 18:10 [UNKNOWN]: I think the showrunners are hitting their stride with season three.
18:11 --> 18:13 [UNKNOWN]: Can't wait to see how it turns out, spoiler free.
18:14 --> 18:20 [UNKNOWN]: Did you all listen to our podcast on episode one or two, I don't remember which one it was, where I I believed with a special
18:21 --> 18:22 [UNKNOWN]: I think that's what Gijo is.
18:22 --> 18:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, no.
18:23 --> 18:24 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, you did hear it.
18:24 --> 18:26 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't know if you two heard it.
18:26 --> 18:27 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
18:27 --> 18:27 [UNKNOWN]: Yes indeed.
18:28 --> 18:28 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
18:29 --> 18:30 [UNKNOWN]: You know, what did you say?
18:30 --> 18:31 [UNKNOWN]: I thought it would be fun.
18:32 --> 18:34 [UNKNOWN]: And Gijo, I do apologize.
18:34 --> 18:35 [UNKNOWN]: I do my best.
18:36 --> 18:39 [UNKNOWN]: No need, because you didn't spoil G. Joe, you call him to interrupt G. Joe.
18:39 --> 18:47 [UNKNOWN]: Well, they keep calling me in as the Laura Mester, and so I automatically make these connections, and, you know, you're doing your job.
18:47 --> 19:03 [UNKNOWN]: I keep forgetting that in point of fact, there are some people who are coming to the world of Middle Earth through this for the first time, so I will continue to do my best, and thank you, John, and advance for all the Gallum interruptions that you may still have to give me from time to time.
19:03 --> 19:05 [UNKNOWN]: Never fear, smiggle is here.
19:07 --> 19:08 [UNKNOWN]: Oh dear.
19:09 --> 19:09 [UNKNOWN]: Oh dear.
19:10 --> 19:10 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
19:10 --> 19:14 [UNKNOWN]: So we had one other piece of feedback that we want to get through before the main episode.
19:14 --> 19:21 [UNKNOWN]: That's from Aaron K. R. Dunedine, a co-host of Cosmere Corner, which we're just making plans for the next episode for.
19:21 --> 19:22 [UNKNOWN]: And things have been crazy.
19:23 --> 19:25 [UNKNOWN]: And Radio Accessible Radio Act of Rambright.
19:25 --> 19:26 [UNKNOWN]: Of course.
19:26 --> 19:29 [UNKNOWN]: And is our Gen Z representative, our official Gen Z liaison.
19:30 --> 19:31 [UNKNOWN]: He's a council member.
19:32 --> 19:49 [UNKNOWN]: And this one's a little bit long and it's about eight minutes and it was a little bit solicited, but it's been building and it has to do with international relationships and a way for us to frame some of what's going on between these quote unquote nation states and how they're engaging with each other or not engaging with each other.
19:50 --> 19:53 [UNKNOWN]: Hey, Laura Hounds, Erin here.
19:53 --> 20:03 [UNKNOWN]: I am voice mailing in today to talk a little bit about principles of neutrality in the Rings of Power and specifically in relation to the dwarven kingdoms.
20:04 --> 20:10 [UNKNOWN]: Alright, a couple of housekeeping items before I get into the actual Rings of Power of it all.
20:11 --> 20:25 [UNKNOWN]: international relations, there is essentially the belief and principle that the world operates as an anarchy, which does not mean that everything is crazy all the time and that there's no rules and no government.
20:26 --> 20:32 [UNKNOWN]: but all that really means is that there is no higher power that states answer to.
20:33 --> 20:43 [UNKNOWN]: And so essentially what that means for states can be a few different things, but in the IR school of realism, which is one of the sort of,
20:43 --> 21:04 [UNKNOWN]: three main-ish schools of international relations would mean that all states are going to act in their own interests all the time, because there is no higher power to dull out rules and punishment for breaking the rules and its only states operating as independent entities, they're always going to do what's best for themselves.
21:05 --> 21:09 [UNKNOWN]: And sometimes what is best for yourself as a state is
21:13 --> 21:26 [UNKNOWN]: the principles of neutrality that we sort of think of essentially came about during Tolkien's time, a lot of the guiding principles of how states exist and interact with each other are fairly new.
21:26 --> 21:38 [UNKNOWN]: It's previous to sort of the 1900s, there were a few very basic principles that came about and specifically the idea of sovereignty that all states are governing themselves
21:39 --> 21:51 [UNKNOWN]: Exist, essentially, you stay over there and do your thing and I'll stay over here and do my thing that idea of sovereignty and not violating each other's sovereignty.
21:51 --> 22:00 [UNKNOWN]: Really only came about in the 1600s before then, you know, if you had good relations between two different kingdoms or two different states.
22:00 --> 22:20 [UNKNOWN]: that was just how it operated you if you had good relations you didn't hurt each other and if things were bad maybe you fought each other from time to time and once sovereignty is introduced the need to justify war and justify your stance on the international stage becomes a lot more important
22:21 --> 22:36 [UNKNOWN]: And bringing that into the Tolkien context, 1907, the hate conventions happen, and the rules and guiding principles around what it means to be a neutral state are really solidified.
22:37 --> 22:39 [UNKNOWN]: And a few of the main principles around that are...
22:40 --> 22:53 [UNKNOWN]: A, you have to be impartial, and this isn't sort of a vague, oh, generally you're not looking at other states and taking once I know you really do have to be impartial.
22:55 --> 23:01 [UNKNOWN]: If there's a war going on, you are not allowed to give any sort of advantage to one side or the other.
23:01 --> 23:13 [UNKNOWN]: And one of the more specific things is you can't give loans, no monetary assistance, you can't send weapons to another nation if you are remaining neutral.
23:14 --> 23:15 [UNKNOWN]: All of these sort of principles.
23:15 --> 23:21 [UNKNOWN]: are being broken by the dwarves in the rings of power, right?
23:21 --> 23:27 [UNKNOWN]: You have, I believe, the dwarves sending weapons to restock some of the elven supply.
23:27 --> 23:36 [UNKNOWN]: And it's not uncommon for a nation that claims itself to be neutral to send arms and assistance to one side or another.
23:36 --> 23:38 [UNKNOWN]: This principle of neutrality
23:43 --> 23:52 [UNKNOWN]: Essentially, the dwarves have picked aside whether they want to admit it or not, and sauron with his influence and even sending the rings in the first place.
23:53 --> 23:54 [UNKNOWN]: That's a play for power.
23:54 --> 24:00 [UNKNOWN]: He's trying to gain de facto control over the dwarven realms with these rings.
24:01 --> 24:11 [UNKNOWN]: And even though he's failing, he's making that play, and he, both the dwarves and sauron have essentially set up their themselves in one camper or another.
24:11 --> 24:24 [UNKNOWN]: when it comes to even more of a Tolkien connection and this violation of Dwarven neutrality by Sauron by sending the rings by sending the Nazgul to demand allegiance.
24:25 --> 24:27 [UNKNOWN]: This isn't something that would have been unfamiliar to Tolkien.
24:27 --> 24:29 [UNKNOWN]: During the first World War,
24:30 --> 24:46 [UNKNOWN]: Germany violates Belgian neutrality, and essentially all of the principles of what it means to be a neutral state are thrown out the window because you can't guarantee that you are going to be safe and protected by this
24:47 --> 24:52 [UNKNOWN]: sort of recently established idea of what it means to be a neutral state.
24:52 --> 24:53 [UNKNOWN]: It's a free for all.
24:53 --> 25:07 [UNKNOWN]: Everyone is going after their own interests which brings me back to the point of realism that states are going to do what's best for them and they're going to push and push and push and do what they feel they can get away with.
25:07 --> 25:10 [UNKNOWN]: And that's exactly what Sauron is doing on the global stage.
25:10 --> 25:15 [UNKNOWN]: And from the perspective of the dwarves, they are trying to maintain some level of neutrality.
25:15 --> 25:34 [UNKNOWN]: In this conflict, they aren't directly involved, Sauron hasn't made any outright attempts to invade any of the dwarven realms, and is only doing these acts of sort of political influence and magical influence in the case of the rings.
25:35 --> 25:35 [UNKNOWN]: And so
25:36 --> 26:04 [UNKNOWN]: for the dwarves to go out and break that neutrality is not very good for them because I would imagine that a lot of these dwarven kingdoms not only have relationships with the elves and with the forces of good but they also would have relationships with the different human kingdoms that have aligned themselves with sauron and so angering sauron and declaring an overt side in this war
26:04 --> 26:10 [UNKNOWN]: is going to break a lot of those connections and that's not what's best for the dwarven realms at this moment.
26:10 --> 26:26 [UNKNOWN]: In the long run, we can confidently say as members of the audience that the dwarves shouldn't get involved because Sauron isn't going to let them be, he's not going to let them stay and their stone halls under the mountain and live in peace just because
26:26 --> 26:27 [UNKNOWN]: They didn't get involved.
26:28 --> 26:40 [UNKNOWN]: He's going to come for them eventually because he has this idea of dismantling the anarchy that I brought up earlier This system where there is no one on top and There's no one to dull out any sort of
26:41 --> 26:43 [UNKNOWN]: Rules, there's no one to keep order.
26:43 --> 26:51 [UNKNOWN]: It's just dependent on states interacting with each other and Making agreements and understandings with one another.
26:51 --> 26:59 [UNKNOWN]: So I want us to change that he wants to take the chaos of the world and Remake it in his one perfect order with him at the very top and
27:00 --> 27:06 [UNKNOWN]: Knowing that, we can say that the dwarves are in need of intervention.
27:06 --> 27:07 [UNKNOWN]: They need to get involved.
27:07 --> 27:13 [UNKNOWN]: I hope that this made a little bit of sense and is helpful.
27:13 --> 27:23 [UNKNOWN]: I am definitely going to, for future episodes, be sending in something about the new Minorians, but I'm all caught up on episodes five and six, and so I...
27:24 --> 27:32 [UNKNOWN]: There are things about what's going on in the new minority in situation that I couldn't leave out what's going on in those latest episodes.
27:32 --> 27:36 [UNKNOWN]: So, expect to hear back from me very soon with more.
27:37 --> 27:48 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you for listening to me, Ramble, and I am always... My DMs are open if you want any sources or people to study or different concepts that you're interested in.
27:49 --> 27:50 [UNKNOWN]: So, see you all later.
27:52 --> 28:01 [UNKNOWN]: the Valarby with you, Aaron, he's a student of international, but that he's pursuing his studies in this area.
28:01 --> 28:04 [UNKNOWN]: He's something of a scientist himself, you're saying, indeed, indeed he is.
28:05 --> 28:11 [UNKNOWN]: And I love that he's one of his classes, at least, is doing this through the lens of Middle Earth.
28:11 --> 28:11 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
28:12 --> 28:13 [UNKNOWN]: I just think that is so cool.
28:15 --> 28:26 [UNKNOWN]: Uh, and I think it's important to kind of realize that, you know, yeah, you can be neutral, but you're, can you really be neutral in the face of a, of a sauron, right?
28:26 --> 28:42 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, can, could, could England really pursue non-aggression in World War 1 or World War II, like, you know, so it's just, those are questions to think about as worth balancing the powers of nation states, because above a nation state, there is,
28:45 --> 28:56 [UNKNOWN]: but in just sort of in your daily pursuit of trying to organize a kingdom, you're it and you have to think about what's best for your tribe, your people, your region.
28:56 --> 29:02 [UNKNOWN]: And what is your responsibility for the acts that are done with the weapons that you survive?
29:03 --> 29:05 [UNKNOWN]: We're seeing a lively debate on that today.
29:06 --> 29:06 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
29:06 --> 29:11 [UNKNOWN]: Well, and every overall only works if everybody respects
29:13 --> 29:13 [UNKNOWN]: Fair.
29:14 --> 29:32 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, the Just Worth theory was developed very early on in like the 8th or 9th century, I think, and only this past, no, this year, uh, Pope Leo had a 2026 in the cyclical where he said basically the Just Worth theory doesn't exist anymore.
29:34 --> 29:40 [UNKNOWN]: So, I think that's a good amount of pragmatism.
29:41 --> 29:50 [UNKNOWN]: And I've always thought the only thing that could unite the earth in a global sense, which is, of course, what aliens in the universe.
29:50 --> 29:50 [UNKNOWN]: Star Trek is this.
29:51 --> 29:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, one large threat that is extra terrestrial, if you will, which is another way of saying aliens.
29:58 --> 30:04 [UNKNOWN]: That everybody says, oh my gosh, you know, you're my enemy, but that's a lot worse, and we're going to have to take care of it somehow.
30:04 --> 30:07 [UNKNOWN]: Now, we can all become plurbist, but that's for me.
30:07 --> 30:10 [UNKNOWN]: Well, that's the other thing, but that's the kind of invasion that too, I think.
30:10 --> 30:10 [UNKNOWN]: It is.
30:11 --> 30:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think, please.
30:12 --> 30:16 [UNKNOWN]: And I think it's point about the doors, not having been invaded yet.
30:17 --> 30:19 [UNKNOWN]: As far as I'm concerned, they've been invaded by rings.
30:20 --> 30:20 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
30:21 --> 30:22 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
30:22 --> 30:27 [UNKNOWN]: So, and the other doorflords aren't willing to conceptualize that.
30:27 --> 30:29 [UNKNOWN]: To see that as such.
30:29 --> 30:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
30:29 --> 30:32 [UNKNOWN]: They see them as opportunities for power.
30:33 --> 30:33 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
30:34 --> 30:36 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that's right, right?
30:36 --> 30:39 [UNKNOWN]: Like I think that is capturing the essence of the rings.
30:39 --> 30:40 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, you look at Baramir.
30:41 --> 30:52 [UNKNOWN]: And I think I said this in an earlier episode, but the movie does not do him justice, because he really was this beacon of honor and glory and righteous warrior.
30:53 --> 30:57 [UNKNOWN]: of Gondor who was corrupted by the ring because it could get anybody.
30:58 --> 31:04 [UNKNOWN]: Because nobody was immune to it, even those most outstanding and most heroic in their societies.
31:04 --> 31:09 [UNKNOWN]: I think the movie shows him as kind of suspicious from the beginning.
31:09 --> 31:11 [UNKNOWN]: And I think that was one of Peter Jackson's minor missteps.
31:13 --> 31:19 [UNKNOWN]: And here we have these dwarf floors, which, you know, whether they're good or less good,
31:21 --> 31:24 [UNKNOWN]: they are unable to avoid succumbing to the race.
31:25 --> 31:26 [UNKNOWN]: I like that.
31:26 --> 31:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just going to really interject with Boramere too.
31:28 --> 31:31 [UNKNOWN]: The ring is Sauron's ring.
31:31 --> 31:36 [UNKNOWN]: So it's going to figure out your weaknesses and like, that's what you're going to respond to.
31:37 --> 31:39 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I could use this to defeat the enemies of Gondor.
31:40 --> 31:40 [UNKNOWN]: Right?
31:41 --> 31:43 [UNKNOWN]: You know, that's a very Sauron thing.
31:43 --> 31:45 [UNKNOWN]: I go, what's your bag, baby?
31:45 --> 31:47 [UNKNOWN]: Let me get in there and get up on that.
31:50 --> 32:10 [UNKNOWN]: What I appreciate about the movie approach though, is that we are set up very early on, while we're still in the audience, to realize that Bordabier has already been persevering about what are we going to do, how are we going to say the situation, because... Rubindell, right?
32:11 --> 32:12 [UNKNOWN]: No, this is while he's in Lorian.
32:13 --> 32:15 [UNKNOWN]: He, he in, um, it's after Gandalf dies.
32:16 --> 32:16 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I'm sorry.
32:17 --> 32:20 [UNKNOWN]: I thought you were talking about, we, by the time of the Council of El Rond.
32:20 --> 32:25 [UNKNOWN]: No, no, no, no, no, um, I see a much more human hero, if he will.
32:26 --> 32:32 [UNKNOWN]: When he shares with Erdogan, that his father expects great things of him, where we heard that line before in Tolkien material.
32:33 --> 32:35 [UNKNOWN]: And of course, I will do them.
32:36 --> 32:39 [UNKNOWN]: And yet he recognizes the situation
32:40 --> 32:44 [UNKNOWN]: pretty serious and how on earth is he supposed to carry this whole burdens.
32:44 --> 32:53 [UNKNOWN]: So what appears to be a heel turn in books is actually a growing progression all along.
32:54 --> 33:07 [UNKNOWN]: Now I think maybe Tolkien wanted boredom here to be more like the kind of unreproachable hero that you were talking about last episode, John, you know, the perfect hero in Elendale or whoever else.
33:08 --> 33:17 [UNKNOWN]: I think right up until that point, that's kind of what we're seeing in him, and the way he's referred to, particularly by the Hobbits, would read before us that.
33:17 --> 33:22 [UNKNOWN]: But in the films, we do at least see, alright, there's something else going on here.
33:22 --> 33:24 [UNKNOWN]: So maybe Javit to put it the way you did.
33:25 --> 33:28 [UNKNOWN]: We are seeing his weakness exposed already.
33:28 --> 33:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, right now.
33:29 --> 33:30 [UNKNOWN]: We're worse up until that point.
33:30 --> 33:31 [UNKNOWN]: We don't see it.
33:32 --> 33:32 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
33:32 --> 33:35 [UNKNOWN]: It could really be read in the books as this is just his pride.
33:36 --> 33:40 [UNKNOWN]: My armies will flock to my banner and I will lead them out.
33:41 --> 33:46 [UNKNOWN]: So it sounds as though I think maybe Tolkien felt that pride was the overreaching.
33:46 --> 33:47 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
33:47 --> 33:47 [UNKNOWN]: Look.
33:48 --> 33:49 [UNKNOWN]: Very Catholic of him.
33:50 --> 33:51 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
33:51 --> 33:59 [UNKNOWN]: But I really enjoy what you're saying, Marilyn, because it harkens back to our last conversation, which we had just last evening.
33:59 --> 33:59 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
34:01 --> 34:04 [UNKNOWN]: Tolkien is writing this, this is Beowulf, right?
34:04 --> 34:22 [UNKNOWN]: This is Beowulf, retold, and these are heroic larger than life characters, and they are almost closer to plot devices than they are human characters, a lot of them, not all of them, but a lot of them, except that there are the fader flaws in Beowulf.
34:23 --> 34:24 [UNKNOWN]: We do see them.
34:25 --> 34:37 [UNKNOWN]: Sure, but it's bad, but it's also Arthur and a whole bunch of literature and virtually every single heroic character in all those literature does have a fatal flaw, sooner or later.
34:38 --> 34:40 [UNKNOWN]: But that fatal flaw is very...
34:41 --> 34:42 [UNKNOWN]: plot-driven, right?
34:42 --> 34:46 [UNKNOWN]: Is this this exact thing will will be the downfall, right?
34:47 --> 35:01 [UNKNOWN]: Where as things like me to plot mechanic like he's going to they're going to write to that plot to that to that flaw and then run the character through that it can pre-constructed with that flaw in mine.
35:01 --> 35:03 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm not going to say it's better or worse.
35:03 --> 35:06 [UNKNOWN]: I just think it's a different older, short writing.
35:07 --> 35:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
35:08 --> 35:21 [UNKNOWN]: And so when Peter Jackson is adapting it and now when these short runners are adapting the brings of power, they have to, they necessarily to meet a modern audience, they need to do more character work.
35:21 --> 35:24 [UNKNOWN]: Whereas that was not, it just seems like that was not Tolkien's interest.
35:26 --> 35:32 [UNKNOWN]: Well, his character work, I think, focused pretty heavily on the Hobbits, because they are a viewpoint characters.
35:33 --> 35:33 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
35:33 --> 35:38 [UNKNOWN]: And Hobbits don't have much to do with heros, heroics, right?
35:39 --> 35:53 [UNKNOWN]: And that's kind of the whole point for them, because they are humble and literally low to the ground, they're less likely to be tempted by things, and therefore it is only a Hobbit who can actually manage to get the ring all the way to the volcano,
35:54 --> 36:01 [UNKNOWN]: without falling into its temptation, until the very last minute, because through that high exposure, that's all high.
36:01 --> 36:01 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
36:02 --> 36:05 [UNKNOWN]: He says in his writings, it was an impossible task.
36:06 --> 36:09 [UNKNOWN]: So, Frodo's failing is not a moral failing.
36:11 --> 36:25 [UNKNOWN]: I think you've hit the, he've hit it right on the nose, which is the Lord of the Rings is a story about normal flawed people going into a world of giants of moral giants of our giants.
36:26 --> 36:30 [UNKNOWN]: and their normal CB being their superpower.
36:30 --> 36:31 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah.
36:31 --> 36:38 [UNKNOWN]: And here we are, back in the era of all, everyone around being his giants.
36:38 --> 36:39 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
36:39 --> 36:41 [UNKNOWN]: And how do you adapt that?
36:42 --> 36:47 [UNKNOWN]: How do you bring the viewer into that world without making it inaccessible?
36:48 --> 36:51 [UNKNOWN]: It's a really tough thing that they are doing here.
36:51 --> 37:06 [UNKNOWN]: And as we also said last time, these are giants largely because we're seeing them in the review for mirror by people who have listened for thousands of years to the recitation of Gil Gallaud was an elven king of him, the harpersat they sing.
37:06 --> 37:17 [UNKNOWN]: The last round was fair and free between the mountains and the sea, so all of these wonderful qualities are emphasized because you really don't want to know that, you know, he lost hope.
37:17 --> 37:18 [UNKNOWN]: It's hope failed him or whatever.
37:19 --> 37:23 [UNKNOWN]: or another one, you know, slept with the sister and didn't know about it, right?
37:24 --> 37:25 [UNKNOWN]: Which is what happens to Arthur.
37:26 --> 37:27 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
37:28 --> 37:31 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I haven't lost hope.
37:31 --> 37:33 [UNKNOWN]: And I think we're gonna go take a break.
37:33 --> 37:35 [UNKNOWN]: Come back and get right into this episode.
37:55 --> 37:59 [UNKNOWN]: I think goodness, middle-earth FAA is doing better than ours.
38:00 --> 38:02 [UNKNOWN]: We've got to take a ride on a fell beast.
38:02 --> 38:03 [UNKNOWN]: That's a topical reference.
38:03 --> 38:05 [UNKNOWN]: That one's not gonna age well.
38:07 --> 38:09 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I hope it isn't gonna age well.
38:09 --> 38:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, let's hope it doesn't age well.
38:12 --> 38:12 [UNKNOWN]: Really?
38:12 --> 38:13 [UNKNOWN]: Great point.
38:14 --> 38:18 [UNKNOWN]: So the orcs struggle to bridle the fell beast, Sauron wants to ride to goon to bad.
38:19 --> 38:20 [UNKNOWN]: It's such a fun word to say.
38:21 --> 38:21 [UNKNOWN]: Goon to bad.
38:23 --> 38:28 [UNKNOWN]: Sauron tells them the beast were once eagles until Morgoth blessed them with his touch.
38:29 --> 38:35 [UNKNOWN]: When the orcs say they fed it carry on, Sauron says that's the whole problem they only eat living flesh.
38:35 --> 38:39 [UNKNOWN]: He offers an orc as a meal and orders the beast saddled.
38:41 --> 38:54 [UNKNOWN]: So last episode we were talking about some of the slapstick physical humor of people of the assassin getting sort of accidentally knocked back by a guy and doll's staff.
38:55 --> 38:59 [UNKNOWN]: In this one, I did think the orc flying in from stage left or whatever.
39:00 --> 39:05 [UNKNOWN]: was funny, and it did really sort of played for for what was going on.
39:05 --> 39:13 [UNKNOWN]: And this is a fellow beast, and this is like a really geeky situation, and so having a little bit of humor worked.
39:13 --> 39:14 [UNKNOWN]: It was dark humor.
39:14 --> 39:15 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was very dark.
39:15 --> 39:16 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, it was dark.
39:16 --> 39:23 [UNKNOWN]: And so now Salad on has to have a new number one work, because we've just finished the guy who had the big of the talent curve, or anything.
39:23 --> 39:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
39:26 --> 39:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I, I, I too was like, I wonder what Marilyn is going to think about this low, quote-unquote Lord drop.
39:36 --> 39:39 [UNKNOWN]: So Marilyn, I see the notes on this, so tell us what you think.
39:40 --> 39:42 [UNKNOWN]: I have thoughts indeed, I do.
39:42 --> 39:45 [UNKNOWN]: I hate the notion of felbees being tormented eagles.
39:46 --> 39:48 [UNKNOWN]: And it just completely contrary to the lore.
39:48 --> 39:51 [UNKNOWN]: And biologically, they're not even close.
39:52 --> 39:58 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, all right, you can argue birds were dinosaurs once upon a time, or they evolved from them.
39:58 --> 40:01 [UNKNOWN]: But so did Snakes' vision various other creatures.
40:02 --> 40:05 [UNKNOWN]: Tolkien actually coded these felbeists as terredactals.
40:06 --> 40:07 [UNKNOWN]: And to the best of my knowledge?
40:08 --> 40:09 [UNKNOWN]: Well, no, that's not true.
40:09 --> 40:10 [UNKNOWN]: There were more than one.
40:10 --> 40:12 [UNKNOWN]: But even so,
40:14 --> 40:21 [UNKNOWN]: This doesn't look like a tear-dactual, it looks more like a bronchosaurus, who lost a lot of weight, was equipped with wings and endowed with a really vicious set of teeth.
40:22 --> 40:23 [UNKNOWN]: I really like the design though.
40:24 --> 40:25 [UNKNOWN]: It was, I thought it was a great design.
40:25 --> 40:26 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, it's a great design.
40:26 --> 40:28 [UNKNOWN]: Just don't try to tell me it was once a needle.
40:28 --> 40:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
40:28 --> 40:30 [UNKNOWN]: No, it doesn't make sense at all.
40:30 --> 40:33 [UNKNOWN]: It makes absolutely no sense.
40:33 --> 40:35 [UNKNOWN]: You can see how you get an orc from an elf.
40:36 --> 40:41 [UNKNOWN]: I'm willing to buy in on that, and that was also one of the things talking offered as a possible origin of the orc.
40:42 --> 40:45 [UNKNOWN]: But, you know, that's a recognizable change.
40:46 --> 40:49 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know, is Morgana's like stretch a necks out here.
40:49 --> 40:53 [UNKNOWN]: Like, what are we changing beaks into jaws?
40:53 --> 40:54 [UNKNOWN]: I agree with you, Marilyn.
40:54 --> 40:57 [UNKNOWN]: It stretches crudulity here.
40:57 --> 41:03 [UNKNOWN]: And also, there is a prequel trap too to be like, see, this is how that became that.
41:03 --> 41:06 [UNKNOWN]: And once you answer all these questions, yeah, you don't think you need to answer all the questions.
41:06 --> 41:08 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think you need to say this is a fellow beast.
41:08 --> 41:09 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
41:10 --> 41:19 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was completely unnecessary and it reminds me very much of the where did the mythural come from in season one.
41:20 --> 41:20 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yeah.
41:20 --> 41:21 [UNKNOWN]: You need to answer that one.
41:21 --> 41:22 [UNKNOWN]: Good analogy.
41:22 --> 41:23 [UNKNOWN]: Show don't tell people.
41:25 --> 41:27 [UNKNOWN]: Didn't, uh, didn't they establish in?
41:28 --> 41:38 [UNKNOWN]: season one that Sauron had some animal communication abilities because he like puts his hand on the creatures head didn't he talked to the sea serpent or something like that.
41:38 --> 41:44 [UNKNOWN]: Wait he didn't talk to it he just kind of floated in the water but I don't think we saw that until season two.
41:45 --> 41:56 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, yeah, it's it's all blur, but yeah, there was doesn't but Sauron has some ability to kind of Yeah, and he talks to them all right like he's he's a Maya.
41:56 --> 42:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, he talked to the work in black speech and the work was all Oh my master right on right now
42:03 --> 42:16 [UNKNOWN]: I like that better though because Sarah on, of course, sort of where Wolves and has his whole fit in the first age where he lives as a where Wolves and that's exactly how Finn Rod died is Sarah on Kildman where Wolform.
42:18 --> 42:35 [UNKNOWN]: From a visual story telling standpoint for the episode, we do have a bookend watch, I guess if we could say it that way, we've had a couple of these already, but here we open with the fell beast and we end with the Eagles more or less.
42:35 --> 42:38 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, we end with DO, but like we kind of end with the Eagles as well.
42:38 --> 42:50 [UNKNOWN]: And so the episode is bookended and interestingly, yeah, if the fell beast is deformed eagle, then, you know, they sort of, we go through that sort of transformation of the two things.
42:50 --> 42:53 [UNKNOWN]: So you could also say you're beginning an ending.
42:53 --> 43:00 [UNKNOWN]: If you count Theo as the end, you're beginning an ending with good beings corrupted by an evil.
43:01 --> 43:03 [UNKNOWN]: Ooh, you know, yeah, like that.
43:04 --> 43:04 [UNKNOWN]: Well played.
43:04 --> 43:05 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
43:06 --> 43:06 [UNKNOWN]: Perfect.
43:07 --> 43:07 [UNKNOWN]: Good one.
43:09 --> 43:11 [UNKNOWN]: The O did look pretty ridiculous in that outfit.
43:11 --> 43:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just gonna be honest.
43:12 --> 43:16 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we're gonna, well, yeah, but on point, on purpose.
43:16 --> 43:17 [UNKNOWN]: I think that's right.
43:17 --> 43:17 [UNKNOWN]: Challenge.
43:18 --> 43:24 [UNKNOWN]: I have a similar thought, like, are we, are we just, you know, this is the end of that clothes, right?
43:24 --> 43:31 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, this is the, the German, the young boys in Germany wearing sort of these oversized uniforms that are being drafted for my life.
43:31 --> 43:32 [UNKNOWN]: It's interesting.
43:32 --> 43:33 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
43:33 --> 43:35 [UNKNOWN]: I just thought they made him look like he was five years ago.
43:38 --> 43:40 [UNKNOWN]: It really did look like they de-aged him.
43:40 --> 43:42 [UNKNOWN]: Well, the ring did, but isn't that the effect of the ring?
43:43 --> 43:44 [UNKNOWN]: Well, why is it cleaned him up?
43:44 --> 43:48 [UNKNOWN]: Why is aging considered to be something to do?
43:48 --> 43:54 [UNKNOWN]: Well, no, he's maybe looking younger because he has a health restore.
43:54 --> 43:55 [UNKNOWN]: He got a health buff.
43:56 --> 43:57 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, he went to the spa.
43:58 --> 43:59 [UNKNOWN]: He went to Sauron spa.
43:59 --> 44:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, the ring is, yeah, kind of a spa effect.
44:03 --> 44:05 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we're not here to talk about Theo yet.
44:05 --> 44:07 [UNKNOWN]: We're, we're still on our philbies.
44:07 --> 44:09 [UNKNOWN]: I, there's not much to say about this scene.
44:09 --> 44:12 [UNKNOWN]: I just wanted to call this out because it was a fun, fun.
44:12 --> 44:20 [UNKNOWN]: Cool design, I like the design and it looked very, the NAS GALS have a very funny way of describing these things that I won't repeat it on our podcast.
44:20 --> 44:22 [UNKNOWN]: You don't have to go listen to their episode for coverage.
44:23 --> 44:31 [UNKNOWN]: But I was like, once I heard that, I was like, oh, I can't unsee that now.
44:31 --> 44:32 [UNKNOWN]: And apparently it has a name.
44:34 --> 44:36 [UNKNOWN]: So, okay.
44:37 --> 44:38 [UNKNOWN]: I don't want to know.
44:38 --> 44:45 [UNKNOWN]: So, for the rest of the episode, I have basically just done by setting.
44:45 --> 44:48 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't mean to do this, but it kind of just worked out that way.
44:48 --> 44:49 [UNKNOWN]: Worked a lot better.
44:49 --> 44:52 [UNKNOWN]: So, we're going to do all of the dwarfs stuff now.
44:52 --> 44:53 [UNKNOWN]: So, Kazadume.
44:53 --> 44:57 [UNKNOWN]: Angry about the Nazna Goul, the dwarven lords, demand that the seven rings.
44:58 --> 45:01 [UNKNOWN]: Doran refuses, but thrain sides with the lords.
45:01 --> 45:11 [UNKNOWN]: These address to speak sense and call out Sauron's trap, having admitted his father were the ring before naming him air, Doran is caught in a trap.
45:12 --> 45:20 [UNKNOWN]: the king's edict, naming his, him heir is made invalid, and Thrain is ready to step in the succession must be decided by combat.
45:21 --> 45:26 [UNKNOWN]: Disa warns Durin that he's always baited to anger by Thrain, Nervy says he must follow Thrain if he wins.
45:27 --> 45:33 [UNKNOWN]: Later, Rene promises Disa to withdraw his claim and leave the kingdom if he is given the seven rings.
45:35 --> 45:39 [UNKNOWN]: He promises not to tell Durin about their previous, or engagements too.
45:41 --> 45:47 [UNKNOWN]: Before he can do it, Disa confesses to sleeping with the rain when she and during were on a break.
45:47 --> 45:48 [UNKNOWN]: They were on a break.
45:48 --> 45:50 [UNKNOWN]: That's a friend's reference.
45:50 --> 45:58 [UNKNOWN]: Just before they got engaged, they agreed that their marriage is too strong to be broken by this and focused their efforts on beating the rain.
45:59 --> 46:01 [UNKNOWN]: The dwarves prepare for their duel.
46:01 --> 46:06 [UNKNOWN]: Doran feels confident until his son tells him about Thrain getting close with Thisa.
46:07 --> 46:09 [UNKNOWN]: The misunderstanding sends Doran into a rage.
46:09 --> 46:17 [UNKNOWN]: He attacks Thrain and has him cornered, but Thrain throws sand in his face and knocks Duran out, stopping just short of killing him.
46:17 --> 46:20 [UNKNOWN]: Nervy proclaims Thrain King of Kazudum.
46:23 --> 46:27 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, where do we start on that one?
46:27 --> 46:28 [UNKNOWN]: Let's get it out of the way.
46:29 --> 46:31 [UNKNOWN]: I hated the whole, well, I saw them.
46:32 --> 46:33 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, we're looking over.
46:33 --> 46:34 [UNKNOWN]: Can't go talk to her for a minute.
46:35 --> 46:36 [UNKNOWN]: No, we got to do this.
46:36 --> 46:39 [UNKNOWN]: We have time to train this still getting ready.
46:40 --> 46:42 [UNKNOWN]: We just got through this whole thing about how he's more mature now.
46:42 --> 46:45 [UNKNOWN]: We had character development, but apparently not.
46:46 --> 46:48 [UNKNOWN]: Just it pissed me off.
46:49 --> 46:51 [UNKNOWN]: It was not good right at part was not good writing.
46:52 --> 46:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was it was just a it was hand of the writer making Thrain King of Cows a Doom
46:57 --> 47:02 [UNKNOWN]: So there were a couple of people who on the discord we were talking this through.
47:03 --> 47:20 [UNKNOWN]: Some different ways that people are interpreting the Gamble comments and Durans reaction was it during being pissed because Thrain was, you know, getting up close to her and he's not mad about.
47:21 --> 47:38 [UNKNOWN]: Disa and their past relationship but he's mad that Thrain was pushing it so much and and and you know loses it or is it you know Oh the fell beast of jealousy is arising within him and he's insecure about his relationship and goes into the right
47:39 --> 47:42 [UNKNOWN]: regardless of how you decode that situation.
47:42 --> 47:57 [UNKNOWN]: The fact that we're doing this stupid toxic male behavior thing where me mad, me mad, me have big pain, me slash out at everything is effing stupid and just needs to go away from TV writing.
47:57 --> 48:02 [UNKNOWN]: It just really does nobody in any favors and it really pissed me off.
48:03 --> 48:05 [UNKNOWN]: Because I thought that they did something really interesting
48:06 --> 48:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, okay.
48:07 --> 48:07 [UNKNOWN]: I'm a little hurt.
48:08 --> 48:12 [UNKNOWN]: You kind of kept something from me, but I know our relationship is strong.
48:12 --> 48:14 [UNKNOWN]: I can see it in your face.
48:15 --> 48:16 [UNKNOWN]: I can see it in your eyes.
48:16 --> 48:18 [UNKNOWN]: I know the history that we've lived together.
48:18 --> 48:26 [UNKNOWN]: Let me just, there's no, let me honor our relationship and in honoring there is no space for me to be jealous or hurt or anything like that.
48:26 --> 48:29 [UNKNOWN]: Let me be cool and calculated and go kick my brother's ass.
48:30 --> 48:39 [UNKNOWN]: And then you had an interesting fight because then Thrain really did have to work extra hard to beat a level head of Duran and that would have been interesting.
48:40 --> 48:46 [UNKNOWN]: But this toxic man, oh, I can't control my pain, it's just, it really bothers me.
48:46 --> 48:48 [UNKNOWN]: It really, really is cheap, lazy writing.
48:48 --> 48:49 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
48:49 --> 48:55 [UNKNOWN]: I interpret it as Jessica did, excuse me, in her message that
48:56 --> 49:04 [UNKNOWN]: it was rage that Thrain had been sexually pursuing his wife, that he had been stalking her.
49:06 --> 49:15 [UNKNOWN]: I unfortunately think it was more than that because you had just had this long conversation where Doran asked probably a hundred times.
49:15 --> 49:16 [UNKNOWN]: I'm exaggerating.
49:16 --> 49:21 [UNKNOWN]: But like four or five times never again didn't happen again nothing now.
49:22 --> 49:25 [UNKNOWN]: He felt insecure at that time as we all would.
49:25 --> 49:26 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's fine, right?
49:26 --> 49:28 [UNKNOWN]: That's a natural reaction.
49:28 --> 49:34 [UNKNOWN]: But they did that to signal that it's not just about three, and this is about feeling betrayal from his wife.
49:34 --> 49:38 [UNKNOWN]: And I don't, they wanted to have it both ways.
49:38 --> 49:40 [UNKNOWN]: They wanted to have this heartwarming.
49:40 --> 49:43 [UNKNOWN]: I accept that you made a mistake, and I love you enough to forgive me.
49:43 --> 49:45 [UNKNOWN]: It wasn't even a mistake.
49:46 --> 49:47 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's not even a mistake.
49:47 --> 49:50 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it's sleep with the brother of your ex.
49:50 --> 49:52 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, okay fine, but she's a whole person.
49:52 --> 49:55 [UNKNOWN]: She can live her life, and I have no business.
49:59 --> 50:02 [UNKNOWN]: Now you could be doing like a three day break David.
50:02 --> 50:03 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
50:03 --> 50:05 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not this is not a full We're broken up.
50:05 --> 50:09 [UNKNOWN]: This is a I You tell which way I go on the ritual and rest.
50:09 --> 50:10 [UNKNOWN]: They were on the right
50:11 --> 50:15 [UNKNOWN]: And he comes back three days later and says, hey, let's say he changed.
50:15 --> 50:15 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
50:16 --> 50:21 [UNKNOWN]: And don't you think the time to tell him was then fine?
50:21 --> 50:26 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just saying like, I'm not saying that she's she made a mistake.
50:26 --> 50:29 [UNKNOWN]: She did she make the mistake was in keeping it from him.
50:29 --> 50:30 [UNKNOWN]: The mistake was not sleeping with him.
50:30 --> 50:33 [UNKNOWN]: And no, it's still bad to sleep with your axis brother.
50:33 --> 50:34 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying it's good.
50:34 --> 50:35 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying it's good.
50:35 --> 50:36 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just saying it's out of a mistake.
50:36 --> 50:37 [UNKNOWN]: She can choose what she wants to choose.
50:38 --> 50:40 [UNKNOWN]: She could choose it, but it's still bad thing to do.
50:40 --> 50:42 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't say that it wasn't bad.
50:42 --> 50:46 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just saying that before intent was to get back with Doran, which clearly it was.
50:46 --> 50:47 [UNKNOWN]: This was a mistake.
50:47 --> 50:57 [UNKNOWN]: I think her intent was to prevent him from blowing up, which is what he did, which is very much in character with how we have seen him all along.
50:58 --> 51:00 [UNKNOWN]: And he's called the firebeard for a reason.
51:01 --> 51:04 [UNKNOWN]: things get up his nose very easily and very quickly.
51:04 --> 51:06 [UNKNOWN]: But we have not seen that at all.
51:06 --> 51:10 [UNKNOWN]: This like he has become this different man stick with that story.
51:10 --> 51:13 [UNKNOWN]: Well, that's the interesting story, not that he loses a shit.
51:14 --> 51:19 [UNKNOWN]: I agree, but it's only been five years and you're talking about the habits of how many decades.
51:19 --> 51:25 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, but it's one of those truths that like he's he is reached a different stage in his life.
51:26 --> 51:28 [UNKNOWN]: And he did in the conversation with Disa.
51:29 --> 51:35 [UNKNOWN]: And then like his son says something and like you say John he doesn't take the time to go let me Yeah, no, that was a fault.
51:35 --> 51:36 [UNKNOWN]: That was a fault.
51:36 --> 51:37 [UNKNOWN]: I agree with you.
51:37 --> 51:58 [UNKNOWN]: This is what I'm saying is is if if you want to have this whole mature conversation of I believe our bond is stronger than that mistake, but you know you could debate what the mistake was but whatever it was Our bond is stronger than that you can't do that and then turn around and have him doubt his wife five minutes later Yeah, it's yeah, but I don't think it's easy.
51:58 --> 51:58 [UNKNOWN]: It's awful
51:59 --> 52:00 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think he did doubt his wife.
52:01 --> 52:02 [UNKNOWN]: I really don't know.
52:02 --> 52:04 [UNKNOWN]: But that's the case.
52:04 --> 52:06 [UNKNOWN]: If that's the case, then they did not do a good job telling that story.
52:07 --> 52:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, exactly.
52:07 --> 52:12 [UNKNOWN]: Because I think there's multiple interpreting the scene of what.
52:12 --> 52:13 [UNKNOWN]: So let's read Jessica's.
52:13 --> 52:14 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
52:15 --> 52:15 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
52:16 --> 52:20 [UNKNOWN]: I think it wasn't a miscommunication between Jordan and Gamel.
52:21 --> 52:32 [UNKNOWN]: I feel like Gamel was telling Duran that Thrain's advances on Disa were not consensual and were more threatening, which is why Duran's eyeer was directed at Thrain.
52:33 --> 52:54 [UNKNOWN]: for the harassment and not desai it was righteous albeit and in opportune moment and gammals also chosen in opportune moment to reveal it but both he and during were well intentioned as how i read it she says i think i'm sorry go ahead David yeah no so what i'm said what i want to point out is is that there are
52:55 --> 52:57 [UNKNOWN]: different people are decoding.
52:57 --> 52:58 [UNKNOWN]: So she's decoding it that way.
52:59 --> 53:01 [UNKNOWN]: I can't say what other other people are doing.
53:01 --> 53:06 [UNKNOWN]: I can say with the way that I read it was, nope, they're just falling back into the jealousy trap.
53:07 --> 53:19 [UNKNOWN]: And so I don't know how other people are decoding it, but if we are all perceiving it differently, then there is a fault in the writing of not telling us,
53:20 --> 53:26 [UNKNOWN]: Not constructing the scene, so it was clear why did Jordan lose his temperature, his temper.
53:26 --> 53:30 [UNKNOWN]: Because you wouldn't have had him asking multiple times.
53:30 --> 53:31 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
53:31 --> 53:40 [UNKNOWN]: If you wanted to tell me that this was a rock solid, unshakable thing that he would have just stopped her right there, whatever was in the past is in the past.
53:40 --> 53:42 [UNKNOWN]: and we're together, and we're here now.
53:42 --> 53:44 [UNKNOWN]: And that would've told me, okay, this is about the rain.
53:45 --> 53:46 [UNKNOWN]: But they did not do that.
53:47 --> 53:50 [UNKNOWN]: They had him be insecure and suspicious the whole time.
53:51 --> 53:59 [UNKNOWN]: The other thing is, I don't believe Disa wouldn't have smacked the shit out of the rain every time he went up to her and tried to seduce her like that.
54:00 --> 54:14 [UNKNOWN]: I think that the, again, hand of the writer is, is creating these scenes where she just lets him go near her and let him get right up to her in a way that's completely out of character for her.
54:14 --> 54:22 [UNKNOWN]: I think Disa, as Queen, recognized that to slap the brother of the king in public, for all to see, would probably not have been a smirk.
54:23 --> 54:24 [UNKNOWN]: They were private.
54:24 --> 54:27 [UNKNOWN]: They were in private a couple times, sometimes they were in public, but sometimes they were in private.
54:28 --> 54:33 [UNKNOWN]: And I still maintain that she did not see that as a politics move.
54:33 --> 54:35 [UNKNOWN]: I think I should have known both of them.
54:36 --> 54:40 [UNKNOWN]: long enough to know what isn't a clever thing to do.
54:41 --> 54:48 [UNKNOWN]: I also think that Gammley had a particular motive of wanting to tell his father, I'm on your side.
54:48 --> 54:51 [UNKNOWN]: I understand why you're so pissed at my uncle.
54:52 --> 54:55 [UNKNOWN]: Uh, naive teenage bro move.
54:56 --> 54:59 [UNKNOWN]: Right, and he wants his dad to kick this guy's ass.
54:59 --> 55:02 [UNKNOWN]: Right, right, yes, so you use it, whatever.
55:02 --> 55:03 [UNKNOWN]: And that's fine.
55:03 --> 55:08 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I don't, the, the, the dumb teenager doing the inopportune thing.
55:08 --> 55:09 [UNKNOWN]: I don't, that's not a problem.
55:09 --> 55:10 [UNKNOWN]: That, that's fine.
55:11 --> 55:11 [UNKNOWN]: I, I get it.
55:12 --> 55:18 [UNKNOWN]: And the cool thing would have been during would have been like, oh, that's interesting.
55:18 --> 55:19 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I'm going to go kick my brother's ass.
55:20 --> 55:23 [UNKNOWN]: But you see, can you talk about being in a new level now?
55:24 --> 55:26 [UNKNOWN]: I can't think of how many times I thought I was in a new level.
55:27 --> 55:27 [UNKNOWN]: Sure.
55:27 --> 55:29 [UNKNOWN]: And that had to cycle back again.
55:29 --> 55:33 [UNKNOWN]: That's fine, but we're, you know, do tell us an interesting story.
55:33 --> 55:39 [UNKNOWN]: Don't tell us a boring story about poor, you know, men who can't control their emotions.
55:39 --> 55:40 [UNKNOWN]: I just find it really interesting.
55:40 --> 55:45 [UNKNOWN]: It's the two guys in the room worked on him and I'm losing my cool over it.
55:45 --> 55:48 [UNKNOWN]: I wasn't gonna say that David, but there you go.
55:48 --> 55:54 [UNKNOWN]: And as the woman in the room I'm saying I could see this as being a stalker motivated.
55:55 --> 55:56 [UNKNOWN]: reaction, you know.
55:56 --> 56:07 [UNKNOWN]: Right, your decoding gig, a GAMLY's a comment as, and endurance reaction as I'm encoding during the reaction as you did that to my life.
56:07 --> 56:07 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
56:08 --> 56:11 [UNKNOWN]: All been for often terms of the, the con cool collected red beard.
56:12 --> 56:23 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, but still like, we were, well, we were just talking about this in family therapy the other week about how anger, you know, like, okay, get angry in a moment to like stop a kid running out on the street or touch
56:25 --> 56:31 [UNKNOWN]: but really it doesn't work for the long run and it's it's short-sighted and we see that here.
56:31 --> 56:32 [UNKNOWN]: He loses his own.
56:32 --> 56:32 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he loses everything.
56:33 --> 56:33 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
56:33 --> 56:35 [UNKNOWN]: All of that is aspirational David.
56:36 --> 56:39 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and they were telling us to work at it about it.
56:39 --> 56:41 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, and he worked through it.
56:41 --> 56:48 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm saying, I'm saying is it's lazy writing.
56:49 --> 56:56 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm insulted by the that they went there because they could have gone somewhere much more interesting.
56:57 --> 57:07 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I guess it's, you know, obviously everybody is entitled to how they interpret things and we're obviously different, because of the frames that we have built up over a lifetime.
57:08 --> 57:11 [UNKNOWN]: I just, it's a boring, it's boring.
57:11 --> 57:15 [UNKNOWN]: It's a boring way to tell a story about a guy who can't control himself.
57:16 --> 57:17 [UNKNOWN]: So.
57:17 --> 57:17 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
57:18 --> 57:21 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I think we've, we've, this one's a better.
57:22 --> 57:22 [UNKNOWN]: Sorry.
57:22 --> 57:23 [UNKNOWN]: We've hammered this.
57:26 --> 57:27 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, did it work for you?
57:27 --> 57:28 [UNKNOWN]: We've mind this.
57:28 --> 57:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
57:29 --> 57:31 [UNKNOWN]: We've mind this.
57:31 --> 57:32 [UNKNOWN]: There you go.
57:32 --> 57:32 [UNKNOWN]: Just a question.
57:32 --> 57:39 [UNKNOWN]: Question of action is in terms of the the the arc of the McKin the machinery of the plot.
57:39 --> 57:46 [UNKNOWN]: Did it work for you as of you or to have during lose everything in in this.
57:47 --> 57:49 [UNKNOWN]: Did the mechanisms work for you as a storytelling element?
57:49 --> 57:58 [UNKNOWN]: Absolutely, because Duran has wanted to plaster threens face all over three walls for decades.
57:59 --> 58:09 [UNKNOWN]: And Disa adding on this additional potential fuel, that was a big moment for him to listen, to not blow up, to wait to the end.
58:10 --> 58:15 [UNKNOWN]: And I think he was perfectly entitled to repeat, never, never since, never agreed.
58:15 --> 58:22 [UNKNOWN]: Because holy cow, I would not be able to sit there calmly and say, oh, yeah, so you use up with your ex-wife kind of thing.
58:23 --> 58:37 [UNKNOWN]: and it would take a lot of time for me to get through that and I do think it's quite realistic for doing to believe that he has gotten through it, that it's not going to stir him up.
58:38 --> 58:43 [UNKNOWN]: And then he just gets that one extra piece from Gammley and
58:48 --> 58:50 [UNKNOWN]: Because how could he not?
58:51 --> 58:59 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's a lot of expectation to put on somebody to change that much in such an emotionally charged situation to begin with.
59:01 --> 59:05 [UNKNOWN]: And it's the culmination of the back and forth between two brothers.
59:06 --> 59:32 [UNKNOWN]: and it's really decades of hurts, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah
59:33 --> 59:39 [UNKNOWN]: and have this kind of conversation that anybody in a long-term relationship probably has added some point in their lives.
59:40 --> 59:43 [UNKNOWN]: Often many times or the course of their relationship.
59:44 --> 59:46 [UNKNOWN]: And to see that modeled so well,
59:47 --> 59:49 [UNKNOWN]: Because it's clear, Jordan is hurt.
59:50 --> 59:51 [UNKNOWN]: Jordan is upset.
59:51 --> 59:58 [UNKNOWN]: Jordan is now full of self-doubt, which by the way, he'd already had with his whole, I might really probably King or not.
59:58 --> 01:00:02 [UNKNOWN]: And having to admit that his father was under the influence of the ring.
01:00:02 --> 01:00:02 [UNKNOWN]: That's a good point.
01:00:03 --> 01:00:04 [UNKNOWN]: That's got a hurt.
01:00:04 --> 01:00:04 [UNKNOWN]: That's got a hurt.
01:00:04 --> 01:00:14 [UNKNOWN]: He's brother showing up and then having the reveal and then actually coming to grips with the fact that, oh yeah, my dad was under the influence when he named me, he's, brother has been grinding his face in it.
01:00:15 --> 01:00:15 [UNKNOWN]: Right, right.
01:00:16 --> 01:00:18 [UNKNOWN]: For years, ever since he got back.
01:00:18 --> 01:00:21 [UNKNOWN]: And he's all prints door and already lost his prints to once.
01:00:22 --> 01:00:24 [UNKNOWN]: And he only got it back because of the ring.
01:00:24 --> 01:00:25 [UNKNOWN]: Right, so that's what he's got.
01:00:25 --> 01:00:26 [UNKNOWN]: And that's what he's got.
01:00:26 --> 01:00:27 [UNKNOWN]: Right, he's insecure.
01:00:27 --> 01:00:28 [UNKNOWN]: He's out.
01:00:28 --> 01:00:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:00:30 --> 01:00:37 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, that is all interesting and I think adds to my appreciation in the story.
01:00:37 --> 01:00:54 [UNKNOWN]: I just didn't like the mechanics, but when we understand what else is going on in during psychology and how insecure he's feeling, insecurity on top of insecurity on top of insecurity, and then his teenage son says one little thing.
01:00:55 --> 01:01:10 [UNKNOWN]: and no matter how it's coded or decoded in terms of what's going on with his relationship with his spouse, it is it's that instant of the ice just breaking through of his sense of security.
01:01:11 --> 01:01:12 [UNKNOWN]: I am king.
01:01:12 --> 01:01:13 [UNKNOWN]: I am better than this.
01:01:13 --> 01:01:21 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and I think it speaks well to both of you as guys, as men, that you has such a strong reaction against it.
01:01:22 --> 01:01:24 [UNKNOWN]: because you recognize the pattern in the history of it.
01:01:25 --> 01:01:26 [UNKNOWN]: And you are rejecting it.
01:01:26 --> 01:01:31 [UNKNOWN]: And I'm grateful and glad that you are, and I'm sure your spouse is sorry for that.
01:01:31 --> 01:01:34 [UNKNOWN]: My spouse, like, what do we owe our spouses?
01:01:34 --> 01:01:38 [UNKNOWN]: But, you know, they are whole and it's not my woman.
01:01:38 --> 01:01:40 [UNKNOWN]: It's not my wife.
01:01:40 --> 01:01:41 [UNKNOWN]: Sure.
01:01:41 --> 01:01:43 [UNKNOWN]: She is not my possession.
01:01:43 --> 01:01:51 [UNKNOWN]: And then if she does something wrong, quote unquote wrong, then it's mind uponish or to mind to be upset or my pride to be wounded or any of that.
01:01:53 --> 01:02:04 [UNKNOWN]: She is a, you know, my spouse is as a valid as a person and in their choices as I am and it's a power over its power with right exactly and I think do it and saw.
01:02:06 --> 01:02:09 [UNKNOWN]: Um, what I consider to be thrones hitting honor.
01:02:11 --> 01:02:15 [UNKNOWN]: As being an attack on her and you're and he's standing up for her.
01:02:15 --> 01:02:19 [UNKNOWN]: Who among all of us would not stand up for our partners and say hey.
01:02:19 --> 01:02:21 [UNKNOWN]: That was gross not get off.
01:02:21 --> 01:02:23 [UNKNOWN]: I guess where I'm getting tripped up as he was already doing that.
01:02:24 --> 01:02:24 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:02:24 --> 01:02:35 [UNKNOWN]: He was already doing what he was already during was already taking care of the rain and already knew that the rain had violated his trust in multiple ways.
01:02:36 --> 01:02:37 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I don't think
01:02:38 --> 01:02:46 [UNKNOWN]: But finding out this, if he thought it was just thrain, it was a unilaterally thrain going to DISA.
01:02:46 --> 01:02:48 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think that would have sent him into such a rage.
01:02:48 --> 01:02:51 [UNKNOWN]: I really think it was feeling like he was betrayed by DISA.
01:02:52 --> 01:02:54 [UNKNOWN]: Well, it was the culmination of the new thing, though.
01:02:55 --> 01:02:55 [UNKNOWN]: You know what I mean?
01:02:56 --> 01:03:01 [UNKNOWN]: I do think that there, I don't think that we can credibly say that this was only about the ring.
01:03:01 --> 01:03:04 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know, maybe we'll see in the next episode and he's like, fine with Disa.
01:03:05 --> 01:03:08 [UNKNOWN]: But I, that's gonna be really important.
01:03:08 --> 01:03:15 [UNKNOWN]: The next episode's gonna, I'll be shocked if they don't have a, at least a hard conversation about this.
01:03:16 --> 01:03:18 [UNKNOWN]: Of course they will, John, come on.
01:03:20 --> 01:03:25 [UNKNOWN]: I watch a little bit of five, but not I didn't see any dwarf story stuff yet.
01:03:25 --> 01:03:29 [UNKNOWN]: So I think that's a really good point and a really good thing to hang on.
01:03:29 --> 01:03:32 [UNKNOWN]: Like, let's see what they do with this going forward here.
01:03:32 --> 01:03:35 [UNKNOWN]: So that it can reflect, we can reflect back on this.
01:03:35 --> 01:03:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:03:35 --> 01:03:37 [UNKNOWN]: To be continued.
01:03:37 --> 01:03:38 [UNKNOWN]: No need to speculate.
01:03:38 --> 01:03:51 [UNKNOWN]: We got a lot of good blog posts this one of the how how you know the modern man's approach to infidelity Ring rings in rituals watch.
01:03:51 --> 01:03:59 [UNKNOWN]: I was very excited while they were getting ready for their ritual combat Which had a lot of black Panther vibes for me just from step-point
01:03:59 --> 01:04:08 [UNKNOWN]: It was I can't wait for season three of rings and rituals to talk about the, the, the rituals of preparing for their ritualized combat in the 2028 is going to go hard.
01:04:09 --> 01:04:14 [UNKNOWN]: And my lord, holding a burning coal in your hand for that.
01:04:14 --> 01:04:17 [UNKNOWN]: And then you start the combat totally.
01:04:17 --> 01:04:19 [UNKNOWN]: I know they're dwarfs, but come on.
01:04:19 --> 01:04:20 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
01:04:20 --> 01:04:22 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know if your biology is as affected by it.
01:04:24 --> 01:04:27 [UNKNOWN]: Evidently, more than made the reformed of stone, right?
01:04:27 --> 01:04:36 [UNKNOWN]: They were full of, so I, you know, I really like, I want to know more about that ritual of what I interpreted because we get no words.
01:04:36 --> 01:04:38 [UNKNOWN]: We not even know what, uh, gambling actually said.
01:04:39 --> 01:04:42 [UNKNOWN]: You know, we just see them talking together.
01:04:42 --> 01:04:53 [UNKNOWN]: Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh, shh
01:05:01 --> 01:05:05 [UNKNOWN]: is this, you know, buy my beard, is this true, buy your beard, is this true.
01:05:06 --> 01:05:08 [UNKNOWN]: So it's kind of like a dwarf pinky swear, right?
01:05:10 --> 01:05:12 [UNKNOWN]: At least that's what I was seeing in that image.
01:05:12 --> 01:05:12 [UNKNOWN]: Who knows?
01:05:13 --> 01:05:16 [UNKNOWN]: Let's see if Disa has a conversation with Gammley.
01:05:17 --> 01:05:22 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I think she is absolutely going to have a conversation with Gammley.
01:05:23 --> 01:05:27 [UNKNOWN]: Well, now that he's his uncles in charge, he could either go one way or the other.
01:05:27 --> 01:05:32 [UNKNOWN]: We could have another interesting sort of father- I don't think he's going with him.
01:05:32 --> 01:05:32 [UNKNOWN]: I'm kidding.
01:05:32 --> 01:05:33 [UNKNOWN]: I'm kidding.
01:05:33 --> 01:05:35 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I'm just, you know, I hope so.
01:05:35 --> 01:05:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:05:36 --> 01:05:38 [UNKNOWN]: I do know for my uncles cooler than my dad.
01:05:38 --> 01:05:39 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:05:39 --> 01:05:41 [UNKNOWN]: Well, every boy goes through that at some point.
01:05:41 --> 01:05:43 [UNKNOWN]: 100% thank you.
01:05:44 --> 01:05:49 [UNKNOWN]: I never had any brothers, so I'm doing this all from the detached observation.
01:05:49 --> 01:05:51 [UNKNOWN]: I had to and I'll give you my thoughts on it.
01:05:51 --> 01:05:52 [UNKNOWN]: Well, we're on break.
01:06:13 --> 01:06:21 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to preempt you, John, and just really quickly say, thank you everyone for just listening through a very activating non-percently.
01:06:22 --> 01:06:25 [UNKNOWN]: I think it was an important conversation.
01:06:25 --> 01:06:29 [UNKNOWN]: And I think we were all, I hope we were all respectful during it.
01:06:29 --> 01:06:30 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:06:30 --> 01:06:35 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I have to say that I never could have had that kind of a recession with the vast majority of men I know.
01:06:36 --> 01:06:42 [UNKNOWN]: So the fact that I can have it with both of you and feel perfectly comfortable doing so is a testimonial to you both.
01:06:43 --> 01:06:59 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I appreciate your respect and hearing us out and sharing your own view and that we could come to a place of understanding without losing our cool and losing the kingdom.
01:07:00 --> 01:07:07 [UNKNOWN]: And losing the sovereignty of our spirit.
01:07:07 --> 01:07:08 [UNKNOWN]: I can't make that swear.
01:07:09 --> 01:07:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'd love to read this next section, but, um, go for it.
01:07:12 --> 01:07:12 [UNKNOWN]: Say it.
01:07:12 --> 01:07:13 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:13 --> 01:07:13 [UNKNOWN]: Say it.
01:07:13 --> 01:07:14 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:14 --> 01:07:14 [UNKNOWN]: Say it.
01:07:14 --> 01:07:14 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:14 --> 01:07:15 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:15 --> 01:07:15 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:15 --> 01:07:16 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:16 --> 01:07:16 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:16 --> 01:07:17 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:17 --> 01:07:17 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:17 --> 01:07:17 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:17 --> 01:07:18 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:18 --> 01:07:19 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:19 --> 01:07:19 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:19 --> 01:07:20 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:20 --> 01:07:20 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:20 --> 01:07:20 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:20 --> 01:07:21 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:21 --> 01:07:21 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:21 --> 01:07:22 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:22 --> 01:07:22 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:22 --> 01:07:23 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:23 --> 01:07:23 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:23 --> 01:07:23 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:23 --> 01:07:24 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
01:07:25 --> 01:07:29 [UNKNOWN]: Elrond arrives after defeating 16 orcs and asks the other Lord.
01:07:30 --> 01:07:33 [UNKNOWN]: Lord's for permission to ask Numenar for help.
01:07:33 --> 01:07:36 [UNKNOWN]: They say they already did, and Pharaoh refused.
01:07:36 --> 01:07:39 [UNKNOWN]: Elrond suggests Gilgallad go to Numenar personally.
01:07:41 --> 01:07:48 [UNKNOWN]: Gilgallad doesn't want to debase himself but cure Donbury frames it as humility and suggests that they send another emissary who looks a heck of a lot like Elros.
01:07:49 --> 01:07:51 [UNKNOWN]: Gee, I wonder who that could be.
01:07:51 --> 01:07:51 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, right.
01:07:53 --> 01:07:55 [UNKNOWN]: So Belle Rios is busy here.
01:07:55 --> 01:08:00 [UNKNOWN]: He's, uh, he's dropped all of the, all the, uh, good quotes.
01:08:00 --> 01:08:06 [UNKNOWN]: The only things in this world that are truly lost are those for which we cease to search.
01:08:07 --> 01:08:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's good.
01:08:08 --> 01:08:09 [UNKNOWN]: That's, uh, what are the audio clips that I pulled?
01:08:10 --> 01:08:20 [UNKNOWN]: I have always believed to know, and our soldiers looked me for it now, some assurance that
01:08:24 --> 01:08:30 [UNKNOWN]: I would give anything to give it to them, but what am I to do and hope is lost.
01:08:30 --> 01:08:38 [UNKNOWN]: The only things in this world that are ever truly lost are those for which we cease to search.
01:08:41 --> 01:08:43 [UNKNOWN]: Except the Silverells, those are lost.
01:08:44 --> 01:08:48 [UNKNOWN]: The Sun's a fan are getting them even though they might be searching.
01:08:49 --> 01:08:57 [UNKNOWN]: So this sort of led me down this a little bit of a rabbit hole among the nature of hope and what is hope.
01:08:58 --> 01:09:02 [UNKNOWN]: And there's different, there's actually different kinds of hope.
01:09:02 --> 01:09:08 [UNKNOWN]: You know, there's hope that something specific will win, you know, winning the lottery, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
01:09:08 --> 01:09:10 [UNKNOWN]: Or there's, there's hope that
01:09:11 --> 01:09:18 [UNKNOWN]: The future more generalized hope that things can look differently than they are now.
01:09:18 --> 01:09:24 [UNKNOWN]: Like there's some perceived unfortunateness in the future, and we can hope that that may be different.
01:09:26 --> 01:09:32 [UNKNOWN]: And hope isn't necessarily prediction, but it's this willingness to act without knowing things will turn out.
01:09:32 --> 01:09:40 [UNKNOWN]: So that's like hope is a kind of a collective action, a chorus of people coming together.
01:09:41 --> 01:09:43 [UNKNOWN]: which makes me think of courage as contagious, right?
01:09:43 --> 01:09:51 [UNKNOWN]: You know, for all, helping together and taking action together, Mississippi, like we can, you know, see real change.
01:09:52 --> 01:09:56 [UNKNOWN]: But then, you hope is interesting as well, because it can be like a deferment of grief.
01:09:58 --> 01:10:07 [UNKNOWN]: And it can also lead to a false sense of things which are like, I'm hopeful that it can change and then it kind of generates a sense of complexity, complexity.
01:10:08 --> 01:10:15 [UNKNOWN]: So I just think it's really interesting that this one comment just opens up this whole conversation.
01:10:15 --> 01:10:16 [UNKNOWN]: What is hope?
01:10:16 --> 01:10:17 [UNKNOWN]: What's the nature of hope?
01:10:17 --> 01:10:18 [UNKNOWN]: How does it function?
01:10:19 --> 01:10:20 [UNKNOWN]: I can give you Tolkien's answer.
01:10:21 --> 01:10:21 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:10:23 --> 01:10:25 [UNKNOWN]: Tolkien has two kinds of hope in the middle of earth.
01:10:26 --> 01:10:30 [UNKNOWN]: One is on dear and the other is a stale.
01:10:30 --> 01:10:31 [UNKNOWN]: We've talked about this before.
01:10:31 --> 01:10:38 [UNKNOWN]: We have those who want to do the really deep dive, can read the Athra Beth, which is in one of the last volumes.
01:10:39 --> 01:10:42 [UNKNOWN]: And Dr. Sarabran is currently teaching a superb class on the right now.
01:10:44 --> 01:10:46 [UNKNOWN]: So, on dear is your general kind of,
01:10:49 --> 01:10:50 [UNKNOWN]: Right, I hope it doesn't rain tomorrow.
01:10:51 --> 01:10:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's that's a perfect example of I'm dear, because you have knowledge that it might rain, it might not rain or whatever.
01:10:57 --> 01:11:01 [UNKNOWN]: Estelle is more like trust.
01:11:01 --> 01:11:08 [UNKNOWN]: Estelle is, you could have hope in the ultimate outcome because you trust.
01:11:10 --> 01:11:19 [UNKNOWN]: in Spibibi, if you like, if you're aware of that concept, or trust at something will come about, even though you can't see the end.
01:11:19 --> 01:11:24 [UNKNOWN]: And there's a reason why one of Erdogan's names is Estelle.
01:11:24 --> 01:11:25 [UNKNOWN]: That's what he was named as a baby.
01:11:26 --> 01:11:26 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
01:11:27 --> 01:11:28 [UNKNOWN]: They name in your baby home.
01:11:28 --> 01:11:35 [UNKNOWN]: They write exactly, but in this instance, they trusted that he might be the one.
01:11:36 --> 01:11:43 [UNKNOWN]: to bring about the return of the new minority in line to the throne of Gondor and United Kingdoms.
01:11:44 --> 01:11:46 [UNKNOWN]: Tough break that I'm going to do a career quiz as a baby.
01:11:48 --> 01:11:53 [UNKNOWN]: Well, maybe it's more like his mother, because he didn't have much to say about anything at that point.
01:11:54 --> 01:12:01 [UNKNOWN]: But yeah, as always, thank the valour for cured down, because he does of all characters in body
01:12:03 --> 01:12:05 [UNKNOWN]: trust in the Valor.
01:12:06 --> 01:12:18 [UNKNOWN]: And even in that concept of Spivimi, I know, I can quarrel with his take on, you know, perfection has come to Middle-earth, but he does recognize the perfection that originates with the Valor.
01:12:18 --> 01:12:23 [UNKNOWN]: And of course, we know that even the Valor are not perfect, shall we say.
01:12:24 --> 01:12:30 [UNKNOWN]: So, I think at this point, Guildala appears to have lost both Amdir and Estelle.
01:12:32 --> 01:12:36 [UNKNOWN]: But I will also say uneasy lies the head of which authority rests.
01:12:37 --> 01:12:44 [UNKNOWN]: He's carrying literally the fate of Middle-earth right now, as he sees it, and he's not altogether wrong.
01:12:46 --> 01:13:00 [UNKNOWN]: So maybe this is one of the things that makes him so great that the heart presiders sing about him in later years, that he has lost all hope and he still keeps going, not
01:13:01 --> 01:13:03 [UNKNOWN]: one or two habits that we know about.
01:13:04 --> 01:13:07 [UNKNOWN]: Who climb all the way up to not do him to throw away a piece of jewelry.
01:13:09 --> 01:13:10 [UNKNOWN]: I think the way you put that, that's very funny.
01:13:11 --> 01:13:11 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I didn't know.
01:13:11 --> 01:13:13 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I wanted to talk about it in that way.
01:13:13 --> 01:13:15 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I just checked his ring and yeah, it is.
01:13:16 --> 01:13:16 [UNKNOWN]: Brings.
01:13:16 --> 01:13:18 [UNKNOWN]: The gold jewelry is so tacky.
01:13:18 --> 01:13:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:13:18 --> 01:13:23 [UNKNOWN]: That's a quote from very secret diaries, which folks have never heard of this.
01:13:23 --> 01:13:24 [UNKNOWN]: It's very funny.
01:13:25 --> 01:13:29 [UNKNOWN]: I've had a gay friend read it and he thought it was hysterical.
01:13:29 --> 01:13:33 [UNKNOWN]: Some people might find it a little bit overly snarky about gay men.
01:13:34 --> 01:13:39 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's great, and that was that comment came from legalists.
01:13:40 --> 01:13:40 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
01:13:40 --> 01:13:41 [UNKNOWN]: He thinks it's a great hit.
01:13:41 --> 01:13:44 [UNKNOWN]: He's a great mission because gold joy is so tacky.
01:13:44 --> 01:13:45 [UNKNOWN]: So let's get it.
01:13:46 --> 01:13:53 [UNKNOWN]: An old grumpy homeless man tricks a short person and his friend to sneak into a foreign country all in order to destroy former neighbor's jewelry.
01:13:55 --> 01:13:58 [UNKNOWN]: I got that one from one bad larry, a Reddit user.
01:13:59 --> 01:14:00 [UNKNOWN]: Well, there you go.
01:14:00 --> 01:14:01 [UNKNOWN]: There you go.
01:14:02 --> 01:14:09 [UNKNOWN]: So the other, so there's just in this conversation with Keardon and Gil Gallad, there's two different conversations happen.
01:14:10 --> 01:14:13 [UNKNOWN]: There's the first, the second one which is about hope, which we just talked about.
01:14:14 --> 01:14:21 [UNKNOWN]: The other one is about war and the cost of war and just victory, so John, if you could play that other audio quote.
01:14:22 --> 01:14:27 [UNKNOWN]: Another victory to call this a victory.
01:14:28 --> 01:14:32 [UNKNOWN]: is almost a mockery given how dearly it cost.
01:14:32 --> 01:14:32 [UNKNOWN]: Costs.
01:14:32 --> 01:14:35 [UNKNOWN]: It makes sacred that which it presents.
01:14:36 --> 01:14:41 [UNKNOWN]: A lindon free from Sauron's rule, but for how long for today.
01:14:41 --> 01:14:43 [UNKNOWN]: And that alone is causing off the hope.
01:14:46 --> 01:14:47 [UNKNOWN]: So!
01:14:48 --> 01:14:51 [UNKNOWN]: The cost that makes sacred, that which it preserves.
01:14:52 --> 01:14:54 [UNKNOWN]: So there's two things in my mind on this.
01:14:54 --> 01:15:00 [UNKNOWN]: There's one about the Mahabharata and Vishnu having a conversation with Arjuna, which will kick for a second.
01:15:01 --> 01:15:08 [UNKNOWN]: But the other one is this idea of a just war and just wars being fought.
01:15:09 --> 01:15:12 [UNKNOWN]: Justly can be fought justly or they can be fought unjustly.
01:15:13 --> 01:15:36 [UNKNOWN]: And regardless, there's terrible tolls that are taken regardless, and it just makes, again, makes me think of Tolkien and his experience with World War I and then having a son go through a World War II and this idea that man, you've got this power that is emanating at you and shooting rockets at you and dropping bombs on you and you're doing the same, but like you're
01:15:38 --> 01:15:51 [UNKNOWN]: and you're feeling pretty pressed by things and so just this idea of the cost of quote-unquote victory and what what what does winning in a situation like that mean can you win that?
01:15:52 --> 01:16:02 [UNKNOWN]: Some of the most sacred spaces in towns and cities up and down to UK are the memorials, the Senate House,
01:16:03 --> 01:16:08 [UNKNOWN]: that were created after World War I, pain on her of their beloved dead.
01:16:09 --> 01:16:12 [UNKNOWN]: And they are very, very solemn places.
01:16:13 --> 01:16:21 [UNKNOWN]: I think even to this day, so that is how they are trying to make sacred, the memory of all those who were lost.
01:16:21 --> 01:16:23 [UNKNOWN]: Right, right.
01:16:23 --> 01:16:25 [UNKNOWN]: And never forget, never forget.
01:16:25 --> 01:16:29 [UNKNOWN]: And they just had their day a couple of weeks ago.
01:16:29 --> 01:16:33 [UNKNOWN]: No, never, 11th, yeah, I'm a, I'm a, I'm a, I'm a, I'm a,
01:16:33 --> 01:16:33 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:16:34 --> 01:16:43 [UNKNOWN]: And a Nari on when he's training the soldier, sorry, John, in the past episode, I forget the line.
01:16:43 --> 01:16:47 [UNKNOWN]: I wish I'd pulled it, but he's asking them like, do you understand what you're fighting for here?
01:16:48 --> 01:16:49 [UNKNOWN]: What are you fighting for?
01:16:49 --> 01:16:50 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, straight up.
01:16:51 --> 01:16:51 [UNKNOWN]: Sorry, John.
01:16:51 --> 01:16:51 [UNKNOWN]: Go ahead.
01:16:52 --> 01:16:55 [UNKNOWN]: It's also an inversion of the end just to find the means.
01:16:55 --> 01:16:57 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
01:16:57 --> 01:16:59 [UNKNOWN]: Because here the means justify the end.
01:17:01 --> 01:17:08 [UNKNOWN]: It's interesting, I never, I didn't process it that way when watching it, but when seeing it written out, I'm like, oh, yeah.
01:17:08 --> 01:17:10 [UNKNOWN]: That's an interesting little inversion there.
01:17:10 --> 01:17:14 [UNKNOWN]: Which then if you go to the Mahabharata, which is this ancient Indian sort of...
01:17:16 --> 01:17:21 [UNKNOWN]: Odyssey and what's the other one, they're part of the Odyssey, the movie.
01:17:21 --> 01:17:21 [UNKNOWN]: Really?
01:17:21 --> 01:17:22 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
01:17:22 --> 01:17:27 [UNKNOWN]: It's like five times as long as like the Iliate or something like that, it's crazy long.
01:17:27 --> 01:17:33 [UNKNOWN]: But the book, the Bhagavad Gita, and I've talked about this before, is one slice of that story.
01:17:34 --> 01:17:46 [UNKNOWN]: and it's when these two families are going to war and on the eve of battle, Arjuna, one of the brothers of this one side of the family is sitting there and it's for him to call to blow the horn and start the whole battle.
01:17:47 --> 01:17:49 [UNKNOWN]: And he's talking to an avatar
01:17:52 --> 01:17:57 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying Christ like in the sense of a Savior form, but in a teacher form.
01:17:57 --> 01:18:07 [UNKNOWN]: He's an avatar that's a teacher, and he's sent to Earth to help people figure things out and do heroic deeds, so people are inspired and all that kind of stuff.
01:18:07 --> 01:18:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm really, really simplifying stuff, but he has this whole long conversation about look.
01:18:12 --> 01:18:18 [UNKNOWN]: He did everything that you had to do to try to avoid this, but here we are, and there
01:18:20 --> 01:18:24 [UNKNOWN]: And the quickest way to get through this and be done with it, is to be done with it.
01:18:25 --> 01:18:38 [UNKNOWN]: Go through it, be as effective and quick as you can with everything, and let go of your reservations, and prosecute the war as best as you can to get the war over as quickly.
01:18:38 --> 01:18:43 [UNKNOWN]: Again, that's not the goal of the conversation, the goal of the conversation is kind of a detached action thing.
01:18:44 --> 01:18:46 [UNKNOWN]: But this idea that was like, well, this is going to suck.
01:18:47 --> 01:18:47 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:18:48 --> 01:19:04 [UNKNOWN]: So get it done and be done with it and know that you did everything that you could have to prevent it and win faced with no other choice, then you commit to the action and it's the right action to move through it without reservation.
01:19:05 --> 01:19:16 [UNKNOWN]: I always think of something that wise person told me once which is, if you feel that you are left with no other choice, then you have to ask, who did you give that choice away to?
01:19:18 --> 01:19:37 [UNKNOWN]: You know, if I had a nickel for every time David brought up the Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gapava Gap
01:19:54 --> 01:20:00 [UNKNOWN]: It's hard, there are certain political ends that don't seem to be able to be accomplished without it.
01:20:00 --> 01:20:09 [UNKNOWN]: What I respect is the honor of the people who take about a servant a certain way and they feel that's out.
01:20:10 --> 01:20:12 [UNKNOWN]: I can honor and respect that.
01:20:17 --> 01:20:22 [UNKNOWN]: This is my path as my calling, or this is the bowel I've made, and then I see that through.
01:20:23 --> 01:20:23 [UNKNOWN]: I take your word.
01:20:24 --> 01:20:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and I don't, I don't see, I don't, I don't glory in it, and I don't, you know, I don't go overboard or whatever.
01:20:30 --> 01:20:35 [UNKNOWN]: The path of balance and the path of right action is, it's not an egregious thing.
01:20:36 --> 01:20:46 [UNKNOWN]: So, the, there's a book I'm reading right now on the rumble, the elder leggings, and you know, the BOB character is a trained assassin.
01:20:47 --> 01:20:58 [UNKNOWN]: And like many fantasy books these days, there's often the little excerpts of other texts in the beginning of the chapters.
01:20:59 --> 01:21:06 [UNKNOWN]: In universe texts, and one of the things that was set in one of them was, there is no such thing as a merciful death.
01:21:07 --> 01:21:12 [UNKNOWN]: It is just that the pain is out of sight of the one perpetrator got
01:21:14 --> 01:21:33 [UNKNOWN]: The person being drowned is still screaming that you just can't hear it the same thing with smothering with a pillow or things like that The full of it well, you know, like be you know It was an interesting thing it was just saying like the quick death is not actually merciful It just makes you feel better doing it exactly exactly and I was like wow
01:21:34 --> 01:21:45 [UNKNOWN]: That's such an interesting thing because you read all these, you know, all these stories of like noble warriors and people, you know, again, and justifying the means.
01:21:46 --> 01:21:51 [UNKNOWN]: And like, oh, well, I gave him a quick death at least, like, and not actually better.
01:21:52 --> 01:21:54 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe it's better, but it's not good at least.
01:21:54 --> 01:21:56 [UNKNOWN]: It could have been worse, but it really wasn't.
01:21:57 --> 01:21:57 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:21:58 --> 01:21:58 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:21:58 --> 01:22:05 [UNKNOWN]: And that is, it is brought to mind as we're talking about this just versus unjust war thing.
01:22:05 --> 01:22:05 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:22:05 --> 01:22:10 [UNKNOWN]: Like it is just you trying to make yourself feel better about a bad thing you're doing.
01:22:10 --> 01:22:10 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:22:11 --> 01:22:11 [UNKNOWN]: But then.
01:22:13 --> 01:22:18 [UNKNOWN]: Well, let's not debate the gesture or theory on this podcast.
01:22:18 --> 01:22:19 [UNKNOWN]: No, let's do it for another 20 minutes.
01:22:19 --> 01:22:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, exactly.
01:22:21 --> 01:22:23 [UNKNOWN]: I would like to hear about Newman Audit John.
01:22:23 --> 01:22:24 [UNKNOWN]: Let's get to Newman, or.
01:22:24 --> 01:22:25 [UNKNOWN]: It's a great time over there.
01:22:26 --> 01:22:27 [UNKNOWN]: Nothing bad happening.
01:22:27 --> 01:22:31 [UNKNOWN]: Cameron talks to a lendial about his birth out of wedlock.
01:22:32 --> 01:22:36 [UNKNOWN]: His mother was a sex worker and when Pharaoh and found Cameron, he killed his mother and took him.
01:22:37 --> 01:22:40 [UNKNOWN]: Elendio offers Kevin a way to change his path and join the faithful.
01:22:40 --> 01:22:43 [UNKNOWN]: The prison cart is stopped for a message from Ferris' own.
01:22:44 --> 01:22:47 [UNKNOWN]: When Kevin exits, the trap springs and the faithful kill his underage.
01:22:48 --> 01:22:53 [UNKNOWN]: An Aryan holds Kevin at swordpoint, but is stopped by his father who believes Kevin is worth more alive.
01:22:54 --> 01:22:56 [UNKNOWN]: A lot of great quotes over here, right?
01:22:56 --> 01:22:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:22:57 --> 01:23:00 [UNKNOWN]: And then I have an audio quote of a lendial talking to Kevin as well.
01:23:01 --> 01:23:01 [UNKNOWN]: Here we go.
01:23:02 --> 01:23:02 [UNKNOWN]: Pretty.
01:23:03 --> 01:23:04 [UNKNOWN]: Natty stayed his hand.
01:23:04 --> 01:23:07 [UNKNOWN]: Did he give you the chance to escape where you were born?
01:23:07 --> 01:23:10 [UNKNOWN]: Would you spend your whole life horing yourself to his darkest instincts?
01:23:14 --> 01:23:16 [UNKNOWN]: Do you think insulting me will save your neck?
01:23:16 --> 01:23:18 [UNKNOWN]: I wasn't insulting you, son.
01:23:18 --> 01:23:20 [UNKNOWN]: Stranger doesn't listen.
01:23:20 --> 01:23:29 [UNKNOWN]: I was taking up the title interest in you, so... And, you know, first of all, he wasn't insulting him.
01:23:29 --> 01:23:31 [UNKNOWN]: But he was like this.
01:23:31 --> 01:23:33 [UNKNOWN]: You can give him a way out, but also insult him.
01:23:33 --> 01:23:34 [UNKNOWN]: But let's be honest.
01:23:34 --> 01:23:35 [UNKNOWN]: Don't leave.
01:23:35 --> 01:23:36 [UNKNOWN]: Don't leave.
01:23:37 --> 01:23:39 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you to see your son.
01:23:39 --> 01:23:40 [UNKNOWN]: He made a yummy joke.
01:23:41 --> 01:23:41 [UNKNOWN]: Oh.
01:23:42 --> 01:23:43 [UNKNOWN]: Really, okay.
01:23:43 --> 01:23:49 [UNKNOWN]: I'm I'm just so no, but he was saying basically like you are being an awful person You could do better, but you're being an awful person.
01:23:49 --> 01:23:50 [UNKNOWN]: It absolutely wasn't.
01:23:50 --> 01:24:08 [UNKNOWN]: It's all I thought that was kind of At the same time of being right turn really interesting But then you cut it off right before what I thought was the interesting part is when Kevin goes Souls are for fools and children in a lendil replies and yet when your soul is free no chain can bind you Lovely lovely dialogue there.
01:24:09 --> 01:24:10 [UNKNOWN]: That's a lendil right there
01:24:11 --> 01:24:28 [UNKNOWN]: We are so interesting that we are debate last night about him, sort of around here and I was like, oh, this is the Ellen deal that, you know, don't kill him, like, you know, pity, pity is whatever the pity line is.
01:24:28 --> 01:24:30 [UNKNOWN]: Well, the thing is, we get...
01:24:33 --> 01:24:41 [UNKNOWN]: You know, basically a rephrasing of Gandalf Spikker from a lendial, which is he says let the Valor keep their own counsel on who deserves to live.
01:24:42 --> 01:24:46 [UNKNOWN]: That is exactly the message that Gandalf gives Frodo when talking about Valor.
01:24:48 --> 01:24:56 [UNKNOWN]: And it works in this scene, not as a member buried, but actually something that I feel this is Ellen Diel's nature and his character.
01:24:56 --> 01:24:58 [UNKNOWN]: Great point David.
01:24:58 --> 01:25:01 [UNKNOWN]: And for you, he's in the language of the faithful.
01:25:01 --> 01:25:06 [UNKNOWN]: So again, we've criticized the writers quite a bit this episode and then that episode.
01:25:06 --> 01:25:09 [UNKNOWN]: But this was, I thought, a plus dialogue.
01:25:09 --> 01:25:10 [UNKNOWN]: This was fantastic.
01:25:10 --> 01:25:11 [UNKNOWN]: It was superb.
01:25:12 --> 01:25:14 [UNKNOWN]: They seem to really allow themselves to flour
01:25:18 --> 01:25:21 [UNKNOWN]: the whole storyline about which we have the very least amount of information.
01:25:23 --> 01:25:39 [UNKNOWN]: It's much more of a blank canvas for them to draw on, they have a few plot points, and they're just really knocking it out of the park with how they decide to enact these basic plot points, and I've been really impressed.
01:25:40 --> 01:25:55 [UNKNOWN]: That's interesting, because I feel like we have more, I mean, obviously we don't have the whole like Kevin possible redemption arc in the books, but you do have more of a complete sketch of the order of events in Newman R, than you do in like Kaza Doom.
01:25:56 --> 01:25:59 [UNKNOWN]: And that, I think, Kaza Doom, I think, has been some of the worst writing this season.
01:25:59 --> 01:26:09 [UNKNOWN]: So I would almost say the opposite is when they have a track to follow, they are better at coloring in the lines than they are about sketching their own new scenery.
01:26:10 --> 01:26:14 [UNKNOWN]: No, I think we're saying the same thing as when we call the opposite from you.
01:26:14 --> 01:26:14 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:26:14 --> 01:26:16 [UNKNOWN]: Well, then I better retrace.
01:26:18 --> 01:26:21 [UNKNOWN]: They have certain points in the plot that they know they have to hit.
01:26:21 --> 01:26:22 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:26:23 --> 01:26:28 [UNKNOWN]: And how they are getting from point A to point B is entirely up to them.
01:26:29 --> 01:26:30 [UNKNOWN]: And I love what they're doing.
01:26:31 --> 01:26:31 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:26:31 --> 01:26:35 [UNKNOWN]: And I think they feel less constrained and therefore they feel more free.
01:26:37 --> 01:26:41 [UNKNOWN]: to embroider and elaborate and give us a really wonderful story.
01:26:42 --> 01:26:45 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't hear that that way the first time some glad you said it again.
01:26:46 --> 01:26:47 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, I did too.
01:26:47 --> 01:26:49 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:26:49 --> 01:26:52 [UNKNOWN]: We see that a lot with the Sauron stuff in the way that Dickers is playing.
01:26:52 --> 01:26:52 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:26:53 --> 01:26:53 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:26:53 --> 01:26:57 [UNKNOWN]: Another all but blank canvas upon which they're doing gorgeous artwork.
01:26:59 --> 01:27:02 [UNKNOWN]: And the, the deep baritone tones of Lloyd Owen was taking an interest in your soul, my son.
01:27:02 --> 01:27:03 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, like, no, boy, that's daddy.
01:27:03 --> 01:27:05 [UNKNOWN]: You can have an interest role.
01:27:05 --> 01:27:22 [UNKNOWN]: You can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you can have a role, you
01:27:24 --> 01:27:40 [UNKNOWN]: Um, so there, there were some comments on the discord, and I don't disagree that, um, an Aryan's jetpacking across the, and being able to intercept a four-horse carriage running out at full speed somehow they were able to, uh, upper bed.
01:27:40 --> 01:27:40 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:27:40 --> 01:27:41 [UNKNOWN]: That was a bit of a bad.
01:27:41 --> 01:27:52 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I'm finally, I'm fine that he, he rescues his father and you know, they dispatch the guards and, you know, and he has the whole moment of like, do I kill him?
01:27:52 --> 01:27:55 [UNKNOWN]: Do I not, you know, pity is pity, but yeah, I was ridiculous.
01:27:56 --> 01:27:57 [UNKNOWN]: Get your cereal bowl out, kids.
01:27:57 --> 01:27:58 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:27:58 --> 01:27:58 [UNKNOWN]: We are.
01:27:58 --> 01:28:02 [UNKNOWN]: We're gonna, we're gonna enjoy this for what it is.
01:28:04 --> 01:28:09 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, when Nillendiel says, don't kill him, he's worth more alive.
01:28:09 --> 01:28:13 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think that's necessarily a company thought to kill him.
01:28:13 --> 01:28:14 [UNKNOWN]: No, no.
01:28:14 --> 01:28:17 [UNKNOWN]: No, I think it was you speaking an audience language as well.
01:28:18 --> 01:28:18 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
01:28:18 --> 01:28:19 [UNKNOWN]: That's what I was just saying.
01:28:19 --> 01:28:20 [UNKNOWN]: It's a good point.
01:28:20 --> 01:28:21 [UNKNOWN]: He's a good point.
01:28:21 --> 01:28:22 [UNKNOWN]: Him saying, like, I think I could save him.
01:28:22 --> 01:28:24 [UNKNOWN]: And Aryan's just going to be like, shank.
01:28:24 --> 01:28:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'm right.
01:28:25 --> 01:28:25 [UNKNOWN]: We're not saving him.
01:28:25 --> 01:28:28 [UNKNOWN]: But saying he's worth more alive.
01:28:28 --> 01:28:29 [UNKNOWN]: He's like, oh, right.
01:28:29 --> 01:28:30 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:28:31 --> 01:28:50 [UNKNOWN]: And I also now understand, perhaps, why Fettison would have been holding back before proclaiming Eminence's heir, because as I understand this story, it was Fettison who engendered the boy with his sex worker and mother, but that's not the same thing as a legit quote-unquote legitimate dissent from father to son.
01:28:51 --> 01:28:57 [UNKNOWN]: So Numanorians might be less comfortable with automatically accepting Kevin as the obvious next heir.
01:28:58 --> 01:29:06 [UNKNOWN]: So having his father's proclamation in court is more than just the formality that it would have been, say, with, um, taro dotionner.
01:29:07 --> 01:29:08 [UNKNOWN]: Although taro dotion was kind of, uh, if you do.
01:29:08 --> 01:29:08 [UNKNOWN]: Can you hear that?
01:29:08 --> 01:29:09 [UNKNOWN]: Can I hear what?
01:29:09 --> 01:29:10 [UNKNOWN]: How does a bastard, or do a Hamilton man?
01:29:10 --> 01:29:23 [UNKNOWN]: Do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a Hamilton man, do a
01:29:23 --> 01:29:30 [UNKNOWN]: I was just trying to think of what the bastered last name is for a new minority and oh my gosh, like the game of thrones last time.
01:29:30 --> 01:29:30 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, exactly.
01:29:30 --> 01:29:32 [UNKNOWN]: See, I think it would be see.
01:29:32 --> 01:29:33 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:29:37 --> 01:30:03 [UNKNOWN]: uh... we that it wasn't interesting reveal though and uh... boy you're like oh man can then like now i get you and like oh i kind of have some i kind of feel like uh... salron listening to theos sob story you know like oh my god but then yeah you say you're still an odious worm well and it also helps me understand a little bit better uh...
01:30:04 --> 01:30:16 [UNKNOWN]: Why he might just toss out in the side because desperate desperate desire to be accepted would fire out way any kind of considerations in his mind.
01:30:16 --> 01:30:28 [UNKNOWN]: And this is an interesting development in what we thought was a very sort of paper thin mustache twirling character and actually creates a lot of interesting depth for him.
01:30:28 --> 01:30:34 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and again one of those spaces were like, Oh, the writers have room because I don't think Kevin's a named character, right?
01:30:34 --> 01:30:35 [UNKNOWN]: Not at all.
01:30:35 --> 01:30:35 [UNKNOWN]: Not at all.
01:30:35 --> 01:30:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:30:36 --> 01:30:38 [UNKNOWN]: So there's another one John that add to our list of probably dead.
01:30:38 --> 01:30:40 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he's probably dead.
01:30:41 --> 01:30:44 [UNKNOWN]: If we see what they've done, if he lastly remore episode, they'll be shocked.
01:30:45 --> 01:30:48 [UNKNOWN]: Well, given the eventual outcome, which I will not mention, thank you, Golem.
01:30:50 --> 01:30:54 [UNKNOWN]: I think we kind of know that he is already dead eventually.
01:30:54 --> 01:30:56 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, in the overarching things.
01:30:57 --> 01:30:59 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, certainly by the time of the third age, he's dead.
01:30:59 --> 01:31:01 [UNKNOWN]: So I'll give you that.
01:31:01 --> 01:31:01 [UNKNOWN]: There we go.
01:31:02 --> 01:31:03 [UNKNOWN]: There we go.
01:31:03 --> 01:31:04 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:31:04 --> 01:31:08 [UNKNOWN]: So shall we head on to the fortress of Goondabad?
01:31:09 --> 01:31:10 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yeah.
01:31:10 --> 01:31:11 [UNKNOWN]: I can't wait.
01:31:12 --> 01:31:13 [UNKNOWN]: Ma'am, Luke.
01:31:13 --> 01:31:15 [UNKNOWN]: I love saying the Mordor names.
01:31:15 --> 01:31:17 [UNKNOWN]: Because the Orgrstames are just so fun to say.
01:31:19 --> 01:31:42 [UNKNOWN]: Can I also tell you the the voice I hear in my head when I say those is a shadow Mortor and shadow war games which are very non-cannon do not pay attention to them No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
01:31:43 --> 01:32:04 [UNKNOWN]: Orc leadership and like if you kill an orc that's in this level of the leadership they will be replaced It's somebody else will be promoted in their place and this and that it's a whole thing It's very cool and then they patented it and they never use it again And they won't let anybody else use it very mad at them for that very very very very cool stuff though But it's like a warlord system.
01:32:04 --> 01:32:10 [UNKNOWN]: I think it's called anyway, but every time one of the named orcs comes in it'll be like
01:32:10 --> 01:32:35 [UNKNOWN]: Go shot, go shot, go shot, go Everybody's like chanting and I'm always every time I say marnook, I'm thinking marnook Go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go
01:32:39 --> 01:32:55 [UNKNOWN]: uh right you know once he checks the menu he'll be uh he'll be ready to get ready to go you know looks like it looks like meets back on the menu boys and then everybody was like what's it what's a menu in middle earth anyway I thought you're trying to have a general so
01:32:57 --> 01:32:59 [UNKNOWN]: Well, okay, we didn't read the description, John, move us.
01:32:59 --> 01:33:00 [UNKNOWN]: All right, all right.
01:33:00 --> 01:33:05 [UNKNOWN]: Marnook, Marnook leads Galadriel and Orandeard into Gundabad.
01:33:06 --> 01:33:11 [UNKNOWN]: He introduces himself as a general and reveals Galadriel offering to turn her over to Saurant together.
01:33:12 --> 01:33:19 [UNKNOWN]: Mar-Nook sends around here to the torture rack, Mar-Nook intercepts them on the way, and kills the Orcs.
01:33:20 --> 01:33:24 [UNKNOWN]: My tale is found dead, and the mission is nothing but a risk now.
01:33:25 --> 01:33:28 [UNKNOWN]: Around here says that Colludryl knows all the same secrets.
01:33:28 --> 01:33:33 [UNKNOWN]: Killaborn speaks from another cell, but around here says they don't have time to save him.
01:33:33 --> 01:33:37 [UNKNOWN]: Killaborn offers more intel and promises to get them out alive if they release him.
01:33:38 --> 01:33:43 [UNKNOWN]: Kilaborne then leads them to escape, but when he learns, their unnamed companion was taken below.
01:33:43 --> 01:33:44 [UNKNOWN]: He suggests they leave her behind.
01:33:45 --> 01:33:50 [UNKNOWN]: One marnu marnu uses Galadriel's name, Kilaborne springs into action.
01:33:51 --> 01:33:55 [UNKNOWN]: Kilaborne arrives just in time to see Kiladriel complete her slaughter of her captors.
01:33:56 --> 01:33:58 [UNKNOWN]: She drops her sword and goes to him as the alarm rings.
01:33:59 --> 01:34:04 [UNKNOWN]: Their boss has arrived and Sauron brought three Naznagoul.
01:34:05 --> 01:34:08 [UNKNOWN]: He asks for Galadriel and Marnuk alive, and the rest killed.
01:34:09 --> 01:34:13 [UNKNOWN]: Saran finds my tallet, dead, and learns her neighbor was Kelliborn.
01:34:15 --> 01:34:19 [UNKNOWN]: The elves run into a naznogul and Marnuk fiend surrender.
01:34:20 --> 01:34:25 [UNKNOWN]: Taking the opportunity to free the prisoners, they lock the Naznegool in a cell and continue outside.
01:34:26 --> 01:34:36 [UNKNOWN]: Galadriel shoots a flare arrow and wakes Lundraval, prints of Eagles who slept nearby, around here in Marnuk, bar the door, to the cliff, and they stand on.
01:34:37 --> 01:34:43 [UNKNOWN]: The Elves' work, clear landing zone, and Marnuk, is killed by a Naznegool.
01:34:44 --> 01:34:49 [UNKNOWN]: The Naznegool suggests around here run with Galadriel, but when he won't,
01:34:49 --> 01:34:52 [UNKNOWN]: The Nazdergoal reveals himself to be Theo.
01:34:53 --> 01:35:01 [UNKNOWN]: Vampire on deer tells Theo to take off the ring and Theo seems on the verge of listening when Sauron arrives in orders around your killed.
01:35:02 --> 01:35:07 [UNKNOWN]: Theo obeys the order and the caliborn jumps to the eagle with Galadriel.
01:35:08 --> 01:35:11 [UNKNOWN]: Theo is ordered to leave her on deer and picks up his helm.
01:35:13 --> 01:35:33 [UNKNOWN]: big scene where we want to well David you made me laugh in the chat with your comment that this is uh... look i am your son father i am your uh... not adopted uh... girlfriend son what does that make us absolutely nothing
01:35:35 --> 01:35:37 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was, you know, it was fine.
01:35:38 --> 01:35:38 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not knocking it.
01:35:39 --> 01:35:43 [UNKNOWN]: I just thought it was funny that it was this sort of scene in a way.
01:35:44 --> 01:35:58 [UNKNOWN]: And it was again, writers, tricks, you know, writers being tricky about like not showing us who the secret, Nazna Goul was, that was being, you know, minted in the previous scene.
01:35:58 --> 01:36:03 [UNKNOWN]: So, of course we have to have the big reveal of it being Theo and all of that.
01:36:04 --> 01:36:06 [UNKNOWN]: But all good, whatever.
01:36:06 --> 01:36:24 [UNKNOWN]: And Theo now has a very difficult new memory as he is his identity is struggling between being a Nazna goal and being Theo, because he has a memory of killing a rendezier, who he realizes.
01:36:25 --> 01:36:33 [UNKNOWN]: Now, who's only ever really thinking about trying to be the best sort of stepdad that around here can be given the circumstances?
01:36:33 --> 01:36:41 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it did also, you know, we mentioned Star Wars before it did give me very much Ben Solo and Hans Solo and that whole scene.
01:36:41 --> 01:36:43 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, yeah, I didn't even think about that, you know.
01:36:43 --> 01:36:45 [UNKNOWN]: I put those memories, those movie out of my memories.
01:36:45 --> 01:36:49 [UNKNOWN]: But the idea of use, I don't think that was a bad part of that movie.
01:36:49 --> 01:36:59 [UNKNOWN]: No, no, I think it was actually a pretty good character moment of using a betrayal of it's it's sort of giving yourself a moral injury, right?
01:36:59 --> 01:37:06 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, it's it's morally injuring yourself by betraying your entire identity to forge yourself a new in evil.
01:37:07 --> 01:37:12 [UNKNOWN]: And that's what Ben Solo kind of horrendous and it's also what Vio does here.
01:37:13 --> 01:37:13 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:37:20 --> 01:37:24 [UNKNOWN]: the in the idea of of us having to separate from our parents.
01:37:25 --> 01:37:29 [UNKNOWN]: I think Marilyn, you were looking to say something a minute ago.
01:37:30 --> 01:37:34 [UNKNOWN]: I think new minority and resource colonization has a lot to answer for.
01:37:36 --> 01:37:37 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, right.
01:37:38 --> 01:37:40 [UNKNOWN]: This outcome absolutely broke my heart.
01:37:41 --> 01:37:46 [UNKNOWN]: But I do appreciate a comment shared by a reader, which we'll be reading below.
01:37:53 --> 01:38:03 [UNKNOWN]: and watching the deterioration and Saturn's just awful, awful, hammering on him.
01:38:05 --> 01:38:10 [UNKNOWN]: And I keep thinking of Pranwan's advice to her son, find the light and the shadow will not find you.
01:38:11 --> 01:38:20 [UNKNOWN]: So, Theo has really lost light in the last five years, and thanks that he has a solution
01:38:22 --> 01:38:24 [UNKNOWN]: his anger and suddenly finds out.
01:38:25 --> 01:38:35 [UNKNOWN]: A little bit about who and what he truly is when he said, I knew the minute that Nazgonell said, you guys should run now.
01:38:36 --> 01:38:37 [UNKNOWN]: I said.
01:38:38 --> 01:38:43 [UNKNOWN]: Oh God, it's Theo, which I really had hoped they would go that way.
01:38:44 --> 01:38:45 [UNKNOWN]: And they did.
01:38:45 --> 01:38:46 [UNKNOWN]: He's in his dad's oversized suit, right?
01:38:47 --> 01:38:53 [UNKNOWN]: It really, I think your right David, it was intentional to make him look like he was in over his head here.
01:38:54 --> 01:38:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, in the big little little body and a big outfit.
01:38:57 --> 01:38:57 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:38:57 --> 01:38:58 [UNKNOWN]: Absolutely wasn't.
01:38:58 --> 01:39:00 [UNKNOWN]: And that was conveyed very clearly.
01:39:07 --> 01:39:12 [UNKNOWN]: quote unquote, fatherly voice of love and the fatherly voice of command.
01:39:14 --> 01:39:18 [UNKNOWN]: And it is the command that is, you know, knee jerk reaction.
01:39:20 --> 01:39:22 [UNKNOWN]: And how much of that, well, it's clearly its power over.
01:39:23 --> 01:39:24 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, from south on.
01:39:25 --> 01:39:30 [UNKNOWN]: And that kind of violation is just gas.
01:39:30 --> 01:39:32 [UNKNOWN]: It's just absolutely horrible.
01:39:33 --> 01:39:44 [UNKNOWN]: But I was also really horrified by what we were talking about earlier, bridging of another underrepresented person in terms of the actor.
01:39:45 --> 01:39:47 [UNKNOWN]: But there's some nice feedback to that.
01:39:47 --> 01:39:48 [UNKNOWN]: Help me feel better about that.
01:39:50 --> 01:40:00 [UNKNOWN]: Also, from a comment that's been made in a couple places, I'm kind of worried about that dangling thread that is night delay, because Souton is an excrementcer.
01:40:01 --> 01:40:06 [UNKNOWN]: Oh yeah, yeah, yeah and I think that could be the only reason why we spent so much time on her dead body.
01:40:07 --> 01:40:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:40:08 --> 01:40:09 [UNKNOWN]: And it was left in the cell.
01:40:09 --> 01:40:10 [UNKNOWN]: Well, why was it left in the cell?
01:40:11 --> 01:40:12 [UNKNOWN]: Did that works there?
01:40:12 --> 01:40:13 [UNKNOWN]: No.
01:40:13 --> 01:40:17 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, there's some good potential here and we're going to hang onto this body.
01:40:17 --> 01:40:19 [UNKNOWN]: Shout out to Peter O'H.
01:40:19 --> 01:40:21 [UNKNOWN]: and the discord who had this very same thought.
01:40:21 --> 01:40:24 [UNKNOWN]: I think earlier he was one of the first persons to post the thought anyway.
01:40:24 --> 01:40:25 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah.
01:40:27 --> 01:40:40 [UNKNOWN]: But it was also nice, well, the other thing is, I am really worried that this is going to be taking myself on an opportunity to train Theo in that dark art.
01:40:41 --> 01:40:51 [UNKNOWN]: Now I have a whole bunch of stuff lore about the name, I can't remember the exact name now, but the names that Theo's posthead father.
01:40:53 --> 01:40:58 [UNKNOWN]: And the artificiality of it all, but I think it has to be a whole lore episode because it gets convoluted.
01:40:58 --> 01:41:20 [UNKNOWN]: There's no time for it here now But it was nice to see that Galadriel has a Partner elf who equals her still in fighting and it's gaping and Wow, are they gonna have a lot to catch up on I mean now we have two couples we have we have a Disa in Dordin and we have Galadriel and California and then
01:41:21 --> 01:41:26 [UNKNOWN]: How has this endless war affected them as a couple?
01:41:27 --> 01:41:32 [UNKNOWN]: How has this evil presence mean first it was Mordloff and now it's so wrong?
01:41:33 --> 01:41:41 [UNKNOWN]: How is that going to impact them and their relationship and I mean they've been a part for a thousand years?
01:41:42 --> 01:41:47 [UNKNOWN]: or maybe not quite that one, but according to their story, I mean, the story that they're telling us.
01:41:47 --> 01:41:53 [UNKNOWN]: And again, this is another canvas that they're painting on fairly creatively.
01:41:54 --> 01:42:00 [UNKNOWN]: And it's important to say that Tolkien painted fairly frequently on the same canvas.
01:42:00 --> 01:42:03 [UNKNOWN]: And again, that's me another lore episode that we will eventually pick up.
01:42:04 --> 01:42:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I wanted to say to like, I love and you know, there were things I mentioned already that I did not love about this whole sequence of, you know, the caliber and like I did not like the caliber was willing to leave people behind and that our on dear was willing to leave people behind either I think both of them kind of
01:42:21 --> 01:42:48 [UNKNOWN]: That's how they're both like dudes like recounting his military history I served under these great general and you would know the these big names and I know the way like why are you just freeing a fellow Oh for guys I thought that was totally out of care that said I did love that when they went to go save Galadriel God rolled me to don't saving Galadriel and all many you know I thought that was fantastic
01:42:49 --> 01:42:56 [UNKNOWN]: And they did the little video the visual thing of her dancing back and forth to mirror how he first saw her dancing in the forest.
01:42:57 --> 01:42:58 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, that was for Handle.
01:42:59 --> 01:43:04 [UNKNOWN]: And the NASGALS made a really good comment too, which is, she drops her sword.
01:43:05 --> 01:43:13 [UNKNOWN]: Gladriel is in the heart of an orch stronghold, and she is a consummate warrior.
01:43:15 --> 01:43:19 [UNKNOWN]: And so, for her to drop her sword, that's a BFD.
01:43:19 --> 01:43:20 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:43:20 --> 01:43:28 [UNKNOWN]: She is so taken by not having, not having seen this man for so long.
01:43:29 --> 01:43:32 [UNKNOWN]: And she feels so safe and so vulnerable and connect.
01:43:32 --> 01:43:34 [UNKNOWN]: She can feel, she can let go of her.
01:43:36 --> 01:43:39 [UNKNOWN]: that the warrior side of her for a moment.
01:43:39 --> 01:43:41 [UNKNOWN]: I also think it was even more than that.
01:43:42 --> 01:43:45 [UNKNOWN]: It was just simple sheer shock.
01:43:45 --> 01:43:47 [UNKNOWN]: And her hands, her hands just went.
01:43:47 --> 01:43:52 [UNKNOWN]: You know, but I'm, I, I would counter that and saying she wouldn't do that because she's a warrior.
01:43:53 --> 01:43:59 [UNKNOWN]: I understand you're saying I think at the same time, I read it as that's how shock she was.
01:43:59 --> 01:44:00 [UNKNOWN]: Sure.
01:44:00 --> 01:44:03 [UNKNOWN]: And in that moment of shock, you just go,
01:44:05 --> 01:44:06 [UNKNOWN]: And yeah, I'm saying her warrior.
01:44:06 --> 01:44:16 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, we're we're besides at the same coin, but I also think that you know, there was this really long silence, and I think I interpreted that as Osadmay.
01:44:18 --> 01:44:19 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, right, right.
01:44:19 --> 01:44:23 [UNKNOWN]: They were communicating with each other in that moment, but they just weren't verbalizing it.
01:44:24 --> 01:44:24 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:44:24 --> 01:44:26 [UNKNOWN]: So that everybody could hear it.
01:44:26 --> 01:44:33 [UNKNOWN]: But then she can, that they could have that moment of connection of like, good God, like of all places that we run into each other.
01:44:33 --> 01:44:34 [UNKNOWN]: It's here.
01:44:34 --> 01:44:41 [UNKNOWN]: So never mind the stupidity of the scene of like, maybe you know my wife, never mind.
01:44:41 --> 01:44:42 [UNKNOWN]: We gotta run off with a very deep.
01:44:43 --> 01:44:43 [UNKNOWN]: That was just very dumb.
01:44:44 --> 01:44:44 [UNKNOWN]: I don't want to go through it.
01:44:44 --> 01:44:46 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was clunky.
01:44:46 --> 01:44:56 [UNKNOWN]: It was, what bothered me more was to noble elves being completely willing to leave their kindred behind.
01:44:56 --> 01:45:02 [UNKNOWN]: I just think it was completely out of left field just to make our comedy a bit work.
01:45:02 --> 01:45:12 [UNKNOWN]: I saw this as showing just how much California suffered in the last 1000 years.
01:45:12 --> 01:45:13 [UNKNOWN]: It was not a good look.
01:45:14 --> 01:45:15 [UNKNOWN]: absolutely.
01:45:15 --> 01:45:16 [UNKNOWN]: He knew it that way.
01:45:16 --> 01:45:21 [UNKNOWN]: He knew this place inside and out and it must have been absolutely filthy knowledge to have a clogged mind with.
01:45:22 --> 01:45:29 [UNKNOWN]: But he knew he knew that without additional help there was no way in the world they could free anybody else.
01:45:29 --> 01:45:30 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
01:45:30 --> 01:45:31 [UNKNOWN]: The distances were too long.
01:45:31 --> 01:45:32 [UNKNOWN]: There were too many people.
01:45:33 --> 01:45:36 [UNKNOWN]: No, I can understand why that was his decision.
01:45:37 --> 01:45:42 [UNKNOWN]: Now, I'm not going to let it finish for a rendezvous to make the same decision
01:45:45 --> 01:45:46 [UNKNOWN]: That was a little harder.
01:45:47 --> 01:45:48 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, we're not right there, right?
01:45:48 --> 01:45:50 [UNKNOWN]: When you're right there, he's there.
01:45:50 --> 01:45:51 [UNKNOWN]: Clearly he knows what's right.
01:45:52 --> 01:45:56 [UNKNOWN]: Now, perhaps he thinks, all right, he's, you know, he's pitching me a line.
01:45:57 --> 01:46:11 [UNKNOWN]: At the same time, how much would he have heard about Kelliborne as a servant elf in the forest, subordinate three or four ranks down, remember how almost reverent he was when he first encountered Galadriel.
01:46:12 --> 01:46:17 [UNKNOWN]: She's heard of her, but she is so far above him, she's a legend.
01:46:18 --> 01:46:18 [UNKNOWN]: She's incredible.
01:46:19 --> 01:46:24 [UNKNOWN]: So, Galiborn just goes back so very far, and he's completely dropped out.
01:46:24 --> 01:46:30 [UNKNOWN]: And even Tolkien doesn't know who his parents are, you know, like, he could even decide that.
01:46:30 --> 01:46:36 [UNKNOWN]: So he could have made the calculation, you know, this guy could be trying to sell me a good line just to get out.
01:46:36 --> 01:46:39 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, but then why not just let him out because he's an elf.
01:46:39 --> 01:46:53 [UNKNOWN]: He's an ally like you know, what are you doing you hope if he's been there a long time You might have been turned Yeah, it happened before it was a big deal Won't got turned a lot of elves and they were rejected from their cultures because oh, all right.
01:46:53 --> 01:46:59 [UNKNOWN]: Well, that I didn't know that I didn't yeah Family no longer trusted them Interesting, okay
01:47:06 --> 01:47:09 [UNKNOWN]: Long ago in a galaxy far far away.
01:47:09 --> 01:47:12 [UNKNOWN]: That was actually one of my theories of what Edara was.
01:47:12 --> 01:47:15 [UNKNOWN]: It was an elf that had rejected Burma's kingdom.
01:47:15 --> 01:47:17 [UNKNOWN]: And therefore made his home among the orcs.
01:47:18 --> 01:47:19 [UNKNOWN]: That I do remember.
01:47:20 --> 01:47:21 [UNKNOWN]: I actually think that would have been...
01:47:210 --> 01:47:24 [UNKNOWN]: It's close, but I kind of wish they had gone all the way with that.
01:47:25 --> 01:47:28 [UNKNOWN]: You know, it did not feel like an uru to me.
01:47:29 --> 01:47:29 [UNKNOWN]: You know?
01:47:30 --> 01:47:31 [UNKNOWN]: Well, I don't think it was meant to.
01:47:32 --> 01:47:33 [UNKNOWN]: I think he was meant to.
01:47:36 --> 01:47:38 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he'll always be making one of my heart.
01:47:39 --> 01:47:42 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, this is a big room.
01:47:42 --> 01:47:44 [UNKNOWN]: Your heart's as big as your feet jump.
01:47:46 --> 01:47:48 [UNKNOWN]: And it's stomping all over these theories.
01:47:51 --> 01:48:15 [UNKNOWN]: uh... marnook using fire to drive back the ring bear that seems like the they're establishing the lower of the ring bear's uh... being afraid of fire uh... and i did like marnook that was a really clever point we can't go toe to toe with this guy so we've got to be smarter and we lock him in a cage like that's good writing that was clever
01:48:15 --> 01:48:21 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that was showing the characters doing the things that they're supposed to, you know, being themselves in that way.
01:48:21 --> 01:48:26 [UNKNOWN]: So questions for you both were you surprised that Martin looked turned out to be a good Diane the end?
01:48:27 --> 01:48:29 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, they had me backwards and forwards and upside down.
01:48:29 --> 01:48:31 [UNKNOWN]: I didn't know what things were up by the time.
01:48:31 --> 01:48:35 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's pretty much, that's pretty much what I was at David, what about you, John?
01:48:36 --> 01:48:53 [UNKNOWN]: I have a hard time kind of following these writers to any, and so I don't, I don't trust them enough to take their clues seriously, and therefore I was, I was just like, I was writing the wave.
01:48:53 --> 01:48:53 [UNKNOWN]: You know what I mean?
01:48:53 --> 01:48:55 [UNKNOWN]: I was like, I don't know.
01:48:55 --> 01:48:56 [UNKNOWN]: We'll see what he is at the end.
01:48:56 --> 01:48:58 [UNKNOWN]: I'm not going to, I'm not going to fuss over it.
01:48:59 --> 01:48:59 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:49:00 --> 01:49:00 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:49:00 --> 01:49:05 [UNKNOWN]: I decided I wasn't going to try to decide whether the other just see what I'm rolled.
01:49:06 --> 01:49:11 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I would surprise though that they decided to take him out at the end of this episode.
01:49:12 --> 01:49:16 [UNKNOWN]: Well, at least one person on the discord seemed to think maybe they didn't.
01:49:17 --> 01:49:19 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know why, I didn't see any evidence.
01:49:20 --> 01:49:22 [UNKNOWN]: I only watched it once, so, you know, I don't know.
01:49:22 --> 01:49:28 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was like he got stabbed and he went down, but then we didn't actually see sort of what went on.
01:49:28 --> 01:49:41 [UNKNOWN]: And I mean, if Keirden and Gil Gallard are to be believed as they peer into their rings, you know, maybe Marnook is gonna have a little bit more to say about this story than,
01:49:42 --> 01:49:48 [UNKNOWN]: then just in and here they peer to their rigs and just see him wolf and now butterflies
01:49:56 --> 01:50:05 [UNKNOWN]: How did they get the eagle there?
01:50:05 --> 01:50:09 [UNKNOWN]: Do you think one of the butterflies was the real butterfly sent off to contact Madway?
01:50:09 --> 01:50:10 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know.
01:50:10 --> 01:50:12 [UNKNOWN]: I'm being pretty generous with that take, but
01:50:20 --> 01:50:26 [UNKNOWN]: Another Lord of the Rings call back is, is Landroval canonical?
01:50:26 --> 01:50:28 [UNKNOWN]: Oh yeah, he appears to pop it.
01:50:29 --> 01:50:29 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:50:29 --> 01:50:30 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
01:50:31 --> 01:50:31 [UNKNOWN]: Got it.
01:50:33 --> 01:50:42 [UNKNOWN]: Um, so globally, there are 68 species of recognized, uh, I, I looked up the pronunciation of a sit, it's, oh, I can't do it now.
01:50:43 --> 01:50:45 [UNKNOWN]: The family of Eagle family names,
01:50:50 --> 01:50:54 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, the thing that makes eagles deal a little bit different is their massive size.
01:50:54 --> 01:50:59 [UNKNOWN]: I've got a much heavier build, much heavier head and beak.
01:51:00 --> 01:51:05 [UNKNOWN]: Very powerful feet and actually the ability to hunt large vertebit prey.
01:51:06 --> 01:51:14 [UNKNOWN]: So deer, things in fish, it's very powerful, which makes them different from like hawks and carriers and falcons and things like that.
01:51:16 --> 01:51:20 [UNKNOWN]: I looks like land revolve appears to be mostly a golden eagle.
01:51:23 --> 01:51:36 [UNKNOWN]: And he is a booted eagle, which is a type of eagle, a lot of eagles that have feathers all the way down to their feet, which are adapted for different things.
01:51:36 --> 01:51:46 [UNKNOWN]: A lot of warmer drier climates and eagles that eat snakes and lizards and stuff like that don't have feathers that go all the way down their shins.
01:51:52 --> 01:52:11 [UNKNOWN]: I froze the frame and I looked in the app, sure enough, he's a booted eagle, I could see his booties, but he seems to be also have some elements of a stellar sea eagle in terms of the head and the beak and stuff like that, but then the hast eagle, which is an extinct species from New Zealand.
01:52:12 --> 01:52:30 [UNKNOWN]: is the largest of the Eagles, and we went out of it, it went into extinction around the times the Mallory arrived, and the Mallory were hunted down the Moa bird, which is a large flightless bird in the Micton, New Zealand, and that was the Eagles' principal prey.
01:52:31 --> 01:52:34 [UNKNOWN]: So as the Moa birds were no longer available.
01:52:34 --> 01:52:37 [UNKNOWN]: So something I want to say about Altairro and the Mallory
01:52:40 --> 01:52:45 [UNKNOWN]: prior to the Maori migration, there had been no humans on the island.
01:52:45 --> 01:52:56 [UNKNOWN]: And this was one of the reasons why such large species developed and why so many flightless bird species developed, because there were no large mammal predators.
01:52:57 --> 01:53:00 [UNKNOWN]: You do have, as you said, the eagles and bird birds and things, but
01:53:01 --> 01:53:07 [UNKNOWN]: Um, so you have these massive hamster light creatures and so on, and right no terrestrial, uh, predators.
01:53:07 --> 01:53:14 [UNKNOWN]: No natural, large, no mezzo or or mega, and the melody also had rats come in with him too.
01:53:14 --> 01:53:18 [UNKNOWN]: I believe I don't think that was the English, you're normally a just the English from there.
01:53:18 --> 01:53:22 [UNKNOWN]: Right, but uh, in that case, or maybe it was a doubt when they were English.
01:53:22 --> 01:53:24 [UNKNOWN]: They obviously brought dogs.
01:53:24 --> 01:53:28 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, um, obviously I'm not, I mean, exactly detailed, but.
01:53:29 --> 01:53:38 [UNKNOWN]: I did want to have read Icedize feedback which helped me a lot with the death of the rendezvous.
01:53:38 --> 01:53:48 [UNKNOWN]: So Icedize says, I've read enough cruise quota of interviews to know, sorry, I'm going to start that again.
01:53:49 --> 01:53:52 [UNKNOWN]: I've read enough cruise quota of interviews now to feel a little calmer.
01:53:53 --> 01:53:57 [UNKNOWN]: This helped, and this sources WIC, I don't know what that is, sorry.
01:53:59 --> 01:54:04 [UNKNOWN]: Cordova told TV Insider he learned of his character's fate a few months before filming.
01:54:05 --> 01:54:13 [UNKNOWN]: He believed that there was an element of choice in Iran's death, because the elf refused to abandon Theo even when he had the chance to walk away.
01:54:15 --> 01:54:17 [UNKNOWN]: I have such a Tolkien ending, he said.
01:54:18 --> 01:54:19 [UNKNOWN]: He's not wrong.
01:54:20 --> 01:54:23 [UNKNOWN]: A Rondaier dies trying to pull the aback from the ring's grip.
01:54:24 --> 01:54:29 [UNKNOWN]: It's the same instinct for pity and second chances that drives Frodo, Bilble, and Gandalf and Lord of the Rings.
01:54:30 --> 01:54:35 [UNKNOWN]: She also mentioned that Rondaier died the way he lived, and that there was comfort in that.
01:54:35 --> 01:54:40 [UNKNOWN]: And apparently that's something that Rosie from Nuskel said, but I haven't heard of this.
01:54:41 --> 01:54:46 [UNKNOWN]: Then she goes on south, and doesn't know about the dagger with its golden silver valinora.
01:54:47 --> 01:54:49 [UNKNOWN]: that was used to make the three rings for elves.
01:54:49 --> 01:54:53 [UNKNOWN]: And I don't think he really understands the level of sacrifice required.
01:54:54 --> 01:54:56 [UNKNOWN]: It wasn't just a dagger, a lot that'll gave up.
01:54:56 --> 01:55:01 [UNKNOWN]: It was her last direct tie to her brother, Finn Rod, and representative of her quest for vengeance.
01:55:05 --> 01:55:12 [UNKNOWN]: So what, say more about how this was a comforting insight for you?
01:55:15 --> 01:55:36 [UNKNOWN]: simply he had more agency in his death got it okay that I first had seen rather than just a shock moment of his adopted son right shanking him right not unlike a audience having agency in the murder death and saying you know this is this is only option be able to
01:55:38 --> 01:55:48 [UNKNOWN]: I think you could say that over under felt the same way, I left you before, I have decided I'm not going to do that again if that means I die so be it.
01:55:49 --> 01:56:00 [UNKNOWN]: And hoping perhaps, I mean, ultimately, it didn't matter whether or not to his decision, but perhaps he thought that might lend strength to his pleading to take off the ring.
01:56:00 --> 01:56:02 [UNKNOWN]: And you could see it's happening.
01:56:02 --> 01:56:07 [UNKNOWN]: And then of course, Salarun comes in at the most in opportunity moment, and that was
01:56:09 --> 01:56:10 [UNKNOWN]: opportune by the writer's.
01:56:12 --> 01:56:14 [UNKNOWN]: Well, opportune for sound.
01:56:14 --> 01:56:15 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, exactly.
01:56:17 --> 01:56:17 [UNKNOWN]: Who's he?
01:56:17 --> 01:56:19 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's all point of view on that.
01:56:19 --> 01:56:22 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's fair.
01:56:23 --> 01:56:23 [UNKNOWN]: That's fair.
01:56:23 --> 01:56:28 [UNKNOWN]: That that he was in.
01:56:30 --> 01:56:37 [UNKNOWN]: There was a ongoing relationship here between Theo and Iran dear and it was in just shock value moments
01:56:39 --> 01:56:45 [UNKNOWN]: And I have to say like again, you know, Darth Vader and his little minions, he just walks by and goes kill him.
01:56:45 --> 01:56:53 [UNKNOWN]: And, you know, just instantly, there is no, has it, that's the power of Sauron as I was through these rings.
01:56:53 --> 01:56:54 [UNKNOWN]: There was no hesitation.
01:56:54 --> 01:56:55 [UNKNOWN]: He drew a short step.
01:56:56 --> 01:56:58 [UNKNOWN]: They flashed over the ring when he set it to.
01:56:58 --> 01:57:00 [UNKNOWN]: They were clearly signaling, like the ring is compelling him here.
01:57:00 --> 01:57:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I guess they did.
01:57:02 --> 01:57:08 [UNKNOWN]: Um, well, his choice was accepting the ring, but now that he's made that choice, he's stuck in this for all of them.
01:57:09 --> 01:57:13 [UNKNOWN]: Um, I, I do like this take that Cruz Cordova had.
01:57:15 --> 01:57:26 [UNKNOWN]: My, you know, I first learned of, since this is his funeral, I'll say, I first learned of this actor on Sesame Street when my kids were small, he was Mando on Sesame Street.
01:57:27 --> 01:57:28 [UNKNOWN]: And he, he was really cool.
01:57:28 --> 01:57:29 [UNKNOWN]: So, yeah.
01:57:29 --> 01:57:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:57:30 --> 01:57:32 [UNKNOWN]: But yeah, no, that is a very cool.
01:57:32 --> 01:57:33 [UNKNOWN]: I think you're absolutely right.
01:57:33 --> 01:57:42 [UNKNOWN]: And don't you worry about around you, the character, because he is currently sipping margaritas on the coast of Malah or talking to Finn Rod going, can you believe what your sister did?
01:57:42 --> 01:57:51 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I can see that I can see that yeah, that's very funny He's having a great time.
01:57:51 --> 01:57:54 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he's having a much better time that he wasn't good to bad.
01:57:55 --> 01:58:04 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, I'm questionably Hopefully Cruz Cardova had a good time and And hopefully we'll see more of him on screen in future.
01:58:05 --> 01:58:05 [UNKNOWN]: Yep
01:58:07 --> 01:58:20 [UNKNOWN]: He's got it going on, so, and yeah, it was nice to have a different elf, like a, you know, to have a silver elf, is that right?
01:58:20 --> 01:58:29 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, we haven't really seen them much in, yeah, yeah, it was cool, like he didn't give him it, you know, he adopted a different fighting style than the other ones, and you know, obviously
01:58:36 --> 01:58:46 [UNKNOWN]: So they were able to take, he was able to take that and say, okay, this different group of elves over here, this is how we kind of operate and this was, yeah, that was cool.
01:58:46 --> 01:58:51 [UNKNOWN]: I like that that creative, the creative work that went into creating the difference.
01:58:51 --> 01:58:54 [UNKNOWN]: And he was able to love a human woman.
01:58:55 --> 01:59:02 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, big band, a human, Jan, child who was not his biological offspring,
01:59:03 --> 01:59:04 [UNKNOWN]: big deal, right?
01:59:05 --> 01:59:06 [UNKNOWN]: He is a human man child.
01:59:10 --> 01:59:14 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, well, who knows when that line probably gets crossed from child to man.
01:59:15 --> 01:59:17 [UNKNOWN]: I think there's a lot of backing in for things for a while there.
01:59:18 --> 01:59:20 [UNKNOWN]: Whatever line that is, the U.S. straddle enough.
01:59:24 --> 01:59:30 [UNKNOWN]: All right, so why don't we get to feedback for the overall episode we have, um, I think, I think we've, oh, hard going to bad.
01:59:31 --> 01:59:48 [UNKNOWN]: Sorry, just really quickly, the, in the visual storytelling of going to bad, to show us how big going to bad really is, we get those wide, long shots as they're walking in and they're, they're walking on this huge thing.
01:59:48 --> 01:59:50 [UNKNOWN]: And then when they walk into that narrow,
01:59:52 --> 01:59:58 [UNKNOWN]: It's just really funny, but it was just a really great, like, oh, this place is huge.
01:59:58 --> 01:59:59 [UNKNOWN]: And how do we do that?
01:59:59 --> 02:00:00 [UNKNOWN]: We show you scale.
02:00:00 --> 02:00:02 [UNKNOWN]: And so we make the people a little small.
02:00:02 --> 02:00:04 [UNKNOWN]: And why is the doorway narrow and small?
02:00:05 --> 02:00:06 [UNKNOWN]: Because this was the birthplace of the dwarves.
02:00:06 --> 02:00:09 [UNKNOWN]: This was where during the deathless awoke.
02:00:10 --> 02:00:10 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
02:00:10 --> 02:00:11 [UNKNOWN]: Oh, really?
02:00:11 --> 02:00:11 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:00:11 --> 02:00:12 [UNKNOWN]: Did you talk about that before?
02:00:12 --> 02:00:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
02:00:12 --> 02:00:13 [UNKNOWN]: I believe we mentioned it.
02:00:13 --> 02:00:14 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:00:14 --> 02:00:15 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:00:15 --> 02:00:19 [UNKNOWN]: This is basically the source of the door was prior to being invaded by the forces of Sarah or more.
02:00:19 --> 02:00:21 [UNKNOWN]: I've met a bit of the force of Markoth first.
02:00:21 --> 02:00:22 [UNKNOWN]: I don't remember.
02:00:22 --> 02:00:23 [UNKNOWN]: Interesting.
02:00:23 --> 02:00:24 [UNKNOWN]: Probably more to Gotha.
02:00:24 --> 02:00:24 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:00:24 --> 02:00:25 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:00:25 --> 02:00:27 [UNKNOWN]: If it was the birthplace of the first.
02:00:28 --> 02:00:34 [UNKNOWN]: I also, I really tracked on that scale when the two of them left off them out and never.
02:00:35 --> 02:00:37 [UNKNOWN]: And were captured by the eagle.
02:00:38 --> 02:00:45 [UNKNOWN]: And that was a cool, that was a very Millennium Falcon hiding on the back of the Star Destroyer scene.
02:00:46 --> 02:00:51 [UNKNOWN]: But it was in Land of All, really, that was good move.
02:00:51 --> 02:00:52 [UNKNOWN]: It's like, hey, I'm getting shot here.
02:00:52 --> 02:00:55 [UNKNOWN]: I'm going to go like, clear the zone for a minute.
02:00:56 --> 02:01:00 [UNKNOWN]: And, yeah, props to Land of All, man.
02:01:00 --> 02:01:03 [UNKNOWN]: Is that why an Ariana was saying, I got to go get some power converters.
02:01:07 --> 02:01:08 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
02:01:09 --> 02:01:18 [UNKNOWN]: So, yeah, it was a good, it was a good, it was a good, fighting, good chase, good tricking of the ring, ring, ring, ring bearer thing, good escape.
02:01:19 --> 02:01:19 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it worked.
02:01:19 --> 02:01:31 [UNKNOWN]: It, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it, it
02:01:31 --> 02:01:35 [UNKNOWN]: Did he, did he have, can you communicate with Eagles that way through the, yes, yeah, the Eagles.
02:01:36 --> 02:01:37 [UNKNOWN]: They're not like Eagle Eagles.
02:01:37 --> 02:01:40 [UNKNOWN]: They are, like, merrily correct me from wrong, but they are some level of iron ore.
02:01:40 --> 02:01:58 [UNKNOWN]: They are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are, they are,
02:01:59 --> 02:02:13 [UNKNOWN]: Well, cool ending scene and loved the whole thing of Sarah and walking off and just sort of being really pissed off and Theo looking like a very small little child, big piece of armor.
02:02:13 --> 02:02:15 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, move on to the feedback.
02:02:15 --> 02:02:16 [UNKNOWN]: Let's get the feedback.
02:02:16 --> 02:02:17 [UNKNOWN]: Who wants to read Jennifer M?
02:02:19 --> 02:02:24 [UNKNOWN]: I will read Jennifer M, wrote in a very, thank you Jennifer M. Have we heard from Jennifer M before?
02:02:29 --> 02:02:30 [UNKNOWN]: Dr. Sarah Brown's classes.
02:02:31 --> 02:02:32 [UNKNOWN]: She and I are often in the same classes.
02:02:32 --> 02:02:34 [UNKNOWN]: They're the same sections together.
02:02:34 --> 02:02:36 [UNKNOWN]: And I choose a lovely, lovely person.
02:02:37 --> 02:02:39 [UNKNOWN]: Well, Jennifer, so glad to have you here.
02:02:39 --> 02:02:41 [UNKNOWN]: Friend of Sarah's friend of ours.
02:02:42 --> 02:02:44 [UNKNOWN]: So, thank you for writing in.
02:02:44 --> 02:02:46 [UNKNOWN]: And a nice, long email.
02:02:46 --> 02:02:48 [UNKNOWN]: We may have to stop a couple of points along the way.
02:02:48 --> 02:02:50 [UNKNOWN]: Hello, Laura, how's great podcast?
02:02:50 --> 02:02:54 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks so much for the delightful and insightful episode coverage that isn't rushed.
02:02:54 --> 02:03:01 [UNKNOWN]: What if a rendez-a was meant to show the capacity for pity and love that Samwise could not?
02:03:01 --> 02:03:05 [UNKNOWN]: Does that make him the member Mary, member Barry in the Granola, more tasty?
02:03:06 --> 02:03:22 [UNKNOWN]: Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
02:03:26 --> 02:03:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm a glutton for internet points.
02:03:28 --> 02:03:32 [UNKNOWN]: Your driveway is full, the dump truck filled up your driveway with it.
02:03:32 --> 02:03:38 [UNKNOWN]: If you feed me more internet points, I am going to be a harkin' in.
02:03:39 --> 02:03:42 [UNKNOWN]: And Jennifer, you deserve your own internet points.
02:03:42 --> 02:03:45 [UNKNOWN]: I will take none of them because they are yours.
02:03:46 --> 02:03:50 [UNKNOWN]: This is responding to your first three podcasts and looking forward to the fourth.
02:03:51 --> 02:04:06 [UNKNOWN]: I loved what they did with the eagle, the production and art direction values are outstanding and in my mind, if Gandalf can call on the eagle's regularly, Galadriel can call in a favor once or twice, so I chalk this up to the rule of cool.
02:04:07 --> 02:04:14 [UNKNOWN]: The throwaway line that the felbe used to be eagle's made me very sad, particularly once we saw a magnificent eagle.
02:04:15 --> 02:04:17 [UNKNOWN]: That could be why they went that direction anyway.
02:04:17 --> 02:04:18 [UNKNOWN]: I think so.
02:04:18 --> 02:04:18 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:04:19 --> 02:04:19 [UNKNOWN]: Cheap.
02:04:19 --> 02:04:20 [UNKNOWN]: I say cheap.
02:04:21 --> 02:04:35 [UNKNOWN]: I very much appreciated the showrunners Loki, the humor, uh, Loki, the humor with a rendezvous in Kelliborn, that he'll turn down the stair was perfect and the meta in, uh, was perfect and meta influence.
02:04:35 --> 02:04:42 [UNKNOWN]: It was ironic to me that Chris Gordova as a rendezvous character will die was allowed to dismiss
02:04:48 --> 02:04:52 [UNKNOWN]: So I don't know, I don't really know James Kimmelbauer as he's like a hotty.
02:04:53 --> 02:04:53 [UNKNOWN]: Jamie Kimmelbauer.
02:04:54 --> 02:04:56 [UNKNOWN]: He was he was he's coming up.
02:04:56 --> 02:04:59 [UNKNOWN]: He's like he's hotter lately.
02:04:59 --> 02:04:59 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:05:00 --> 02:05:03 [UNKNOWN]: He's not the new James Bond though in both the new James Bond.
02:05:03 --> 02:05:04 [UNKNOWN]: That's Robert Pattinson, I guy.
02:05:05 --> 02:05:19 [UNKNOWN]: my guys he's ready the twilight generation has been victorious oh if you know the rise of twilight he's Batman he's James Bond he's gonna be probably doctor who next ooh that would be exciting wouldn't it?
02:05:19 --> 02:05:22 [UNKNOWN]: actually I don't think he'd be a good doctor I don't think so either John
02:05:24 --> 02:05:30 [UNKNOWN]: Anyway, I will say that, okay, we all knew that maybe you know my wife, Dr.
02:05:30 --> 02:05:32 [UNKNOWN]: Dot, and then he goes up the stairs.
02:05:33 --> 02:05:36 [UNKNOWN]: Glad you're all white?
02:05:36 --> 02:05:37 [UNKNOWN]: That was funny.
02:05:37 --> 02:05:38 [UNKNOWN]: I enjoyed that much.
02:05:38 --> 02:05:42 [UNKNOWN]: It was funny, I just thought it was like totally just completely disjong.
02:05:42 --> 02:05:43 [UNKNOWN]: Sure, sure, fair enough.
02:05:45 --> 02:05:51 [UNKNOWN]: Continuing on for super secret discussion, we'll around here get a second pro.
02:05:52 --> 02:06:21 [UNKNOWN]: living in the sad reality of knowing too much about how big corporations run i imagine some salaries had to be cut to a forward jamey camel power ooh that's a cynical take dang i don't think the salaries are the biggest expense here i'll be honest like you look at that mountain side the salaries aren't what's eaten the budget and the total kinestate is a certainly probably taking a healthy chunk of that to yeah uh... but that's an interesting thing will he get another pro uh
02:06:23 --> 02:06:30 [UNKNOWN]: And what we, this came up somewhere else the fria, is it fri, what's the spirit in the body?
02:06:30 --> 02:06:31 [UNKNOWN]: Fia.
02:06:31 --> 02:06:32 [UNKNOWN]: Fia, that's it.
02:06:32 --> 02:06:32 [UNKNOWN]: That's it.
02:06:33 --> 02:06:34 [UNKNOWN]: Fia and Roa.
02:06:35 --> 02:06:39 [UNKNOWN]: I mean, I'll be honest, I, I would be shocked if this show isn't losing a ton of money.
02:06:39 --> 02:06:48 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, I don't I think it's a huge, huge spend for Amazon now Amazon is a weird company.
02:06:48 --> 02:07:01 [UNKNOWN]: They're not just a media company part of it is like we have the prestige of Tolkien on our platform sign up and it's it's not white the same calculation is like if CBS did a little in series Yeah, absolutely.
02:07:01 --> 02:07:06 [UNKNOWN]: But I think the budget has kind of just been disregarded at this point
02:07:07 --> 02:07:23 [UNKNOWN]: And hopefully, I mean, for all of, you know, that guy's the owner of that company, maybe if it is just you don't write a bit of a song on, do a witch song, Jeffrey Bezos, did you do okay?
02:07:23 --> 02:07:26 [UNKNOWN]: If it's just a feather in his cap and they do all five seasons, that's fine.
02:07:27 --> 02:07:28 [UNKNOWN]: Like we'll take it, right?
02:07:28 --> 02:07:29 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you, you're funny.
02:07:29 --> 02:07:30 [UNKNOWN]: I will.
02:07:30 --> 02:07:32 [UNKNOWN]: I will.
02:07:32 --> 02:07:34 [UNKNOWN]: Continuing on, did you notice?
02:07:34 --> 02:07:42 [UNKNOWN]: So I see your points about Bombadil, but Tom here, you're, I see your points about Bombadil, but Tom has grown on me after rewatches.
02:07:43 --> 02:07:48 [UNKNOWN]: I love the song and my or how many rewatches have you done, Jennifer Manche, like cranking out.
02:07:48 --> 02:07:49 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's crazy.
02:07:50 --> 02:07:56 [UNKNOWN]: And my ordinary Tolkien fan family is having great fun with the Winx to Star Wars, Peter Jackson's Lord of the Ring movies.
02:07:57 --> 02:07:59 [UNKNOWN]: Everyone conveniently forgets the hobby movies.
02:07:59 --> 02:08:00 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:08:01 --> 02:08:01 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:08:02 --> 02:08:05 [UNKNOWN]: I'm sure Jackson would like to forget the hobby movies himself.
02:08:06 --> 02:08:13 [UNKNOWN]: Did you notice in Sauron and Theo's discussion about evil that Sauron calls on what the wise say?
02:08:13 --> 02:08:20 [UNKNOWN]: I laughed out loud, given all the various levels of passionate lore slinging that has gone on around this show.
02:08:22 --> 02:08:33 [UNKNOWN]: As a community, we are so quick to jump on the lore that supports our desired outcomes that ignore both what Tolkien said, the wise said, and what the wise say in our lore community.
02:08:33 --> 02:08:37 [UNKNOWN]: I think, Marilyn, you're going to need to respond a little bit to that.
02:08:37 --> 02:08:38 [UNKNOWN]: I think you should physically fight.
02:08:38 --> 02:08:42 [UNKNOWN]: That's lean hot.
02:08:42 --> 02:08:43 [UNKNOWN]: I agree with her.
02:08:45 --> 02:08:51 [UNKNOWN]: I'm still wondering both how this show is defining the wise and how Tolkien himself find the wise.
02:08:51 --> 02:08:56 [UNKNOWN]: We talked about this a little bit or actually, I'm sorry, I'm conflating my Atherbeth class right now.
02:08:57 --> 02:09:03 [UNKNOWN]: But I think in both cases, it could just be a little bit of ignorance, you know?
02:09:04 --> 02:09:06 [UNKNOWN]: The wives have agreed this thought of a thing.
02:09:07 --> 02:09:09 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, so who were they?
02:09:10 --> 02:09:11 [UNKNOWN]: What makes them wise?
02:09:12 --> 02:09:15 [UNKNOWN]: Did we have a discussion, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
02:09:18 --> 02:09:38 [UNKNOWN]: For instance, I heard someone passionately going on about how Tolkien said that Pallando was what was doing in the East, but Pallando was the name used when the blue wizards were thought to have failed spectacularly by turning to evil cults in Dark Magic's.
02:09:49 --> 02:09:51 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you know Tolkien, he loves him a name.
02:09:52 --> 02:09:52 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
02:09:52 --> 02:09:56 [UNKNOWN]: And different character arc, different name.
02:09:57 --> 02:10:12 [UNKNOWN]: But it translates, and forgive me listeners, I know what translates into something like, defeated or evil, or Eastern Victor, or something along those lines.
02:10:12 --> 02:10:15 [UNKNOWN]: I'm just, as I say, a linguistics is not of my tree.
02:10:16 --> 02:10:19 [UNKNOWN]: It's been a long day and it's been a very long day.
02:10:21 --> 02:10:30 [UNKNOWN]: Um, looking back after four episodes, I agree with Marilyn that I don't think the faithful were supposed to be excellent at being spies or assassins, okay, taken.
02:10:31 --> 02:10:39 [UNKNOWN]: This was meant to be different from game of thrones and house of the dragon type, palace nastiness, especially with Earian.
02:10:39 --> 02:10:43 [UNKNOWN]: They're just people doing the best they could in a horrible situation and suffering actions.
02:10:44 --> 02:10:48 [UNKNOWN]: So, I will take the point and I think,
02:10:49 --> 02:11:09 [UNKNOWN]: as a regular viewer and television and these kinds of things, I'm probably piled and so and thinking of things in a certain way and so calibration wise and so good thing that there's a podcast we can all listen to to calibrate ourselves, that I wasn't calibrated for the
02:11:11 --> 02:11:27 [UNKNOWN]: new menorian naivete about these kinds of things and so that's that's a fair call on the fact that I'm looking at him like a game of throw like oh this is no one or like they're powerful smart and they're big they're whatever so fair point
02:11:29 --> 02:11:35 [UNKNOWN]: Uh, Maryland's reference to Bonhoeffer was a poignant reminder of this and it sets up.
02:11:36 --> 02:11:46 [UNKNOWN]: Our phyrazones, genocidal reaction, and honestly, I'm glad the writers didn't divert into minute spent on a more detailed or expanded spy and warfare story.
02:11:47 --> 02:11:48 [UNKNOWN]: Hey, man.
02:11:48 --> 02:11:48 [UNKNOWN]: Hey, man, sister.
02:11:49 --> 02:11:51 [UNKNOWN]: Marnouk around here in Galadriel.
02:11:52 --> 02:11:58 [UNKNOWN]: Yep, this was a member, Barry, but thanks to Nick Polk and Triple are over at Tolkien Pop.
02:11:58 --> 02:12:06 [UNKNOWN]: I am viewing this as the showrunners deliberately doing a mini-smiggle salmon photo storyline, but subverting it.
02:12:07 --> 02:12:19 [UNKNOWN]: Sam Arondier, Sam, also Arondier, admits he misinterpreted the situation and subtly apologizes and offers a significant gesture of trust.
02:12:19 --> 02:12:25 [UNKNOWN]: He does, and that's an interesting arc for Arondier, which we didn't really talk about was that hit his...
02:12:26 --> 02:12:34 [UNKNOWN]: his bonding with Marnook and going back to save him and actually develop and change.
02:12:34 --> 02:12:38 [UNKNOWN]: And that's actually a really important point in a glad that this has got brought up.
02:12:39 --> 02:12:41 [UNKNOWN]: Because Orandeard did change.
02:12:41 --> 02:12:43 [UNKNOWN]: He started out as a big kid.
02:12:43 --> 02:12:49 [UNKNOWN]: And he ended seeing that that he could be more than that.
02:12:50 --> 02:12:55 [UNKNOWN]: And I think the fact that he was challenged by the Latherdale saying you're grieving is affecting your judgment.
02:12:56 --> 02:12:580 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, gave him some interest in sight.
02:12:59 --> 02:13:00 [UNKNOWN]: We did not talk about that.
02:13:00 --> 02:13:03 [UNKNOWN]: That was a, that was a gut punch to, to a rendezvous.
02:13:04 --> 02:13:05 [UNKNOWN]: To have, it was.
02:13:05 --> 02:13:10 [UNKNOWN]: To have a, like you were saying before this legend.
02:13:11 --> 02:13:12 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
02:13:13 --> 02:13:15 [UNKNOWN]: See to you, bro, check yourself.
02:13:16 --> 02:13:17 [UNKNOWN]: I'm leaving you behind.
02:13:17 --> 02:13:18 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
02:13:18 --> 02:13:19 [UNKNOWN]: Hmm.
02:13:19 --> 02:13:19 [UNKNOWN]: That's it.
02:13:19 --> 02:13:22 [UNKNOWN]: Just be able to come back and say you were right.
02:13:22 --> 02:13:22 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
02:13:23 --> 02:13:25 [UNKNOWN]: I'll be the one to go in with the miracles on.
02:13:27 --> 02:13:27 [UNKNOWN]: I, with you.
02:13:29 --> 02:13:37 [UNKNOWN]: And then to be able to say, to go back for your comrade who happens to be an org.
02:13:37 --> 02:13:38 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
02:13:38 --> 02:13:38 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
02:13:39 --> 02:13:40 [UNKNOWN]: Because he did not betray them.
02:13:41 --> 02:13:41 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:13:42 --> 02:13:43 [UNKNOWN]: Spiegel Marnook does not betray them.
02:13:44 --> 02:13:48 [UNKNOWN]: And while the ending is tragic, we don't know if Marnook survived.
02:13:49 --> 02:13:52 [UNKNOWN]: Nenia is not captured or destroyed.
02:13:53 --> 02:13:56 [UNKNOWN]: Which, yeah, I don't think even Kelliborne knows that she has the ring.
02:13:56 --> 02:13:59 [UNKNOWN]: Does... No, this is... Not exclusively.
02:13:59 --> 02:14:07 [UNKNOWN]: I think in Lord of the Rings, it's made clear that the ring bearers can keep their ring from the section.
02:14:08 --> 02:14:08 [UNKNOWN]: Right.
02:14:09 --> 02:14:15 [UNKNOWN]: By everybody else, accept Frodo can see Galavittals' ring because he carries the one.
02:14:17 --> 02:14:25 [UNKNOWN]: Now, the one hasn't even been made yet, so there would be no sort of loophole there for anybody to see it if she wished it to remain unseen.
02:14:28 --> 02:14:35 [UNKNOWN]: So, but, but, but he did the right thing and just got them, uh, GTFed them, uh, out of there.
02:14:36 --> 02:14:36 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:14:37 --> 02:14:42 [UNKNOWN]: At one point, John, I think, described the show as like granola, but not in a good way.
02:14:46 --> 02:14:52 [UNKNOWN]: That said, I bet you someone's going to get the clip or something because they were like the 10th hour of this podcast.
02:14:53 --> 02:14:56 [UNKNOWN]: I can't be here, but yeah, you remember.
02:14:56 --> 02:14:59 [UNKNOWN]: So one, but you remembered Palando and go for it.
02:14:59 --> 02:15:01 [UNKNOWN]: Because I can remember a lore thing.
02:15:02 --> 02:15:04 [UNKNOWN]: But I, you want me to remember a joke.
02:15:04 --> 02:15:07 [UNKNOWN]: Why me, you know, I'm not, I'm not going to remember.
02:15:07 --> 02:15:09 [UNKNOWN]: We talk a lot of shit on the microphone.
02:15:09 --> 02:15:10 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yes, it gets, it goes right.
02:15:11 --> 02:15:14 [UNKNOWN]: You can't help but you're as well as for all the hot garbage that comes out of this mouth.
02:15:14 --> 02:15:16 [UNKNOWN]: especially Colonel at Garbage, right?
02:15:18 --> 02:15:23 [UNKNOWN]: Some hits he likes, some bits he just made the experience uneven and were hard to swallow.
02:15:24 --> 02:15:28 [UNKNOWN]: I was thinking that everyone who reads Tolkien gets something unique from the experience.
02:15:28 --> 02:15:35 [UNKNOWN]: This is not an original thought, shout out, to drought the tower and ruin and rev Tom Emmanuel,
02:15:43 --> 02:15:54 [UNKNOWN]: Well, the tower in the room is a fantastic book and it's written in the first person it talks about his own experience so I think listeners if you kind of pull back from heavy hitting more people
02:15:55 --> 02:15:56 [UNKNOWN]: Don't worry about it.
02:15:56 --> 02:16:04 [UNKNOWN]: Get this book and in fact I can even recommend to you get it on ebook because drought reads it himself.
02:16:05 --> 02:16:08 [UNKNOWN]: And he ties in the death of his son to talk.
02:16:09 --> 02:16:15 [UNKNOWN]: And it is one of the more moving and affecting pieces of literature about talking that I've ever read.
02:16:15 --> 02:16:16 [UNKNOWN]: So I highly recommend it.
02:16:18 --> 02:16:21 [UNKNOWN]: What creators often experience stories differently at different times in their lives?
02:16:21 --> 02:16:23 [UNKNOWN]: This is excellent point, Jennifer.
02:16:23 --> 02:16:26 [UNKNOWN]: Very true, because we're constantly changing.
02:16:26 --> 02:16:27 [UNKNOWN]: Detects stays the same.
02:16:27 --> 02:16:28 [UNKNOWN]: Mm-hmm.
02:16:28 --> 02:16:30 [UNKNOWN]: It's same like going back and watching a movie or TV show.
02:16:30 --> 02:16:32 [UNKNOWN]: Get any of these stories or titles.
02:16:32 --> 02:16:39 [UNKNOWN]: We are, I used to do a particular yoga practice that was set at same 26 poses every single day in and out.
02:16:40 --> 02:16:43 [UNKNOWN]: And that's the thing, you come to your practice every day.
02:16:43 --> 02:16:47 [UNKNOWN]: And like, oh, yesterday I did a couple of days ago, I did this pose just fine, and today I can't.
02:16:48 --> 02:16:50 [UNKNOWN]: That's because I'm coming to the pose.
02:16:50 --> 02:16:52 [UNKNOWN]: The pose is not changing.
02:16:52 --> 02:16:55 [UNKNOWN]: And you had something happen in your life between the two events.
02:16:57 --> 02:17:00 [UNKNOWN]: And that to me is the good kind of granola.
02:17:00 --> 02:17:02 [UNKNOWN]: There's always a milk product that I like.
02:17:03 --> 02:17:07 [UNKNOWN]: As the base note, but the crunchy bits are delightful variations
02:17:11 --> 02:17:16 [UNKNOWN]: She's being very Keardonian here, very sage-like in her interpretation of Grinola.
02:17:17 --> 02:17:20 [UNKNOWN]: PS, I adore the Nazgale.
02:17:20 --> 02:17:23 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you for bringing your diverse perspective to the show.
02:17:23 --> 02:17:31 [UNKNOWN]: Well, thank you for actually writing in and giving us some more to talk about, Jennifer, and I hope we hear for me some more during the season.
02:17:32 --> 02:17:33 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks, Jennifer, and love always.
02:17:34 --> 02:17:35 [UNKNOWN]: Who's gonna read Pele?
02:17:37 --> 02:17:39 [UNKNOWN]: I've read enough tonight, Marilyn.
02:17:39 --> 02:17:43 [UNKNOWN]: Okay, I'll read Pillay as long as you promise to do my little.
02:17:43 --> 02:17:43 [UNKNOWN]: I'll do it.
02:17:44 --> 02:17:44 [UNKNOWN]: I'll do it.
02:17:44 --> 02:17:45 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:17:45 --> 02:17:45 [UNKNOWN]: Okay.
02:17:45 --> 02:17:50 [UNKNOWN]: So, Pillay also known as plan buoyant gatekeeper, old friend of the pod.
02:17:50 --> 02:17:56 [UNKNOWN]: Hi there, a lot has happened in this episode, also given to understatements.
02:17:58 --> 02:18:05 [UNKNOWN]: Now that it's been revealed that Theo did become a ring servant, I can appreciate the use of the overplayed trope with seeing and teasing and unknown.
02:18:06 --> 02:18:08 [UNKNOWN]: Obviously, that's supposed to be Theo, ring servant.
02:18:09 --> 02:18:11 [UNKNOWN]: They played it so hard, I thought it was a fake out.
02:18:12 --> 02:18:18 [UNKNOWN]: Maybe I'm meaning too much met at a subpar writing, but I thought it was really clever to subvert the trope by not subriding it.
02:18:19 --> 02:18:19 [UNKNOWN]: Who knows?
02:18:20 --> 02:18:24 [UNKNOWN]: that brings us to the meat, and potatoes as it were, good and devoured.
02:18:25 --> 02:18:31 [UNKNOWN]: They obviously want us to believe Martinook is dead, but Saladron said specifically to leave him alive.
02:18:32 --> 02:18:37 [UNKNOWN]: I don't see Theo refusing his order like that, but perhaps that's a small act of rebellion.
02:18:37 --> 02:18:42 [UNKNOWN]: It's supposed to show Saladron doesn't have complete control yet, yeah, yeah, I remembered.
02:18:42 --> 02:18:47 [UNKNOWN]: All right, so there's a lot of folks are building a lot of evidence from Martinook
02:18:49 --> 02:18:52 [UNKNOWN]: a lot of internet points and cerebells being.
02:18:52 --> 02:18:52 [UNKNOWN]: Yes.
02:18:53 --> 02:18:53 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:18:54 --> 02:18:58 [UNKNOWN]: However, when Theo does kill Hawkeye, meaning have it on dear.
02:18:58 --> 02:19:01 [UNKNOWN]: This is another one of those nicknames you might not have written in before.
02:19:02 --> 02:19:03 [UNKNOWN]: Well, Hawkeye is an obscure character.
02:19:04 --> 02:19:04 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
02:19:04 --> 02:19:04 [UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
02:19:05 --> 02:19:07 [UNKNOWN]: He does so mechanically.
02:19:07 --> 02:19:13 [UNKNOWN]: And without hesitation in a way that's to me, suggest Saludon's word already has that controlling presence.
02:19:13 --> 02:19:15 [UNKNOWN]: I'd inquisitably, I think we're all down with that.
02:19:16 --> 02:19:19 [UNKNOWN]: That scene alone may be a question if he truly needs the one ring.
02:19:20 --> 02:19:21 [UNKNOWN]: Good point.
02:19:22 --> 02:19:23 [UNKNOWN]: Very good point.
02:19:23 --> 02:19:33 [UNKNOWN]: Of course, that's just with his quote-unquote ring servants who are wearing rings, but he wants to control not just them, but also the doors, and particularly the elves.
02:19:33 --> 02:19:36 [UNKNOWN]: So I think that is the real focus for one and a one ring.
02:19:37 --> 02:19:39 [UNKNOWN]: So the mission is a complete failure.
02:19:40 --> 02:19:40 [UNKNOWN]: This bit is dead.
02:19:41 --> 02:19:43 [UNKNOWN]: But, Sauron is a decorum answer.
02:19:44 --> 02:19:49 [UNKNOWN]: I think he'll be able to use the body as a conduit to get the Smith to spill beans.
02:19:50 --> 02:19:57 [UNKNOWN]: Modern look could actually be rewarded as well he toyed with Sauron and the end of the ruse got Sauron what he wanted.
02:19:58 --> 02:20:03 [UNKNOWN]: I think Sauron can respect that, even though he obviously can't trust him anymore.
02:20:03 --> 02:20:05 [UNKNOWN]: I don't know, I think if you can't trust him,
02:20:08 --> 02:20:08 [UNKNOWN]: off with him.
02:20:10 --> 02:20:11 [UNKNOWN]: Boy, howdy.
02:20:11 --> 02:20:16 [UNKNOWN]: In Cosa, do me get a classic miscommunication that borks everything up with what it's done.
02:20:20 --> 02:20:21 [UNKNOWN]: Revealing the truth.
02:20:23 --> 02:20:25 [UNKNOWN]: And activating the firebeard.
02:20:25 --> 02:20:28 [UNKNOWN]: I'm so tempted to do it a third time.
02:20:28 --> 02:20:29 [UNKNOWN]: Go for it.
02:20:29 --> 02:20:29 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:20:32 --> 02:20:35 [UNKNOWN]: I do wonder if the trail can't be retaken because the ritual wasn't done by the book.
02:20:36 --> 02:20:40 [UNKNOWN]: Dored and rushing thrying before the go ahead was given, can't be legal.
02:20:42 --> 02:20:44 [UNKNOWN]: And worried a boxing match the results wouldn't be accepted.
02:20:45 --> 02:20:48 [UNKNOWN]: Although, perhaps all that does is just qualify Dored anyway.
02:20:50 --> 02:20:50 [UNKNOWN]: I'll stop there.
02:20:51 --> 02:20:54 [UNKNOWN]: May the force be every in your walk to Mothhor and live prosper.
02:20:55 --> 02:20:57 [UNKNOWN]: I thought it was done, but alas.
02:20:57 --> 02:20:58 [UNKNOWN]: You haven't said it in a second email, see?
02:21:00 --> 02:21:04 [UNKNOWN]: I need some context for how big Nomenal Rias, yeah, yeah, thank you.
02:21:05 --> 02:21:07 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, they kind of messed with that, haven't they, Paley?
02:21:08 --> 02:21:16 [UNKNOWN]: It seems like a big place considering the complaints about teleportation, and that's sort of what I'm here to complain about, the recapture of Elendil.
02:21:17 --> 02:21:21 [UNKNOWN]: They must have had real guard armor just lying around in order to so quickly murder rescue.
02:21:22 --> 02:21:23 [UNKNOWN]: So how did this happen?
02:21:23 --> 02:21:25 [UNKNOWN]: How did they know what road to go down?
02:21:25 --> 02:21:28 [UNKNOWN]: Where did they get the armor and how did they catch up to the gun, boy?
02:21:30 --> 02:21:38 [UNKNOWN]: I would have accepted it if an audience wasn't among them, or if they had discussed a catastrophe planned if one of them was kidnapped before, and but no.
02:21:39 --> 02:21:49 [UNKNOWN]: We're supposed to believe an audience watched them drive away, put in an order with eagle shipping for Neumonolian armor, gathered a few guys and then rushed ahead, I don't buy it.
02:21:50 --> 02:21:57 [UNKNOWN]: There's at least one scene missing here, and given what we know about the lack of spycraft
02:22:00 --> 02:22:02 [UNKNOWN]: I think he's got some point here.
02:22:03 --> 02:22:04 [UNKNOWN]: Yeah, no.
02:22:04 --> 02:22:08 [UNKNOWN]: I don't think there's no argument about the short cutting of that scene.
02:22:09 --> 02:22:12 [UNKNOWN]: And anyway, nothing we can do about it.
02:22:12 --> 02:22:12 [UNKNOWN]: Yep.
02:22:15 --> 02:22:16 [UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:22:16 --> 02:22:16 [UNKNOWN]: That's it.
02:22:17 --> 02:22:17 [UNKNOWN]: We did it.
02:22:19 --> 02:22:20 [UNKNOWN]: We did it, folks.
02:22:21 --> 02:22:31 [UNKNOWN]: Don't forget, you can get even more content once we get our lower cast going now that we've caught up on the first four episodes on our season pass or as a regular subscriber.
02:22:31 --> 02:22:41 [UNKNOWN]: The season pass is 10 bucks for permanent access and if you're listening to the public feed and you had season pass for season two and you're thinking about coming back for season three, it's only nine bucks for you.
02:22:41 --> 02:22:43 [UNKNOWN]: You can you can you can head right on the
02:22:47 --> 02:22:57 [UNKNOWN]: And don't forget to get warm fuzzies for helping out a very cool podcast that's working it's tail off to bring you good content every day.
02:22:57 --> 02:23:01 [UNKNOWN]: You could donate to charity or you could, you know, support us talking about else.
02:23:02 --> 02:23:02 [UNKNOWN]: Why not both?
02:23:06 --> 02:23:08 [UNKNOWN]: All right, network news, we just didn't have a story yesterday.
02:23:09 --> 02:23:10 [UNKNOWN]: I thought we'd need to go through all this.
02:23:10 --> 02:23:16 [UNKNOWN]: First, he checks in Godzilla, Aliens, 40 of Vision Quest, Clayface, Blade Runner, 29, and all bunch of movies coming.
02:23:17 --> 02:23:22 [UNKNOWN]: Properly Howard, New Season, Dungeons & Doe Rags should be talking about rings of power coming up.
02:23:22 --> 02:23:30 [UNKNOWN]: They had a really good episode today on Godzilla minus zero, and our dear friends never mind the music, and definitely check out the NASCales.
02:23:32 --> 02:23:33 [UNKNOWN]: All righty.
02:23:34 --> 02:23:52 [UNKNOWN]: Thank yous, Marilyn, do you feel like a thank youer that I still have a voice, I still have a voice before, you know, while you pull up the thing, I'll just say That's what I wanted to do David.
02:23:52 --> 02:23:56 [UNKNOWN]: Yes, all the various, yeah, you're pulling out all the greatest hits.
02:23:57 --> 02:23:59 [UNKNOWN]: Well, next we need, uh, bocatan
02:24:03 --> 02:24:09 [UNKNOWN]: Look, if we get any more jetpacking and we have men that mean that we've got manalorians in the mix and then that's right, okay, that's right.
02:24:09 --> 02:24:10 [UNKNOWN]: All right, guys.
02:24:11 --> 02:24:12 [UNKNOWN]: I want to thank the community volunteers.
02:24:12 --> 02:24:13 [UNKNOWN]: Please do so.
02:24:13 --> 02:24:18 [UNKNOWN]: Starting with the student dying, hand to the pod, Nancy, aka two kids, two dogs.
02:24:19 --> 02:24:22 [UNKNOWN]: Master of the polls, Captain of the poll, here I'm Peter O'H.
02:24:23 --> 02:24:25 [UNKNOWN]: Keeper of the Show Tracker Sub-Zero.
02:24:25 --> 02:24:28 [UNKNOWN]: Laura Bririan, Brian 863.
02:24:28 --> 02:24:33 [UNKNOWN]: Moderators, Brian 863, Erin K. and Avaryon, aka the Hammer.
02:24:34 --> 02:24:36 [UNKNOWN]: Then we have the Faithful.
02:24:37 --> 02:24:39 [UNKNOWN]: First, our Discord server boosters.
02:24:40 --> 02:24:49 [UNKNOWN]: Erin K. Teller the Thriller, do 71, Athena Agilella, Lestu, Nancy M. Ghost of Partition, radioactive Richard, and Avaryon.
02:24:50 --> 02:24:53 [UNKNOWN]: And then we have the lore masters of mighty crew.
02:24:54 --> 02:25:00 [UNKNOWN]: Submarchant Michael G. Michelle E. S. C. Peter O. H. Nancy M. Do 71.
02:25:00 --> 02:25:01 [UNKNOWN]: Brian 863.
02:25:01 --> 02:25:05 [UNKNOWN]: Frederick H. Sarah L. Gareth C. Andreby.
02:25:05 --> 02:25:08 [UNKNOWN]: Quang U. Nathan T. Subzero.
02:25:08 --> 02:25:11 [UNKNOWN]: Aaron K. Dally V. Mothership C. D1.
02:25:12 --> 02:25:13 [UNKNOWN]: Charles?
02:25:14 --> 02:25:29 [UNKNOWN]: Kathy W, the Stu, Jeffrey B, Elisa U, Ben B, Scott F, Stephen N, Julia F. Calle S, Ilmariel, Rocky Zim, Jessica A, Red Zippy, the TCS, L&R, Mrs. Tenant.
02:25:29 --> 02:25:38 [UNKNOWN]: Isi Wilson, Eli W, Cassie K, Chumberoni, Katilak, Josh Liu, Paint in PDX, Cori G, Quinch,
02:25:41 --> 02:25:46 [UNKNOWN]: Cassandra C, Sandy B, Sarah Z, and last, but not least, Adrienne.
02:25:49 --> 02:25:54 [UNKNOWN]: Thank you everyone, and we'll see you on episode five.
02:25:56 --> 02:25:56 [UNKNOWN]: Good night, everybody.
02:25:57 --> 02:26:00 [UNKNOWN]: The Lorhound's podcast is produced in published by the Lorhound's.
02:26:01 --> 02:26:06 [UNKNOWN]: You can send questions and feedback and voicemails at the Lorhound's.com slash contact.
02:26:07 --> 02:26:11 [UNKNOWN]: Get early and add free access to all Lorhound's podcasts at patreon.com slash the Lorhound's.
02:26:12 --> 02:26:17 [UNKNOWN]: Any opinion stated are ours personally and do not reflect the opinion of or belong to any employers or other entities.
02:26:17 --> 02:26:18 [UNKNOWN]: Thanks for listening.